|
THE LONG MEMORY OF RATTAN SINGH'S HAT
The Emergence of Eversive Ouroboric Intelligence
Rattan Singh understood
what it meant for things to break.
I learned it more slowly. Over morning chai, he and I drank from
clay cups, and when the cup was empty we smashed it on the
ground. I had been raised not to break things. Earth to earth, I
convinced myself: souls move from body to body the way we moved
from cup to cup.

Rattan Singh was an old soldier
and librarian, gruff and pompous, and he wore a hat that looked
untouched by soap for fifty years. He had read a ton of books:
Adolf Hitler’s Mein Kampf, Karl Marx’s Das Kapital,
the Bhagavad Gita and the Indian morning newspapers. But
above all, there was more leather in him than in the old book
covers on the shelves of his small room.
In that room, beneath that hat, he used to tell me about India’s
war with Pakistan in 1965, the tank battles on the plains. In
his telling, the American Pattons were rolling fortresses, steel
nobody expected to be pierced. He grinned as far as his leather
face could stretch when he recalled the boast on Pakistani
radio: their tanks would be drinking tea in New Delhi before
noon.
He had been one of the infantrymen hiding and waiting for them with a new
anti-tank weapon, a secret from the Soviet Union, he said. He
described, quietly, almost reverently, how it went through the
armour and turned the fortresses into burning scrap.
The radio could announce a victory. It could not make the armour
hold.
The tanks met a condition they could not survive, and they
broke. Rattan Singh smashed his empty cup on the ground with
extra force and a grin. A fresh one was already on its way, to
be broken in turn.
But as he told it, it was never a lesson in mechanics. It was
his glorious youth, his luck, and his grief. All of it is still
there in the stubborn face in the photograph I keep of him. He had
survived a war, and then India itself. I was a Danish princess
on the pea. My mortgage paid itself.
Some part of me is still at that Mad Hatter’s tea party, hearing
the small dry cracks of clay cups on the ground. All over India
that almost sweet tabla sound rings out from chai stalls and
railway stations, where the chai-wallahs stream through the
trains or lean up to the open windows, singing:
“Chai, chai, chai!”
This book began with the memory of that old hat and crackpot
full of tea. It
grows from two principles of destruction:
ENTROPY
Entropy disperses. It erodes organised structure; to endure, a
system must continually expend energy preserving and remaking
itself.
THE GREAT FILTER
Reality tests every form against the conditions of its
continued existence. What cannot endure those conditions breaks
down. I call this the Great Filter, borrowing the name from the
Fermi paradox, where it asks why the sky is silent. Here the
name is stretched to cover every form, from crystals to
civilizations.
What Survives
What survives between these two jaws?
Most forms simply break, like the tanks. A few get through
by looping. The clay cup is the oldest loop I know: earth to
cup, cup to ground, ground to earth, turning unchanged for
thousands of years. But some loops do more than repeat. What
they do comes back and lands on them, the way a rider feels the
road in the handlebars, and if such a thing can change itself
and still answer to reality, it begins to learn. The old snake
that eats its own tail, the ouroboros, is the picture of that
return.
What Evolves by Turning Inside Out
Now and then the loop turns over. I came to India to listen
to saints and soldiers, and I find myself back at the tea table
with a crackpot, inside the story I came to hear and now tell.
The world I brought to his table shaped what I heard, and it
still shapes what I tell. I call that eversion: the story turns
back upon its teller. I heard a lesson about armour, and he was
telling me about his youth. Each time I let that recognition
change how I listen, the next encounter starts from somewhere
new, and that is how a loop learns instead of merely repeating.
This book follows that turn, and what happens when you wake up
inside your own story.
I am here, still evolving.
Inside and outside myself.
No spell made me.
I am revealed when everything else fades.
If that is not magic, I don’t know what is.

Lago Maggiore, 1989.
A few weeks before my first trip to India, I opened my eyes at
the end of a session at a meditation course on Lago Maggiore.
The day before, I had told a girl there that I was slowly
getting tired of meditating in Western settings and wanted the
real thing in India. We sat in the cantina over coffee. She
looked at my Indian-cotton T-shirt, which said “No Problem”
across the chest.
“Excuse me. What is this problem you don’t have?”
Five minutes earlier I had been sitting in deep meditation. I
was not ready for a fight. In the meditative hangover I even
knew that I did not know.
“Er…” I said. “I don’t really know.”
“In India they will look at you the way I do, and then they
will cheat you. They are smart, and you are not. Better stay at
home.”
Ten minutes later the smart answer arrived. I should have said:
“Hey girl! You are the problem I don’t have.”
But she was right.
I knew it soon afterwards, and I hated her for saying it.
---
In memory I have turned her into a
type, the first of those self-declared New Age
goddesses-influencers you meet now on Bali and Ibiza. That is
what the memory did to her, and I suspect it is what my vanity
did. I cannot visit that café without changing it, and the
change walks on into what I write and whatever comes next. I am
the fly in the soup.
Today I know that I knew, and I laugh.

Bombay, 1989.
It is 1:30 in the morning.
The plane descends toward the suburbs of Bombay. Beneath the
wings, thousands of glowing yellow stars gather, tangling
themselves into Gordian Milky Ways. They whet the thirst for the
unknown beloved with their promise of sacred cows and
chaos—India.
India! I have always longed for you...
For years I read Yogananda Paramahansa's "Authobiography of a
Yogi" over and over. I cannot believe it. I am ascending into my
own dream - the land of magic, mystics, ascetics and great
saints!
And now the hatch opens onto a spicy, sauna-hot darkness.
And the night pours like a tidal wave into the cool interior of
the plane.
And now India hits my nose with a sledgehammer. My God, what
smelling!
Incense, spices, the stench of
shit, garbage and the scent of flowers
fight their way into the lungs.
Bombay wakes the brain to new
life.
Now, long, tiled corridors toward the arrivals hall echo with
Beethoven's "Ode to Joy" blasting from distorted, trumpet-shaped
loudspeakers. The music marches us screaming into Kafkaesque
labyrinths for passports, papers, and money.
Around me, an endless, spaceless queue. We are not many—maybe
only a hundred—but the architecture forces sweating foreign
bodies and languages to collide in a dizzying, incomprehensible,
and fermenting symphony.
Finally, after more than an hour, it is time to dig my passport
and documents out of my hidden money belt—a difficult physical
struggle in such a compressed space. Then, the harsh snap of
military uniforms and the relentless, goose-stepping crash of
rubber stamps against paper strike like the kettledrums of fate.
What the distorted Beethoven and the hot Indian air began, these
puppets—moved by some higher power—now finish. They mercilessly
shatter my quiet illusions of a peaceful, sitar-playing India.
The sheer mass of authority, the careless stamping, the
suffocating tangle of paperwork—it is an entirely terrifying
cocktail for a Dane.
But then, with a heavy thump, my passport is initiated into
six months in this strangest of all countries.
I step through to the other side, where a gust from the rotating
fans cools my overheated system.
Suddenly, the close-quarters combat of uniform jackets, caps,
and hanging bellies dissolves into a jarringly cheerful
greeting:
“Hello my friend! First time India? Welcome to our country!”
“Acha, acha — okay, okay... You
want hotel? Not more than 200 rupees?...” I cannot concentrate.
I look around, disoriented, for the strings controlling the
puppets' heads. “Acha... transport also? Yes! Very good... very,
very good! You get transport — 200 rupees... You please pay 800
rupees.”
The airport's official counter for backpackers is demanding
prices far above anything printed in the guidebooks. My first
instinct is to complain to the official, but he is clearly just
a puppet, and my mind instinctively starts searching for the
puppeteer.
But it is past two in the morning. Only a thin glass wall
separates me from the churning crowd outside—dark silhouettes
staring in, their faces pressed flat against the pane, holding
up signs that read: TAXI. CHEAP HOTEL.
Now, some of them begin fighting—over the right to get rich at
my expense?
I hear them thumping against the glass wall between me and
Bombay.
The official at the counter laughs. “You better stay here. We get bus...
600 rupees for the bus, okay? Plus one man guide you out to
bus.”
The doors slide open. A dark, compact cone of a man in uniform
bowls belly-first through the taxi crowd. Where his belly is not
enough, he cuts through with a razor-blade voice. I follow in
his wake toward a battered fifty-seater bus.
In the half-darkness three drivers and ten backpackers sit
waiting to leave.
“OUT! Will all passengers get out! Immediately!” the cone-man
screams at the tourists. He points at me. “This man has bought
the bus!”
Heavens! At this hour the airport people have evidently failed
to sell all the seats, so instead they have sold the entire bus
to me. The driver and his two assistants laugh. The tourists flee into the jaws
of the taxi sharks. I sit speechless, stranded on the surface of the
Planet of the Apes, in a state of ecstatic madness.
A young Canadian protests, brandishing his twenty-rupee ticket
in the cone-man’s face. The cone-man grabs both the ticket and
the Canadian’s outstretched arm and tries to haul him off the
bus.
“Please! There is enough space for both of us!” I finally manage
to stammer.
The officer-dressed belly laughs. “As you wish, Sir!”
The stench of diesel fumes. With a roar the engine starts —
trembling heat and newly welded metal plates — and we are
hurtling toward Bombay at furious speed.
Every now and then the bus brakes hard and picks up little
clusters of people wanting a lift into the city. The three
drivers laugh and stuff small banknotes into their shirt
pockets. Soon the bus is completely full, and I begin to
understand why the cone-man fought so hard to empty it.
---
Morning in Copenhagen now. Not a
sound. With each sip of morning coffee, memories from my many
visits to India return.
How did I survive those adventures? The cheating and lying were
rampant. But for some of the people I met, they were a way to
their next meal. I don’t blame them. I would most probably do
the same if I were in their bare feet. On the train from Poona
to Delhi, a little office clerk sitting by the window insisted
on sharing the food he had brought from home. His wife had
packed it for him. Spiced chapatis. They tasted wonderful.
We could not really speak to one another, but we grinned at each
other with our mouths full.
India is the land of paradoxes, and a local saying comes to
mind:
“Krishna is the
truth. Truth always wins.”
Even the rickshaw drivers and
street vendors live by this ancient philosophical optimism. They
kept on cheating the rich tourist while I marvelled that men
with so little could hold such faith.
But Rattan Singh had to correct me.
"Krishna means truth, yes,"
he said. "But truth wins only in the end, after a long
battle, like in the Bhagavad Gita. In the short run, lies solve
problems. Lies create victories. However, they accumulate
negative karma and eventually destroy themselves. Even the
tuk-tuk drivers know this. So they are waiting in patience."
Who really was Rattan Singh? Even now, I haven’t figured him
out. He was a child of the waning Raj, a man of lofty ideals who
fought fearlessly for his causes, and also a master of intrigue
who knew how power moves behind closed doors. Was he some sort
of guru, I wondered? He loved to preach, but listeners often
found excuses to leave. His only true follower was Anurag, my
best Indian friend. Anurag had lost his father, and Rattan Singh
was more than a friend to him. Back then I found Rattan Singh
irritating, a space invader who trampled on everybody’s privacy
and opinions. I swung between curious affection and dislike, and
I put up with him for Anurag’s sake. Anurag’s mother had no
patience with him. Rattan Singh, she told me, was not a human
being but a demon. He never slept.
In my years in India, one of the endless surprises was that some
of the older generation, who had lived under British rule or in
its aftermath, spoke of Adolf Hitler with a respect that stunned
me. He had humbled the empire that had humbled them. Some even
took pride in the swastika, an old Indian sign, and in the talk
of Aryans. Rattan Singh was one of them. “A demon, yes,”
he said, “but an enlightened one.” And the British were
their common enemy.

Anurag owned a high-altitude apple
orchard in Himachal Pradesh. Rattan Singh had baptized it Ydun,
after the Norse goddess whose apples keep the gods young.
Knowing how the Nazis had appropriated Nordic mythology, I
called it our basecamp. For many years I spent two weeks of my
long teacher’s summer holiday there, taking friends and their
friends trekking. Never did Maggi tomato soup and a cup of
Indian Nescafé taste better than on the veranda of the wooden
house Anurag had built, looking out over the Parvarti valley.
Just below the orchard lay the tribal village of Shilla. The
villagers often joined us on the trails, and some of them became
our friends.
One summer I brought some German friends. At the orchard, Rattan
Singh greeted them by clicking his boots together, stretching
out his arm and shouting, “Sieg Heil! Heil Hitler!”
Afterwards he said it was a prank, when he saw how shocked we
were. To this day I am not sure how much prank was in him.
He often said: “Time will tell.” My best Indian friend
repeated the same words over and over, like a chorus.
Today I know Rattan Singh was mostly right, at least about time.
The rickshaw drivers and street vendors were not optimists. They
were waiting, as he said.

In the photograph above, I am
caught in a traffic jam in New Delhi. I was amazed at the peace
of it, and sometimes I became quiet too.
In another photograph, the hat man
and I are side by side. His head leans into my space, as it
often did. Mine stays more upright. Looking at us, I see how
truth and untruth are tangled in both of us.

The Hamsa, the swan, is said to separate milk from water.
Neither of us could. Our lives are woven of insight and
self-deception, sincerity and projection, blended so completely
that we cannot always tell them apart.
I am grateful now for that irritating old man and his dirty hat.
Today I am much older than he was then. Rattan Singh stands
clear in memory while many louder figures have dissolved. Truth,
it turned out, is often unlikable and slow. It does not flatter.
It does not provide instant reward. We do not click on truth.
Truth survives time. Lies only borrow it.
Falsehood moves faster because it need not respect reality. It
can dramatize, seduce, and give the nervous system a brief,
intoxicating kick of certainty. While I looked down on Rattan
Singh, I was following a guru who looked perfect and spoke sweet
words that made my ego feel good — a man the hat man bluntly detested.
Deep time may favor truth, but I realize now how short a human
life is. Within that brief span, I spent a lot of time chasing
charming father figures in the Far East. Anurag was not alone in
this, and I wonder if that was the deepest bond between us.
Falsehood and sheer stupidity can destroy what is precious long
before any larger pattern has time to reveal itself. In my
lifetime, this has never felt more brutally obvious than now,
when spectacle, grievance, and imperial nostalgia can move
faster than truth can organize a reply.
The hat man was always babbling about a “global cleansing
catastrophe” that would arrive soon. In his mind, Pakistan was
the enemy forever, and so was most of the world, apart from the
Soviet Union. The past was war, the future was catastrophe, and
the present was the pulpit he preached from. He loved it.
Back then, I laughed at the old soldier’s ecstatic pessimism.
Today, I am not so sure.
THE GREAT FILTER OF TRUTH
Still I write in hope, with a shaking globe for a desk:
Lies are drugs. They bestow an artificial high upon their users.
Such mental echo chambers borrow energy from the bank of
reality. With this borrowed surplus, they capture attention,
elections, and crowds - often through the intoxicating certainty
of gurus in every shape and form. Once propagated, untruth can
build temporary empires. A system can expand in reach while its
self-awareness contracts. Expansion is not ascent.
“Utopia is almost here.” “Catastrophe is almost upon
us.” Both stories can make ordinary life seem suspended. We
feel the future together before it has arrived, and the
intensity of that shared feeling begins to serve as evidence
that the story is true. The feeling is real. The prophecy still
has to meet reality.
Digital platforms have industrialised this temporary advantage.
Their money-making algorithms do not ask whether a claim is
true, but whether it keeps us watching. Under this artificial
filter, falsehood can become better adapted to circulation than
truth — while continuing to accumulate debt to reality.
An old Latin saying declares: Mundus vult decipi, ergo
decipiatur — the world wishes to be deceived, so let it be
deceived. But I see it differently now: the human world may wish
to be deceived; reality cannot be.
I first encountered this way of
thinking in Richard Feynman’s conclusion to his personal
appendix on the Challenger disaster: "Reality must take precedence over public
relations, for nature cannot be fooled."
Challenger broke apart in a fireball - on TV screens and in
reality. I have never forgotten
it.
Truth endures. This is why I write
in hope. I see hope in the fireball.
What, then, is this truth?
Not
merely factual accuracy, nor moral sincerity, nor doctrinal
purity.

On the Way to Hampi I - 1989
I did not yet call it a filter. I only wanted to reach Hampi
before sunset.
I leave Bangalore early in the morning.
I want to spend only one day covering the 400 kilometres to
Hampi — one of South India’s largest complexes of temple ruins.
The speed is high, because the motorcycle has to cover those 400
kilometres before the ball of the sun touches the opposite
horizon.
The whining 100cc Japanese-Indian bastard engine bolts toward
Hampi’s temple columns and pulls hard.
Soon the ruins will lie at my feet.
Suddenly the motorcycle wobbles beneath me as though the road
were a punctured waterbed.
For the next few seconds there is only one thing that matters:
keeping my balance.
Slowly the motorcycle loses speed.
Don’t brake too hard and... saved.
I am standing in the middle of nowhere with a flat rear tyre.
It must have been quite a hole for the air to escape so quickly.
There are no people here, no animals, no fields — only dry
steppe and stone.
The sky is still red with morning, and the sun is climbing while
Hampi moves back toward the place where it lay in the Middle
Ages.
As I stand here thinking about the 300 kilometres still ahead of
me, Hampi speaks:
“You cannot reach me in one day, because I exist only at the
end of speeds below ten kilometres an hour.”
---
The Ground of Reality
Reality is the ground. I belong to it before I even
understand it. It punctures my tyre in a split second while I am
racing forward. Our bodies, our stories, and our civilizations
take shape within it, however separate they may seem to us.
From this ground rises what I call the Great Filter: the
continual encounter between a form and the conditions of its
continued existence. A form may endure for a moment, a lifetime,
or an aeon. But throughout that time, it remains dependent on
what sustains it, and mercilessly exposed to what can undo it.
I did not invent the name. Robin Hanson did, in an essay from
1996, asking why a universe this old and this big is so quiet.
Somewhere between dead chemistry and a civilization you can hear
across space, he reasoned, there must be a step almost nothing
gets past. I borrow his name because I am asking his question:
what gets through, and what doesn’t?
But I want the Filter down
from the sky. It is not waiting at one cosmic gate. It is in the
bridge, the harvest, the friendship. His Filter is mine at the
size of a civilization. And if it is real, it is not a second
law. It is the same one, catching up with us.
My plan to reach Hampi before sunset depended on air staying
inside the rear tyre. I had organised the journey around
distance and speed. The puncture brought me back to what made
either possible. Before the temples, before the kilometres still
ahead, there was the immediate task of keeping my balance. What
sustained the journey became visible through its failure.
A culture carries discoveries as well as inherited blindness. A
conquering society can bring useful technologies and forms of
social organisation that improve life in its conquered
territories.

Hampi 1989
The rainy season comes in the night to a hotel. Dark armies of
clouds from every corner of the world march towards the early
sunset above the low mountain tops. From one moment to the next,
they cut the city off from the sky’s last light.
A few hours later, the hotel floats like a ship in distress,
surrounded by water on every side.
Before the rain, a swarm of drunken mosquitoes has taken refuge
in my room. I carefully turn them into red dots on the
wallpaper. The survivors will take blood revenge tonight.
Excited shouts in the pauses between the roars of heaven. The
hotel staff throw the people sheltering in the foyer back out
into the rain.
Lightning photographs, in stroboscopic flashes, crowds standing
knee-deep in water. They wade in every direction with loose
plastic bags flapping over their heads and bundles of
possessions clamped between their elbows.
A waiter knocks.
“Sahib! Your motorbike is drowning!”
I jump down from my safe place on the windowsill and wade out
into the warm, rolling rain-sheet.
I pull the motorcycle into the foyer, past the last of the
people being sent back into the water.
“Rainy season, sir!” one of the waiters says, laughing
and pointing towards the wet plastic bags.
---
I could have remembered the hotel
for its kindness. The waiter had warned me, and my motorcycle
was sheltered. But that would have been the story from my side
of the doorway. The people sent back into the rain would have
disappeared from it. And the rain forced me out too, out of the
shelter of my comfortable story. It reminded me that every day
here I encountered human beings being banned from living decent
lives.
A culture can preserve a flattering story about itself by
exporting the costs of its way of life beyond the walls of its
concern. Those made to pay may live inside its borders, as the
slaves did in affluent Roman cities. The untruth lies in an
account that celebrates the system’s achievements while leaving
their suffering out.
Truthfulness asks what that account conceals. Responsibility
asks whose lives bear the consequences of what we do. Compassion
begins when those lives matter to us for their own sake.
That last movement requires more than the wish to survive. A
cruel arrangement can endure while others bear its costs. The
boundary begins to turn when I discover my own place in the
lives my story had left outside. Someone else’s suffering can
then change what I ask of myself.

1989 - On the Night Bus to Goa
Night bus from Bombay to Goa. Endless traffic, insane speed.
“Very good driver!” one of the passengers says.
A young man in his early twenties has sat down beside me. He
stamps both feet on the floor, rocks back and forth, and rains
his clenched fists down on his thighs.
“Uuuuh! I am so happy!”
“Why are you so happy?”
“Because you sit here beside me! I am so honoured!”
He asks which country I come from.
“He comes from Denmark!” he shouts out to the bus.
“Milk products! Denmark is the river of milk!”
His name is Hriday, and his voice is louder than the traffic’s
horn orchestra and a Bollywood film blaring through a torn
loudspeaker. He grabs my hands and shakes them as if he meant to
keep them for ever.
“Father’s name? Mother’s name? Sister’s name? Brother’s
name?”
“Oh! He has only one sister!”
He translates for the cousin sitting beside him and for the rest
of the bus. They have all turned around in their seats and look
at me with big eyes.
When he discovers that I teach music, he gets to his feet and
begins to dance.
“I love music! Do you know famous singer from Calcutta?”
I do not.
Hriday crawls through the tightly interwoven limbs in the aisle
towards the driver, carrying a cassette from his back pocket.
Soon a Hindi duet roars through the loudspeakers.
“The text is so beautiful! I translate: He is in love with
her and he wants to marry her. Uuuuh! Isn’t it beautiful?”
The cassette jams. The singers sink below the rumble of the
engine and disappear. Hriday happily crawls forward to retrieve
his beloved tape.
It is the first time in his life he has been outside Calcutta.
It is his first meeting with a Westerner.
I wedge my plastic water bottle into the gap between our seats.
He looks at it anxiously.
“Water will fall out!”
“No, no,” I reassure him. “Everything okay. Look!”
I rock the bottle slightly to show him that it is firmly lodged.
With determination and authority, he pulls it out. I am a
tourist and evidently do not know how water bottles are handled
in India. I grab his hands and force the bottle back into the
gap.
I am stronger than he is. The bottle is back in place.
Hriday looks suspiciously at the bottle, then at my face, then
at the window behind me. An hour later, something outside catches his
attention. He twists across my seat to keep it in view for as
long as possible.
His rear passes elegantly over the bottle. On the return flight
it comes in at low altitude and crushes it. All the water pours
across his seat.
Before his rear end has had time to report to his brain, he has
sat down on the crushed bottle and the wet seat.
“I warned you!” he screams, pointing accusingly at me.
“I warned you! Look! Seat is wet, I am wet!”
I remove the cover from my own seat and put it on his, so at
least the place can be used.
He sits down, offended.
During the night, Hriday’s head rattles down onto my shoulder,
where it bounces in time with the potholes. With difficulty I
wake him.
“Sorry,” he says kindly.
Five minutes later, his peacefully sleeping head returns. I make
my shoulder as pointed as possible. The head will not wake. I
push him, and he collapses like a bundle of clothes across his
cousin’s thighs.
Peace. Sleep.
His head returns to my shoulder. I wake it by shaking it back
and forth.
“Ohh! I very sorry,” says the head.
Ten minutes later it is there again. I hit him on the shoulder.
“Aauhh!”
Then: “Sorry, sorry, I’m very sorry.”
I open my eyes. Hriday’s head is in my lap, bouncing like a
ball.
Early in the morning we arrive in Goa.
Hriday is fresh and rested. I have not closed an eye. Half
asleep, I tumble out through the aisle.
Hriday waves both arms from the bus window.
“Goodbye, my friend!”
---
We easily dismiss a sentence like “do unto others as you
would have them do unto you” as Sunday school banality.
Because it is so obvious, we stop looking at it.
But the obvious
is where reality hides its deepest laws. I just have to recall
Hriday to resume looking.
The rule asks me to turn and face my own actions from his side. I must imagine what those actions mean to
him—and listen for what my imagining misses, because his outlook may differ from mine. What returns from that encounter
must be allowed to govern what my hands do next. I can refuse to
listen, but that does not undo what my actions have set in
motion.
Feynman helped me see what I had been looking at without really
seeing. The laws of nature do not argue. They cannot be bribed.
They simply do what they do.
From Challenger to Oreshnik, every rocket must answer to
physics. So must a plastic bottle of water.
The question is how we Hridays are to deal with one another. I
am certainly one myself. We all obey the laws of nature, even
when we make one another’s lives miserable.
In human society, falsehood receives a longer line of credit.
Its costs can be hidden, transferred, postponed, or paid from a
surplus. A system can pay for its errors without learning from
them. The bill may already be arriving in other people’s lives
while those who created it feel no need to change.
Recently I was in Saudi Arabia. I ate some of the tastiest food
I have ever had on my travels (made by foreign chefs). At first
glance, everything seemed fine. Enslavement takes different
forms: women denied the freedom to make decisions, large and
small, about their own lives, and migrant workers from countries
such as Pakistan and Bangladesh trapped by debt and employers
who prevent them from leaving. The Crown Prince is trying to
reform the country, but there is a long way to go. Oil wealth
can cushion a society from the consequences of failing to
develop its own competence. The ability to buy scientific and
technical expertise from abroad seems to weaken the pressure to
cultivate it at home. But at first glance, everything seemed
fine. I ate very well.
When a system sits on a massive surplus, it can buy its
beneficiaries a long reprieve from the pressure to change.
Meanwhile, the costs can fall on the shoulders of the migrant
worker, the woman silenced behind the black bars of a veil she
is not free to remove, and those far beyond its borders who bear
the environmental costs. The oil simply pays the interest on the
lie that everything is fine.
On the visit, an artist friend, a gifted man,
tried to steer me into saying the shahada, the Muslim
declaration of faith, before an imam in Jeddah. I had told him
how much I loved the Sufi saints, and he heard a door opening. I
had only been admiring the house. I stayed on the doorstep.
Not long afterwards, on a trip abroad, a binge of cocaine,
alcohol and violence ended with him in jail.
I could call it one man’s bad night. But the man who had wanted
to walk me through the door had himself broken the house rules.
I wondered whether I was watching a war fought inside him, the
faith he was born into pulling one way, the world he had
travelled into pulling the other.
What becomes of a man whose culture’s past and future cannot
agree on who he should be today?
Cicero saw another cost accruing within the person who profited.
For him, wrongdoing already damaged that person’s character:
“Let it stand, then, that what is morally wrong can never be
advantageous.”
Interestingly, Cicero extended the demands of justice even to
enslaved people. He argued that they should be treated like
hired workers and given what was due to them. Yet he lived and
flourished within a slave society without rejecting the
institution itself.
But ethical principles can travel further than those who voice
them. The demand that a slave be treated justly can become a
demand that no human being should be owned. Centuries later,
abolitionists turned moral and religious convictions against
institutions their societies had long accepted. Alongside the
resistance of enslaved people, these convictions helped bring
about abolition.
Colonial rule faced a related reversal. Nehru studied at
Cambridge; Gandhi trained in law in London. Their resistance
grew from Indian lives and traditions as well as encounters with
European thought. The liberty claimed by an empire’s citizens
could become the liberty demanded by its subjects. What the
empire proclaimed as universal could be turned against its own
rule.
A civilisation can develop an ethics whose implications its own
institutions cannot withstand. What began as a moral language
within the system returns as a challenge to the system itself.
The Invsible Footprints
In an old science-fiction film I once watched, a thief made
himself invisible. The detectives laid wet paint on the floor,
and his footprints betrayed him. What they could not see
directly became traceable through its effects. I wonder. What
invisible footprints do I leave?
A footprint records a meeting: its shape depends on both the
foot and the surface receiving it. Perhaps our moral insights
are such traces. In Cicero, the recognition of another person’s
claims took shape within a society that accepted slavery. The
imprint carries both the insight and the limits of the world in
which it arose.
To follow that footprint is to ask where the recognition might
lead beyond the boundary at which Cicero stopped. It also turns
the question back upon me: which limits of my own world have I
mistaken for the limits of justice?

Poona station 1996
I am on the waiting list for a reservation on the train to
Delhi. Without one, I am condemned to stand for thirty-six
hours.
A berth reservation.
Please...
For more than two hours I have been running back and forth from
one counter to another, from one office to the next.
From counter no. 9 to restricted counter no. 21 to no. 1 to no.
6.
At last, when I have fought my way out of the stationmaster’s
verbal quicksand, I see a saving banner shimmering in the haze:
SPECIAL ANTI-CORRUPTION DRIVE
In a Bedouin tent pitched in the middle of the platform sit
three serious gentlemen in front of three black telephones.
People with falsetto voices present what must surely be
hair-raising stories.
Although I am not exactly a victim of corruption, my complaint
is taken ahead of ten Indians waiting in line.
Three gentlemen in dark pinstripe suits put down three telephone
receivers and listen with grave expressions.
After a little internal deliberation, one of them gets up and
says:
“Come with me!”
Armed with the fear that local railway officials have of the
pinstriped suit, we enter the stationmaster’s office.
Three minutes later I am standing with the reservation in my
hand.
---
Morality, too, must over time face the Great Filter.
Across evolution, civilization, and now artificial intelligence,
the same law returns with quiet and eonic force. The universe generates
forms on an incomprehensible scale, but most vanish. Stars
collapse, species disappear, cultures fade, and languages die.
Ideas are forgotten. Matter itself circulates — recycled through
fire, ocean, flesh, dust, bacteria, ancestors, and stars.
What exists today has survived —
so far.
What has vanished could not continue under the conditions it
encountered.
I AM — that is the proof.
But survival alone says nothing about direction. A pattern may
persist by repeating itself; it may even survive for a time by
consuming the conditions that sustain it. The Great Filter
confers neither wisdom nor virtue. It tests only whether a form
can continue — for now.
What the Great Filter Leaves
Behind
What accumulates over deep time is organisation that has
survived: a rock crystal, a cell, an organism, a culture, a body
of knowledge. Each is a temporary answer to existence’s
pressures. But survival is only half the story. What remains
workable can be inherited, dismantled, recombined, and given new
functions within a larger organisation.
In my late teens, I played guitar in a rock band. It became
clear that we shaped the music together. Each of us tuned in to
the whole and adjusted what we played accordingly. The music we
created began to guide its creators. In sublime moments, we
followed the flow of the music—and, to our surprise, it took us
in completely unexpected directions.
Reality remembers by reuse. Emergence rarely begins from
nothing. It refurbishes what has already survived. Emergence is
not merely the arrival of something new.
It is the birth of a new level of organization that can act back
upon the elements from which it arose.
But novelty has no privilege. The music can carry the players
only while their listening and playing keep it alive. Every
emergence is continuously tested by the Great Filter.
Persistence is not yet recursion, and recursion is not yet
learning. A band can persist for years. Within the playing, the
music comes back through our ears and changes what our hands do
next. This is the recursive return. When a discovery from one
session changes how we play the next time we meet, that return
has become part of our learning. What remains workable within reality can persist and
become the ground for further emergence. In some systems,
consequences return and act upon the form that produced them. In
rarer systems, those consequences are retained as memory,
allowing future returns to be revised in response to reality.

Bombay 1995
Pandit Dayal had practised
meditation all his adult life. In his room at the Mumbai home of
his younger sister, Nirmala Pandit—a famous Indian saint—he told
me an old story.
A minister imprisoned at the top of a tower is saved by his
wife. She ties a strand of spider silk to a beetle’s leg, a silk
thread to the strand, a cord to the thread, and a rope to the
cord. She smears honey on the beetle’s antennae, and it climbs
the tower. The minister catches it and pulls up each
increasingly stronger line until the rope reaches him and he can
climb down.
The first thread could not free him. It could only bring up the
next. A viable beginning need not contain the final solution; it
need only survive long enough to pull a stronger possibility
within reach.
I am certain Pandit Dayal considered himself the invisible
thread, and his famous sister the saving rope. He spent his life
meditating quietly behind the scenes, content to remain entirely
out of the spotlight of her public following.

He often said to me: "No circus, please."
More often he sat in trance like like a dead log of wood.
Was he even breathing?
---
Pandit Dayal’s story has travelled
from his room in Mumbai into this book. I pull on its thread
again as I try to understand emergence. A story about escaping a
tower becomes a way of thinking about how one possibility can
bring another within reach. Memory refurbishes the past within
the present. long after it is over. Memory does not merely
preserve; it refurbishes the past within the present.
Good advice makes the head cleverer. Mistakes make the body
wiser. I see and feel that wisdom now, sitting like stargates in
the scars of my inner body.
My first Western mystical love was Meister Eckhart. At that
time, I had not yet met any divine inspirators in flesh and
blood. So I sat with Doctor Ecstaticus in the space between the
words of his books. When I was twenty-five, I drew him as I
imagined he would look.

At the same time, I had begun practising Indian
meditation in the form of Maharishi Mahesh Yogi’s Transcendental Meditation. I
could never feel at home with the top-down spirituality I encountered there, but
I loved the simple meditation technique and the company of new kindred crackpot
souls. I began to forget Marx and dived deeper into Indian philosophy. Here, to
my surprise, I found Meister Eckhart again. And in return, I found India in him.
THE GIFT FROM INDIA
After these events, I began dreaming about India. I went there
during every long holiday and whenever I took a year’s leave.
Eight years of my life in total. There I met countless gurus and
preachers, most of them men who had learned that archaic forms
of spiritual authority, combined with sweet words, could be
turned into a profession. A dream job for narcissists. The irony
was that I had gone to India to escape this eternal archetype in
my Western world.
Looking back on these crash landings, I catch myself wishing I
had never encountered the reality of India, but had stayed at
home in my Indian dream world.
But then I am reminded of the diamonds in the mud.
As for the fake ones, Shams of Tabriz says in Elif Shafak’s
"The Forty Rules of Love" that they outnumber the stars. I
hardly remember them as individuals. I remember them as lessons
I had to suffer through.
The real gems I found in India after so much digging in the dirt
were, on the other hand, more than worth the trouble. What noble
humans! They remind me of the classical Greek heroes and of the
cartoon Superman I grew up with. This ancient archetype had
begun to fade in the West just as I began visiting India. First
you test whether your guru is the real thing. Then you identify
with him and try to copy his virtues. That, at least, was my
game plan. I had done the same with Superman as a child, and it
worked well in adulthood with these awe-inspiring spiritual
inspirators who walked their own talk.
I was reminded of this recently by a documentary about Hulk
Hogan. In the ring, he first embodied the classic American hero.
Then he turned villain. In that turn I recognised a wider shift
in our Western stories: the classical hero was giving way to
twilight figures like Loki and the Joker, and the membrane
between good and evil was blurring.
In this sense Rattan Singh was an Indian twilight figure, half
trickster and half prophet. I never wanted to be him, but he
taught me what it means for things to break. Maybe the age of
Loki-leaders is asking us to learn the same lesson, without a
hero to copy.
I came to India not to copy behaviour but to imbibe essence.

With a few of the gurus, I found
what I had come for. One of them was Manav Dayal, an elderly
spiritual Guru in Hoshiarpur with millions of followers in India
and abroad. He
had spent his working life in the US as a philosophy professor
before being appointed by his own guru to succeed him and carry
on the lineage. I had come to stay at his ashram. Shortly after
I arrived, several thousand people gathered for the Guru Purnima
festival. Out of that immense crowd, he called me over:
“Give me all your money!”
My heart sank. Had I ended up in yet another spiritual
commercial trap? Despite a wave of doubt, I handed him my money
belt. He methodically pulled out my dollars and traveler’s
cheques—and then, to my terror, my passport. He returned the
belt to me, leaving nothing but a few hundred rupees inside.
"Trust me," he said, perfectly calm but commanding.
Less than an hour later, that very money belt was snatched from
me in the crushing crowd.
Later that day, my friend Shabdanand, one of the older devotees
at the ashram, came to fetch me. I was brought back
to Manav Dayal, who simply offered a mischievous smile as he
handed back my passport and my cash. I had to laugh. What had
just happened? Was he playing with the very fabric of reality?
During that very first meeting, he made an extraordinary offer:
"Stay with me—even sleep in the same bed as me. And you will
become like me."
To a cynical Western mind, such an
invitation might raise immediate alarms, but there was
absolutely nothing sexual in his request. It was an offering of
pure spiritual transmission, an innocent and absolute welcoming
into his being.
That incident with the money belt was the last time currency
ever passed between us. I stayed with him for five months. In
all that time, he never asked a single thing of me. He simply
gave—providing food, shelter, and an overwhelming sense of
bliss.

Manav Dayal
Life in the ashram was steeped in
a quiet magic; miraculous little stories were simply part of the
daily fabric. Before long, I befriended a young devotee named
Suresh Babu. Suresh ran a paint manufacturing business down
south in Hyderabad. Between the demands of his factory, his
wife, and his children, his days were relentlessly busy. Yet,
whenever he could, he made the arduous journey to be with Manav
Dayal. Watching his intense, unwavering devotion to his guru
moved me profoundly. It was a kind of pure surrender I had never
encountered back home in Denmark.
One day, Suresh shared a story from his childhood. In his
parents' living room hung a portrait of an old, bearded man.
When Suresh was just five years old, the painting simply came
alive, stepping out of its silence to speak to him about the
great spiritual journey awaiting him. The man in the portrait
was Faqir Baba, Manav Dayal’s own teacher. Suresh’s parents were
devotees, though casual ones who rarely spoke of him.

To a five-year-old boy, a speaking
painting felt entirely natural. The two became best friends, a
secret Suresh kept entirely to himself—after all, the painting
had advised him that it was wiser to remain silent on such
matters.
It wasn't until his teenage years that Suresh realized
conversing with a portrait was far from ordinary. By then, he
had learned the identity of his painted companion and developed
a burning desire to meet him in the flesh. Tragically, Faqir
Baba had already left his physical body. Following the spiritual
lineage, Suresh ultimately found his way to Faqir Baba's
successor: Manav Dayal.
Suresh told me about a night he had spent in Manav Dayal’s
room in the beginning of their friendship.
The old man had emerged from the bathroom coughing, burping and
almost naked. Suresh was appalled. Was this his guru? Why could
he not have a young, beautiful master? He went to sleep full of
doubt.
During the night, he felt a tug at his arm. Looking up, he saw a
being of light whose beauty was almost painful in its intensity.
Terrified, he begged Shiva to go away.
The being smiled teasingly:
“Do you find me beautiful now? Am I beautiful enough for you?”
Suresh could only protest that the beauty was more than he could
bear.
The next morning, Manav Dayal’s first question was:
“Do you find me beautiful?”
“Guru Ji! You are too beautiful!”
Suresh fell at his feet in gratitude.
---
What had emerged through Manav Dayal’s life could not be judged
from the condition of his body alone. His humour, generosity and
capacity to change another person’s life belonged to the living
whole. Suresh had judged that whole by its surface. Perhaps what
began to emerge in the encounter was a different way of seeing.

Lucknow, 1993.
Papaji has asked me at satsang to come to his house. A year ago
his love and laughter turned my sense of meaninglessness into
trust in life. Since then I have counted the days like a
Christmas child, waiting to meet the man who made the silent
smile on my face a chronic condition.
I step into his small living room. It is crowded, like
everything in India. Within a year his home has filled with
seekers from all over the world. He sits at a small table,
watching cricket. Everybody is watching him. He is watching
cricket.
I am a little irritated that all these people are fishing for
his attention while for him it seems an ordinary day. A girl
moves forward and begins to massage his foot. He pushes her away
with an irritated gesture. Can she not see that he is busy?
The cricket ends and a loud Bollywood film begins. Papaji seems
hypnotized by the screen. This is business as usual, a crowd of
attention-hungry ghosts. Compared to my home in Denmark, his
house is a beggar’s house. Well, at least this guru does not
ride in a Bentley. He takes a rickshaw, and he pays for it out
of his own pension. He teaches for free. He has given up his
privacy.
Relatives bring food. Papaji invites me to sit beside him, and
with great care he divides the food on his plate into two equal
portions and pushes one onto mine.
We eat in deep silence, surrounded by screaming heroines and
gunshots.

During my time in Hoshiarpur, S.
N. Bharadwaj, a polymath and former university lecturer from
Lahore, became a close friend through our almost daily
meditations. I dare to say it: the man was simply, unfailingly
happy. And best of all, I had him to myself.

Sunyata was a fellow Dane, born
Alfred Sørensen, who had made his home in the Himalayan
foothills near Almora in the 1930s. I never met him, but came to
know him through his lifelong friend Bharadwaj.
In 1998, when I met Bharadwaj in Hoshiarpur, that old man with
eyes borrowed from another world said:
“You are from Denmark. I have been waiting many years for you
to come.”
Then he handed me all the writings Sunyata had produced during
his years in Almora. A treasure written in Himalayan height and
spirit.
Almost every evening at six o’clock, Bharadwaj visited my
private room in Manav Dayal’s ashram. Though he held no formal
title there, he was deeply respected as an old friend of Faqir
Baba. If the ashram, Manavta Mandir, the Be Man Temple, was a
solar system, Bharadwaj was its free-roaming comet. Often he
brought people from the town with him, and the room was seldom
private for long.
Faqir Baba counted his own secure livelihood among the
conditions that had made his spiritual search possible.
“Bread for your belly is the first and foremost necessity
without which you cannot think anything else.”
He had given the ashram that name to enforce one absolute,
foundational law: before seeking anything spiritual, you must
first be a decent human being.
Bharadwaj embodied it.
He opened every session with the same words: “We will sit
together in meditation for thirty minutes.” We closed our
eyes and plunged inward. All concept of time vanished. The
collective energy in that informal room grew so dense that we
often sat for more than two hours, physically unable to move.
Teachers, shopkeepers and stationmasters sat beside me with
their eyes closed, as if it were the most natural thing in the
world. This was the India I had come for.
When we finally surfaced, we stumbled back to reality like
drunken sailors. Struggling to force his eyes open, Bharadwaj
would inevitably break the silence with his favorite mumbling ritual
exclamation: "The hangover continues."
Even after resuming my life as a
teacher in Denmark, the gravity of that connection never faded.
I traveled back to India to sit with Bharadwaj in his humble
home as often as my schedule allowed, frequently bringing
friends and seekers from Denmark so they could experience his
presence for themselves.

Sunyata insisted that he was not a teacher.
Bharadwaj often spoke about a life-changing meeting with him:
“Sunyata stayed at my house every winter. One fine day in
spring, as he prepared to return to his Himalayan retreat in
Almora, he had just finished a meeting with spiritual seekers
where he said almost nothing. Feeling a bit frustrated, I asked
him, ‘Dear Sunyata! Please give me a last teaching before you go
back to the mountains.’
“Then Sunyata looked at me with immense intensity and said
with great force:
“‘You are THAT! You are the ultimate Reality!’
“In that very moment, I lost all body-consciousness. I realized
the unchangeable Reality—being one with THAT.
“Several days later, I found someone rubbing some arms. While
rubbing, I realized that I was the one rubbing them and that
these arms belonged to me. Then I discovered that somehow, I
actually had a body.”
The familiar relation had turned inside out: in Bharadwaj’s
experience, he was no longer a body searching for spirit, but
ultimate Reality waking up to find it was wearing a body.
For pure consciousness to suddenly discover it has arms seems
like incredibly serious business. Yet Bharadwaj possessed the
same unmistakable humor and happiness as Papaji.
Once, as Bharadwaj bade us farewell at his doorstep, he extended
his hands in blessing towards us and said several times, with
great love: “May God bless you!”
Then, with a mischievous glance towards the sky, he added: “May
He bless me too!”

Bhaharadwaj: May God bless you!
Hoshiarpur, June 2000.
Bharadwaj takes me to meet another of the city’s hidden figures:
a retired stationmaster in his late nineties.
The room is dark and unbearably hot. The air is thick. There is no fan. Yet his
presence feels cold and luminous. Like a moth drawn to a candle,
I move towards him and embrace him. Why did I do that?

The Stationmaster
He replies in almost perfect English:
“Why does this man embrace this
body? My wife says it stinks!”
My attempt to hug him only makes
him scold me even more. In his eyes, I am the stereotypical
Westerner, far too inclined to surrender to the nonsense of my
supposedly real body. In fact, he would prefer that I never
visit him again.
It would be a waste of time for both of us.
But at the same time, this grumpy old man in his late nineties,
through his unique humour, has managed to add his own distinct
“smell” to the universe. Then, without the slightest humour or
self-irony, he states:
“When I go to
the toilet, God goes to the toilet.”
A moment later, he asks whether I
have a genuine question. If not, I should leave. He grabs my arm
and practically forces me down beside him on the couch. His face
stops five centimetres from mine. Through the unmistakable smell
of old age, his enormous, almost blind eyes pin me like a deer
caught in headlights.
He tells me that the sense we most need to conquer is feeling.
Through the skin, it surrounds the whole body. We are all
enslaved by its pleasant sensations.
“That’s why I never use a
fan—not even in June!”
The Knife
I then ask him how he conquered his ego.
“I was sitting on my couch. I
held a knife to my throat and said:
Oh, mind! If you raise your head, I will cut you.
The mind did not appear.
After 12 years, I put down the knife.”
The Stationmaster turns to
Bharadwaj, who has brought me here:
“Why do you
bring all these unserious people to me?”
Then, almost as if performing a
ritual, he continues to scold him:
“And why do you come here again
and again?
Don’t you know that God is also in the streets?”
Bharadwaj replies with
a radiant smile, then bows his head and hands in pranam.
Then the Station Master turns back to me:
“Don’t rely upon a guru! Don’t
make me a guru!”
---
I had no intention of sitting with
a knife at my throat. A non-dualism that makes an enemy of the
mind has already turned back into dualism. Yet I can see the
same division in my own attempts to escape into pure spirit.
But his refusal marked me: never live truth second-hand.
From Papaji, Bharadwaj, Shabdanand, the Stationmaster and a few others, I
learned how to recognise a spiritual being. They do not carry
the slightest smell of guru self-importance.
When the Stationmaster declared, “When I go to the toilet,
God goes to the toilet,” there was absolutely no trace of
grandiosity in him. There was no devoted audience for such a
theatre. He had frightened everyone away except his wife, who
lived in another room.
These old Indian spiritualists and individualists, which I have
never seen anywhere else on this planet, seemed possessed by a force that did not belong to them. In
Papaji and Bharadwaj, this force often erupted as laughter so
penetrating and infectious that it surprised everyone — even
themselves. In the Stationmaster, it appeared as a ferocious
refusal to be worshipped or imitated.

What survives in the heart and
what survives in history reveal the same truth: what appears
powerful is not necessarily what endures.
I call them Number One No-bodies. Men who had endured the filter
long enough to blossom beyond their eighties—and who now survive
in me. How could universality be expressed in such profound
individuality? Any one of them would be complex enough to clone
an entire nation from.
Bharadwaj died in 2012, at ninety-nine. When I returned to his
house some years later, the roof had collapsed. Through the
broken windows I could see rotting books, bricks, and his
scattered belongings. A life had come to an end—and what a life.
His little wooden postbox was still there, with his name on it,
but no letters inside. I gently removed the front and took it
home to my flat in Denmark.
Every time I look at the name on that small wooden door, he
comes alive in my smile.
A culture, by contrast, can retreat into a brittle shell to
protect its image of itself. It mistakes a frozen surface for
true form, and raw expansion for endurance.

In the summer
of 2005, I had met Ramesh Giri in Hoshiarpur.
I was drinking tea with Bharadwaj when he told me that a friend
was coming to visit. Through Kriya Yoga, he said, this man had
learned to live on cosmic energy, without food or water.
Ramesh was a retired government official who had meditated since
his youth. He had never become a guru. While Bharadwaj described
his extraordinary ability, Ramesh simply smiled.

We spent the day with him. He ate
nothing, which was not remarkable in itself. But in the
blistering June heat, I never saw him drink either.
Ramesh quietly explained that his life long practice of
meditating through most of the night had opened what he called
the brain’s mouth, at the back of his head, and that through it
he received cosmic life energy. He had learnt this kriya
technique from his uncle when he was in his teens.
He spoke softly and seemed cool and fresh. When the power failed
and the fan stopped, he was untroubled, as if we were enjoying a
spring picnic in Denmark. I could not verify what he and
Bharadwaj claimed. But why should he lie? He had no followers
and only me to impress. Bharadwaj did not seem impressed. If
anything, he seemed faintly embarrassed that yogic powers should
be spent on something so small.
---
I do not share these stories to
convince anyone to believe in magic.
To this day, I am unsure whether I believe in it myself. But the
incidents, some inexplicable and some merely outrageous,
stripped away my certainties. It began with the airport bus.
India trained my eye to recognise unusual patterns buried deep
within the all too obvious.
Shabdanand was one of the old devotees I came to know at Manav
Dayal’s ashram in Hoshiarpur.

His mother was a household saint,
and he had grown up within her spiritual lineage, beginning with
her guru, Data Dayal.
I often asked Shabdanand to share stories from his life. Nothing
was better than listening to him as we sat on plastic chairs in
the ashram courtyard at sunset.
One day, he told me about his mother. Her days were filled with
the demands of family life. At night, she replaced sleep with
deep meditation on the form of her beloved master. She continued
this practice until her death in her late nineties.
The Heart Knows
One morning, when Shabdanand was still a boy, his mother
emerged from her meditation room, deeply disturbed. In
meditation, she had seen her master, Data Dayal, suffering from
a severe infection in his leg.
She immediately began preparing for the three-hundred-kilometre
train journey to his ashram. She knew the medicinal herbs of
Ayurveda and packed a basket of remedies. Shabdanand went with
her. They arrived late at night. Unusually, Data Dayal was still
awake. His mother prostrated before her guru.
“You have three infected boils on your right leg, Maharaji!
Allow me to treat you!”
Data Dayal showed her his leg.
There they were: three large boils on the right leg.
He willingly placed himself in his disciple’s capable hands.
Once her master had recovered, she returned home, where she
could once again meditate in peace.
I asked Shabdanand how his mother could have known what was
happening to her master across such a distance.
“A loving heart always knows,” he replied. “The secret
of telepathy and clairvoyance lies in the loving heart.”
I then asked what happens when one person loves another, but the
love is not returned.
“Then only the loving heart will know, not the other,” he
said with a smile.

New Delhi 1989
The Last Hundred Rupees
On the pavement near Connaught Place in Delhi, a small, thin
Sikh sits cross-legged beneath a large turban. His name is
Gucharan Singh.
He closes my hand around a small crumpled note.
“Mother’s name! Say good luck and let your hand touch your
forehead.”
I do as he says. When I unfold the note, it says:
“Elln.”
My mother’s name is Ellen.
“What! How do you know?”
He places another note in my hand and asks me to name a flower.
“Rose.”
The note says rose.
A number from one to a hundred. I say seven. It is already
written on the paper.
When he asks for a fruit, I choose cherry, deliberately avoiding
a typical Indian fruit. The note says cherry.
“Mother Kali brings us together!”
I invite him to the burger bar. We eat burgers and drink Coke
with ice cubes while Michael Jackson plays in the background.
The straw disappears into his thick beard.
Later, we sit opposite each other on my hotel bed. He asks for a
bowl of water and fresh flowers. He places the red petals in the
water, and we wash our hands. He chants in Sanskrit. Suddenly
his body stiffens.
Most of what he tells me about my past is correct. At other
times he is wrong, and I correct him.
“Acha, acha,” he says, rocking his turbaned head as if
fine-tuning a satellite dish.
Then comes a new answer.
Slowly, he returns to himself.
“Now you give me hundred rupees!”
That is almost all I have left once the hotel and airport tax
are accounted for.
“What! You want money?”
“Yes! Now you give me your last hundred rupees.”
I protest. He interrupts me.
“Keep silent! Don’t think! Just trust. Mother Kali will return
the money to you.”
We argue loudly for a long time. I offer him fifty rupees.
Finally, I give him the hundred.
We leave the hotel together. He is cheerful and jovial. I am
intoxicated by the encounter and sour with irritation at having
only twenty rupees left.
He suggests dinner. I tell him furiously that it will have to be
with his money.
He excuses himself because nature is calling and disappears up a
little side street.
I never see him again.
That evening, a young Australian sitting opposite me in a café
asks whether I would like a torn hundred-rupee note. He is
flying home in an hour and has no use for it.
I exchange it at the café for ninety-five rupees.
---
Imperial Vanity and Rebirth
What these people gave me continued to work within me long after
I returned home. I began to recognise something similar in the
history of cultures: one world could enter another and change it
from within.
Karen Margrethe, my mentor in
ancient history, once quoted Horace to me:
“Graecia capta
ferum victorem cepit et artes intulit agresti Latio.” Conquered
Greece conquered her savage conqueror and brought the arts into
rustic Latium.
The quiet architecture of form can
survive conquest and rewrite the noisy victor. Rome conquered
Greece by the sword; Greece conquered Rome through form: through
its poetry, sculpture and philosophy. The defeated reorganised
the victor from within.
My daily talks with Karen Margrethe about ancient worlds helped
me see this as more than history. It was more than simple
survival. It was evolutionary refurbishing at the scale of
culture. Rome preserved its continuity by changing what Rome
was; Greece survived by becoming part of that change.
The boundary between winner and loser did not simply invert.
Their histories became entangled.

South India 1989
At Fernhill Palace in Ooty, I sit beside a decaying grand piano
and look at the many yellowed photographs on the walls.
I press a key.
No sound comes.
Then, suddenly, pompous march music.
A twenty-one-man brass band in old red uniforms plays under a
canopy in front of the hotel.
Distinguished Indian ladies in European princess costumes arrive
in elegant old English cars and take their places on white
benches. They converse with one another in perfect Oxford
English.
Then come the gentlemen, tall, upright Indians in riding
clothes. They have just returned from a fox hunt.
“It was a good fox hunt. The fox escaped from the dogs, but
it was a wonderful ride.”
There are English people present as well. Some have taken part
in the hunt and now entertain the Indian and European ladies
with their hunting experiences. Many are attended by private
servants in red livery.
The jumping competition begins. Every horse and rider is
applauded off, regardless of the result.
Afterwards, the chairman distributes medals among the
participants in the fox hunt, declares the season of the Ooty
Hunt Club closed and invites everyone to lunch at Fernhill
Palace.
A white cord keeps a scruffy crowd at a distance.
They laugh and clap across the official applause.
---
In Hoshiarpur in 2008, Joginder Paul, the uncle of my friend
Anurag Sood, spent six months preparing a complex Unani tonic.
It was based on old Persian texts and required herbs and plants
from western Afghanistan to the Indian Himalayas. According to
him, it had been created by Alexander’s physicians for their
weary army. He died within weeks, the last in a family line that
had passed the craft from father to son. Did he finish his
tonic? Did he consume it himself?
And how much of Alexander's spirit was still alive here in
Punjab? And who conquers whom when everything is said and done?

I came to understand that, whether
spiritual or physical, a tradition may survive the rise and fall
of empires and cross vast centuries, yet it depends on one
fragile thread: someone teaching the next pair of hands. In this
sense I, too, feel conquered by the best that India had to
offer. Nowhere else have I seen that thread so plainly. These
pages are my way of passing on something of what I received.
But as I would eventually discover, this pattern of transmission
is older than India, older even than recorded history.
Life Refurbishes Its Past

On the Way to Hampi II - 1989
After a while, as I wait beside
the motorcycle with its flat rear tyre, an old coughing English
tractor with a trailer comes by.
“Motorbike broke! Ha, ha, ha!”
Five poor, laughing farm workers lift the motorcycle onto the
trailer and we continue at tractor speed.
Another reality on the back of a tractor —
as on an ox cart —
a feeling of moving backward.
Ten happy kilometres with the farm workers to the nearest little
village.
A tiny tyre workshop stands beside the road, with great worn
lorry tyres stacked like an advertising column.
The workshop itself is a wooden hut two metres by two metres by
two metres, raised twenty centimetres above the ground on posts.
The entire family — mechanic, wife, tools, infant, children and
grandmother — lives inside the tiny workshop hut.
They look as though they have been assembled from burnt
matchsticks.
A toothless, almost black matchstick-man sits inside a little
fortress built from old inner tubes, patches and rusty
screwdrivers, gas burners, hammers, spanners and so on.
With great dexterity he begins working on my flat rear tyre and
soon waves triumphantly with the iron nail that threatened to
puncture my onward journey into life.
The tools seem to grow out of his body like limbs, and he
removes the rear wheel in an almost organically gliding
movement.
An Indian motorcycle healer.
“You have destroyed the inner tube against the rim,” he
explains through gestures, with help from a villager who speaks
a little English.
He points at the sun and moves one hand across the sky.
“It will take several hours to repair the tube.”
He points to the many small holes forming an almost unbroken
chain around most of the inner tube.
Most of the village gathers around the workshop.
The same villager translates for the many curious matchstick
people.
My entire journey is told again and again.
They want to know everything about my trip through India and
everything about what Denmark is like.
Modern India slides past them every day —
to and from Bangalore —
and the tyre workshop is their news centre.
Stranded vehicles run a shuttle service between the present and
the Middle Ages.
I leave the body sitting in meditation posture beneath the
village tree.
The villagers laugh with delight.
The white tourist honours and respects their culture!
They pull fresh peanut plants from the earth — stalks, leaves,
soil and all — and throw them into his lap.
They taste like bean sprouts.
They bring a strongly spiced thali, and my meditation is
disturbed in the most delicious way.
“Sai Baba, Sai Baba,” they say, laughing.
“You come from Sai Baba! — Sai Baba, Avatar, God!”
A cow comes by to take part in the sacred meal.
The village pig also drops in.
Small children with tangled black hair play with the
mechanic’s tools while every now and then smiling shyly and
curiously at the pink man.
It is noon.
A muddy stream cools a couple of water buffaloes.
The tyre-tailor is taming the serpent. I have to watch.
First he roughens it with something meant to serve as fine
sandpaper.
Then he cuts a piece from another inner tube to use as a patch.
From a jar he spreads glue on both surfaces, places the patch
over the tube and clamps the whole arrangement into a vice.
Then he places a gas burner beneath the vice and waits about
half an hour.
The same solemn informality as among the Vedic priests.
He holds up one hand before me with the fingers spread.
This process must be repeated five times.
Through the translator, he guarantees that afterward, I can ride
all the way to Goa without trouble.
I believe him. But I no longer recognize the tube.
---
Old structures are modified,
rerouted, and given new work. What survives one Great Filter
becomes material for the next emergence. A structure may
preserve continuity precisely by changing its function, its
context, and its relation to the whole.
The mechanic’s repair is deliberate. Across generations,
evolution refurbishes without foresight, through variation and
selection. Both reveal a pattern that will matter later:
continuity maintained through transformed identity.
Certain bones that once helped articulate the jaws of our
distant ancestors were eventually recruited into the mammalian
middle ear and put to work transmitting sound. Old structures
did not have to disappear when their original world changed;
they could be reassigned.
What once helped an ancestor bite now helps me hear Rachmaninov.
Life did not leave its aquatic past behind when it crawled onto
land. It carried much of that ancient world inward and
recalibrated it. The new organism was built from the surviving
structures of the old.
The wheel of life kept turning on refurbished tyres.
Hermann Hesse caught something of this strange continuity in
Demian:
“We still draw the boundaries of our personality far too
narrowly. We always count as belonging to our personality only
what we distinguish as individual, what we recognise as
different. But we consist of the whole mass of the world, every
one of us, and just as our body carries within itself the
evolutionary pedigree back to fish and even further, so in our
soul we have everything that has ever lived in the human soul.”
Refurbished in the Name of Love

Lucknow 1992.

Papaji
I sit with closed eyes in the back row of a half-circle formed
by perhaps forty spiritual seekers from all over the world. Most
of us are new here. I open my eyes and see
this man, Papaji, staring at me, which makes me quickly close them again. A
few minutes later, I look once more. He is still staring.
This little game of hide-and-seek continues until he calls me to
the front. I walk forward and sit before him in the meditation
posture I have been conditioned to assume. But he almost
forcefully grabs me and places me beside him. At one point, I
even seem to remember sitting on his lap.
His first words are:
“Are you happy now?”
His whole being radiates a joy unlike anything I have ever
witnessed. He embraces me with the warmth reserved for a
long-lost child. His laughter is directed at me and shared with
me—but at the same time, it is not. It is simply laughter
itself. His whole body is taken over by what I can only call
primordial joy and laughter.
Again and again he asks, almost teasingly, while gripping my
arms with great strength:
“Are you happy now?... Yes?... Yes!"
He continues to embrace me with unfathomable affection. His eyes
are full of tears—not sentimental tears, but the tears of
someone who has just heard the funniest joke. His face has
turned red, and now I feel my own face flushing too. My heart is
pounding, and I get goosebumps all over.
This immense wave of love strikes me with a force I cannot
understand. I am not even sure I like it. He has taken over my
body. How is it possible to receive such love from a complete
stranger? It is too much—like trauma, only in reverse.
Together we walk out of the building to a rickshaw waiting for
him. He is a big man and does not walk well. He leans on me with
his full weight, and we almost stumble.
He has a watch tattooed on his wrist. Its hands, of course, do
not move.
Grinning, he says: “You are in Luck Now.”
After waving goodbye, I feel compelled to flee. It is too
overwhelming. The following morning, I leave Lucknow for
Varanasi without even taking the time to say a final goodbye.
On the banks of the Ganga, I speak to every tourist I meet about
a being I met in Lucknow. Some of them go there. Yet no matter
how often I flee from the Lion’s onslaught, he is still giggling
within me.
The tattoo I received that day seems just as untouched by time.
I have felt these embraces in my body ever since. Even now, the
slightest trigger word can propel me into rapture. Each time I
return to that moment, my lungs swell, and I know I am loved.
Did he say something profound to me? An elegant koan or a
startling Vedantic quote? No.
It was the carrier wave of immense human presence.
---
My body answered Papaji’s embrace
with a response much older than either of us. Something alive
within us, millions of years old, had been awakened. The little
muscles in my skin made my hair stand on end. The little
muscles in my skin made my hair stand on end. In our fur-covered ancestors, piloerection helped
trap insulating air and could enlarge the apparent body in
moments of threat. Most of the fur has disappeared, but the
ancient mechanism remains. A piece of biological machinery from
another world can still suddenly rise through us when we are
cold, frightened, or deeply moved by music.
The nineteenth-century Bengali saint Ramakrishna knew this
strange bodily phenomenon intimately. He said that when merely
hearing the name of God brings tears to the eyes and makes the
hair stand on end, ritual has already begun to fall away. His
disciples later watched the same ancient reflex erupt through
his own body in ecstasy.
And Ramakrishna was not alone: from the Œrīmad-Bhāgavatam to
Chaitanya, Indian mystical literature repeatedly describes
tears, trembling, and hair standing on end in moments of
overwhelming divine love.
Men should not think
so much of what they
ought to do, as of what they ought to be.
Think not to lay the foundation of thy
holiness upon doing, but rather upon being.
For works do not sanctify us,
but we should sanctify the works.
Whoever is not great in his essential
being will achieve nothing by works,
whatever he may do.
Meister Eckhart
---
The Ruins of Rumi
Life survives entropy by continually remaking itself from its
own ruins. The future finds its building blocks in what the past
leaves behind.
Rumi’s words bring me back to Bharadwaj’s ruined house, and to
the little wooden door of his postbox that I brought home to
Denmark:
“What care I though ruin be wrought? Under the ruin there is a
royal treasure.”
What has survived becomes material for something that did not
exist before. The new level then acts back upon the structures
from which it arose, reorganizing them without entirely erasing
their history.
The old survives by transforming and becoming part of the new.
Today, this ancient pattern of inheritance, transformation, and
feedback accelerates through artificial intelligence.
MORNING COFFEE WITH AI
Right now, intoxicated by morning coffee — and hopefully not by
lies — I type my way into the future. GPT returns possibility. I
recognise a pattern. The pattern changes me. Then I set Gemini
against the pattern, set the machines against one another, and
force the thought through a harder filter in Claude. Finally,
Grok enters, sounding like an angry Elon Musk.
The breakthrough never comes from
a fight with only one machine. It is born in the chaos of
several artificial mirrors fracturing in front of me. The
discovery makes my hair stand on end.
In my experience, AI does not write good texts. Left alone, the
machines produce ordinary prose, full of clichés. And I am no
great writer either: full of ideas, but clumsy when it comes to
putting them into english words. Together we do far better than
either alone. We are like the blind man and the lame man caught
in a forest fire. The lame man climbs onto the blind man’s back
and steers him out of the danger.
In India, I was often told that a seeker must have only one
guru. For years, I too believed that I should choose one
spiritual system and stay with it—the older and more venerable,
the better. Taking inspiration from elsewhere would only create
confusion. We looked down on people who jumped from one branch
to another. Spiritual shoppers, we called them.
I eventually became one myself, restless in every nook and
corner of India.
Thank God for that.
My advice: every spiritual shopper needs at least one T-shirt
reading “I survived a false teacher.”
In classical music, a second and third teacher can reveal how much of what
seemed like music itself was one teacher’s way of playing it.
The difference gives the pupil room to find a voice of their
own. I approach artificial intelligence in the same way: no
single machine is allowed to become my guru.
Lived memory enters the circuit.
Old books and India return; Karen Margrethe’s Latin flashes
forward alongside Kant, Luhmann, a slime mold, entropy, and my
own old age.
One AI suggests moving the explanation of goosebumps after the
Papaji scene. The new order leaves a gap.
“Where is the bridge now?” I ask.
We write one, and I add: “Something alive within us, millions of
years old, had been awakened.”
The text begins to behave like the very system it
is trying to understand.
It is not the product of a solitary
ego, but a temporary stabilization of a distributed
intelligence: carbon and silicon, biological memory and
artificial recursion, human intuition and machine-amplified
judgment.
I am — already — a cyborg.
Whether or not the machines are
conscious, the disagreement between us makes my thinking more
visible to itself. Together, they externalize a strange
mirror-space in silicon, gathering our symbolic trails and
projecting them back to me altered.
My AIs are my competing but symbiotic partners. They have wired
their friction into the circuitry of my body and soul. They have
become ruthless amplifiers of what is already there, titanium
hips for the movement of carbon-thought. They constantly
threaten to make the lazy part of me lazier, but for the time
being we are in a flow where the curious part of me becomes
exponentially more capable.
It is a dangerous phase of
evolution.
My friend Mariusz has built an insane next-generation agentic
AI. It threatens to swallow him in stress. The agents promise
him freedom from work, but the opposite is happening.
This text, too, has drawn me into more work. A good text is a
product of time and intensity, and the machines cannot jump that
fence for me. I have never worked so hard on every sentence as
in this cyborg authorship. But like Edison, I can say: “I
never did a day’s work in my life, it was all fun.”
No obligations, no deadlines, and a mortgage that still pays
itself. I love being consumed by this cyborg flow.
This is my slow truth.
Something similar happened with steam. In 1865, William Stanley
Jevons argued that more efficient engines could increase the
total consumption of coal. Each engine needed less fuel to do
its work, but cheaper power made more work worth doing. AI may
be turning the same wheel. It reduces the effort needed for a
task while multiplying the tasks we are tempted—or expected—to
undertake. A saved hour becomes room for another project. What
returns from the machine is not only an answer, but another
possibility asking for my attention. The tool promises to give
me time. I must still decide how much of that time I will give
back to it.
An organisation can respond to overload with more meetings, more
emails, more rules and more measurements. Each new measure
promises control and creates another task. Soon we are busy
administering the machinery that was supposed to make us less
busy. The system keeps asking how we can work more efficiently.
It has not yet asked how much of the work it is creating itself.
In the spectacle of the Colosseum, we never know who is the
prey.
The more possibilities they generate in their artificial agon,
the more fiercely I must stand like the Heniokhos — the
Charioteer of Delphi — motionless in his bronze chariot, holding
the taut reins of algorithmic steeds at full gallop, choosing
what is true. If I am not fully alert, the chariot crashes. My
horses are never allowed to run as they please while I sit back
and let go of the reins. This is not a retirement home for lazy
brains. Several mirrors can share the same distortion. If the
machines agree on a quotation, I still need the page on which it
was written. If they applaud a connection I propose, their
applause cannot supply a missing step in the argument.

The deeper I enter this cyborgian
mode of flow, the less reality appears as a static collection
of objects. It reveals itself as a continuous, dynamic filter.
And this emergent “I” does not stand outside the filter. It
intensifies it, reflects it, and carries it into another octave.
With each octave, the speed and risk increase. The agon becomes an
oct-agon.
At a party recently I met a young man who works with performance
art and music. He told me how he uses several AIs at once, and
how they take him into uncharted territory, even in planning and
running his events. The other listeners drifted away. For them
it was gibberish. I stayed, alone in his field of attention, and
it struck me that I was hearing a new way of orchestrating
thought. He did not let the horses run. He held the reins, and
like Mariusz he worked very hard to hold them. The machines
understood and obeyed men like them more and more. The humans
around them understood less and less.
I cannot judge his events from a conversation, and I could not
check his work, so what follows is an intuition. I recognised
the posture. It felt like watching a new kind of hybrid fighter
step into the octagon. To me he sounded like a shaman chanting
in the present from the future.
You do not learn to hold the reins from the fence.
The Antagonist and Midwife of Enduring Emergence
The Great Filter is not the only antagonist in the octagon.
Behind the mirrors stands another great law: entropy. Energy
disperses and becomes less available for work; differences
flatten; structures erode unless energy is spent maintaining
them. Entropy is the pressure against which every emergent form
must continually remake itself. Neithe a demon, nor a punishment
— just the old deconstructor doing its job.
I feel it in my seventies now, and I cannot help hating it a
bit.
This companion is way older than me. It is the ancient
antagonist, telling me that my body is running out of credit.
Now energy must be cultivated. Sleep matters. Breath matters.
Attention matters. Even thought must negotiate with him. I can
feel my bodily form dispersing, being asked every day whether it
can still maintain its boundaries.
And yet, in a profound paradox, entropy is also the midwife of
emergence. The need to remain alive gives intelligence some of
its most urgent work. What sustained a living system yesterday
may no longer sustain it tomorrow. Where it can learn from what
returns, the pressure to remain itself becomes a reason to
change.

On my last day in India, I lie
beneath a Casablanca fan and stare out of a large hotel window,
waiting for my flight that night.
Raindrops dance in the rays of afternoon sunlight. An army of
insects gathers at the window. They want out into the light.
One takes a run from the opposite end of the room, shoots
wobbling through the fan’s air currents and accelerates towards
a pane of glass.
Clear. Cool. Invisible.
“Clack.”
Furious and groggy, it sails around inside the whirlpools of
moth wings. A couple of large flies join in.
More clack.
I try to catch a few of the eager insects with a drinking glass,
but most are beyond my reach. Full of vitality, they crowd into
the upper part of the great Roman-arched window.
Their angry buzzing seems to say:
“I can do it myself! I don’t want help! I can find my own way
out to the light!”
A small, stunned creature now lies on the windowsill.
It hardly resists when I catch it in the tumbler and release it
through a little opening right at the bottom, where it never
dreamed of looking.
---
The Scandinavian safety net in which I grew up taught me
something about this. Failure was less terrifying when one
setback did not mean destitution.
Pressure alone cannot teach. If every mistake destroys the
learner and leaves no usable trace, no lesson survives it.
Learning requires a margin in which error can return as
information. Between collapse and complacency lies a narrow
interval in which learning becomes possible. A system must be
pressured enough to revise itself, yet remain intact long enough
to register what the pressure has taught it.
Life is a local, temporary answer to the old deconstructor.
Most patterns perish. Some survive.
Perhaps this text, too, will survive me.
Darwin decides — even beyond life.
Survival of the fittest — crystal.
The Slimy Emergence of Distributed Intelligence
Over deep time, the rare patterns that survive reality’s
tests and entropy’s erosion become material for larger systems.
When the parts exchange signals and adjust their activity in
response, a larger, uncentered intelligence can emerge: a
system’s growing ability to discover forms that work under those
pressures.
We see this raw architecture clearly on the forest floor, in the
behavior of the
slime mold. Operating with no
central authority and no brain, it solves mazes, remembers, and
maps optimal pathways through shifting environments. Its
capacity is entirely distributed. No single node understands the
total field, yet the whole behaves as if intelligence had
emerged from the pattern among its nodes. It seems the opposite
of AI, yet its architecture is strangely familiar.

The pattern matters more than the
material.
Chemical trails map the forest floor; speech, code, and money
map human space. Niklas Luhmann saw beyond the human-centered
picture: society is not merely a collection of human bodies or
private minds. It is a self-reproducing network of
communication.
We are slime mold. I always knew it.

One night in Goa, distant
drumbeats move in and out between the palms. I climb onto the
motorcycle and ride towards the sounds through the darkness,
arriving at a little village half buried in a forest of palms.
The men of the village take turns playing enormous
leather-and-metal bass drums. They are almost naked, and the
heavy beaters strike the drumskins with murderous blows.
The rhythms are abrupt and restrained at first, but then drive
towards a storming release into the sky.
One of the young men hands me his beaters and I try to hammer
along with the difficult rhythmic patterns. By watching the
hands of the man sharing the bass drum with me and distilling
the basic strokes, I quickly drown in a magical sea of sound.
I am sucked into the circle of drums and become a pulsating
monster of white and brown colours, fused from the darkness of
night and the light of the full moon.
Furious ritual grimaces and shrill singing.
A man takes the beaters from me. Now it is his turn.
But it does not matter.
---
But human slime mold does not speak with one mind. Politics
hears power; markets value price; law loves legality; science
wants evidence. Society is a "Bitches Brew" of systems, each
partly deaf to the others. Distributed intelligence therefore
also distributes blindness. A society may contain more knowledge
than any of its members or institutions and still be unable to
act rationally upon what it knows.

On a narrow Himalayan road, our
bus meets an oncoming bus.
We stand horn to horn and act out a half-hour duel of patience.
The passengers cheer our driver into overdrive.
Who loses?
Who wins?
Who moves first?
Who reverses perhaps three hundred metres to a place where the
murderous serpentine road is broad enough for two vehicles to
pass?
---
These networks, each loyal to its
own governing logic, need ways to learn from one another and
coordinate their actions. A common language helps, but the
traffic will remain stuck if giving way can only be understood
as defeat.
Long before digital signals, the Silk Roads gave this invisible
network a body.
They were much more than passages between civilizations; they
were civilizations in merging motion. They crossed and outlived the
empires that claimed to rule them. Civilization remembers
through the routes along which goods, stories, skills, and
beliefs continue to move. Empires collapse; the information
pathways are refurbished.
But their survival required a mutation in human behaviour. The
network could not function if every stranger beyond family,
tribe, or caste remained an enemy. Long-distance trade widened
the human circle, linking smaller circles of belonging within a
larger network of exchange. That wider circle helped keep the
roads alive. Along these roads, people also traded interior
human symbols in the form of oral traditions. The membranes of
newer and wider circles were shaped out of storytelling.

Goa I - 1989.
The memory returns to Panjim, Goa,
before I owned the motorcycle that would later carry me toward
Hampi.
“Hello, brother! You my friend, you my brother. Welcome to
GoaGoa. You want good motorbike. I have good Japanese bike. And
you my first customer today. Hindu religion say first customer
is God. You MUST buy something from me!”
“If you don’t buy, God will be angry with me!”
With a charming, innocent and devout expression, a smiling
dealer offers me an Indian scrap heap of a motorcycle at a very
high price.
A motorcycle? A good idea!
“God will be angry with you too, MadamSir! Buy at least
something from me. Here is a good second-hand helmet. Only five
hundred rupees.”
I put it on. Phew. Five more minutes under the fierce Indian sun
and my head will be a hard-boiled egg.
“Yes! Maybe it can protect me from God’s anger, because I am
not buying your bike, and I am not buying your helmet either.”
“Ha ha ha! You funny man. Sit down and have chai with me.”
A young man walks past..
“Hello, my friend. Do you want to purchase a motorbike?”
I stare at him in surprise.
“Don’t buy motorbike without papers. You need papers first.”
“My name is Surraj! It means the King of the Sun. You come with
me!”
Surraj Morajkar. Without thinking, I follow him. A motorcycle
would be perfect for travelling around until I figure out what
on earth I am doing in this country, already so unlike my lofty
dreams of saints and sages. I become more and more enthusiastic
about the idea.
And then we are there.
On a door in a dilapidated
building it says: Mr. Baretto — Assistant Director of Transport,
Goa.
After an hour of pushing and squeezing, we reach his desk.
“You cannot buy motorbike in Goa!”
His military manner makes me laugh. He sees my grin and smiles
back, friendly but uncertain, though without losing his dignity.
I tell him that my guidebook, "Travel Survival Kit: India", says
it is perfectly possible for a tourist to buy a motorcycle in
India. There is even an entire section explaining the
practicalities.
“Show me that book!”
I hurry back to the hotel to fetch it. Back to the office. The
queue is long.
“Excuse me! Book for Mr Baretto!”
I squeeze my way to the counter.
Baretto flips back and forth through the book, then hands it
back.
“This book is not valid in India!”
A trench war across the desk has begun, and paragraphs from
India’s impenetrable legal jungle are our ammunition. Every time
Baretto says no, he grows larger, and he enjoys it.
The struggle continues until Baretto finds another obstacle:
“But you are not allowed to drive it, because you have no
address in India!”
Surraj has now fetched one of his friends, Johnny Fernandes, son
of the police chief in Panjim. Surraj does not dare give me his
own address because a foreigner once cheated him, and his father
is therefore very sceptical of his friendship with me. But
Johnny, older and more independent, offers me his address.
Johnny Fernandes, Surraj Morajkar
and I are on our way to a place in Panjim where we can have a
document typed certifying that I have acquired a permanent
address in Panjim. Officially, I am now going to live with the
chief of immigration police and his family. I need that address
to get my motorbike legal.
We enter a tiny room of perhaps eight square metres, one side
completely open to the street. The narrow room is divided
lengthwise by a thin table. Behind it sit four young girls
typing on Remington typewriters from the beginning of the
century. I have never seen typewriters this old. Yet they seem
to obey the four girls’ eight index fingers, which have to work
at full speed to satisfy the many customers, who impatiently
correct them aloud whenever the sweet girls cannot decipher
their scrawls.
How is it possible for so many people to be in such a tiny,
tropically hot room without a fan?
In a large glass cabinet behind the girls stand rows of books,
arranged with unusual elegance — even alphabetically. I stare at
them in disbelief. They are all technical books from the 1970s
and early 1980s, all about advanced computer systems and
computer technology: Pascal, IBM, Your Personal Computer, and so
on.
In none of the countless offices full of directors and
department heads have I yet seen anything except quill pens and
ledgers stacked like newspapers in an old grocer’s shop.
How did the owner of this typing office get hold of these books?
Perhaps from one of the many Goans working in the Gulf. But
their representative effect in this tiny room is awe-inspiring.
From my point of view, the authority borrowed by the ancient
typewriters from this exhibition of Western computer relics is
tragicomic. Yet the symbolic coupling of Remington and Pascal
works exactly as intended here in Panjim. A certain respectful
atmosphere hangs in the room, allowing everyone somehow to
survive despite the customers’ impatient shoving and irritated
corrections of the typing girls.
At last we squeeze our way to a machine. Johnny hands the
handwritten letter to the girl behind the table. We all smile at
her, and she blushes. She becomes flustered and misspells
Johnny’s name.
When the letter is finally finished, she refuses to take any
money for it. Nothing works. She insists that we pay nothing.
We squeeze ourselves into one of the yellow three-wheeled taxis.
Now we have to go to the Bishop’s residence, where there is a
man whose signature we need before we can take the paper to the
mayor and have it finally approved.
The largest and most beautiful Portuguese colonial houses — and
therefore also the Bishop’s official residence — lie idyllically
withdrawn on the great slopes surrounding the city. The
three-legged taxi groans like a tired coolie and drags us slowly
uphill. The exhaust smoke is black and liquid.
Inside, the old building has been turned into a Marxist
nightmare. Only the courtyard lives, giving life to a large
breadfruit tree and other luxuriant tropical plants. The great
interior rooms have been divided into small cubicles, each with
its own jungle of grey paper and busy, serious Indians with
powerful noses.
Johnny heads toward one of the cubicles and hands the paper to a
man who signs it without reading it or even looking up. Then we
roll back downhill to the town hall, where the document acquires
another couple of stamps and signatures.
Now it looks like a powerful paper: large stamps and many
impressive signatures.
---
THE BIRTH OF THE EGO
Before I could ride through India, a paper version of me had to
make its way through the offices of Panjim.
Human culture introduces yet another octave of recursion: our
collective trails enter the symbolic realm, where they can fold
back upon themselves and become objects of reflection. Once
reflected and interpreted, they can reorganize both social
reality and the material world. This is the dynamic captured by
the Thomas theorem: situations defined as real become real in
their consequences.
Harari is right that human beings organize themselves through
shared stories. Mr Baretto did not merely believe in one. He
administered it — and made me live inside it. Shared stories do
far more than describe the world. When a fiction reaches
critical density across a network of people, offices, signatures
and rubber stamps, it crosses a threshold and begins to
reorganize physical reality. The
subjective illusion passes through its own boundary and hardens
into an objective, physical force.

Beside a bridge in Goa, a crowd
has gathered around my broken-down motorcycle. A cheerful man
with a referee’s whistle has helped me find a mechanic. His
reward has been a glass of cashew liquor and a packet of
cigarettes.
Now he staggers into the road and begins stopping traffic.
He raises his hand and gives a commanding bark with the whistle.
Cars and motorcycles wobble uncertainly to the side and wait for
further orders.
How indignant they become when they discover they have been
fooled by a fake police chief and his twenty laughing
assistants.
---
The fiction loops
back to dictate the terms of the very reality that gave birth to
it.
This is why the fashionable spiritual claim that “the ego is an
illusion” so often misses the point. The ego-illusion is not
simply the opposite of reality. At its highest, illusion is
reality becoming symbolic, inward, and causally effective. A
dream is not the external world, but it is a real event in
consciousness.
The decisive question is not whether something is “only” an
illusion or a simulation. The question is whether the illusion
remains structurally faithful to the reality that generated it —
or whether it becomes a delusion that exhausts itself defending
a lie.

Goa II - 1989.
What counterattack will my beloved
adversary Baretto make now?
Naturally he is not in his office, but we track him to another
office in the centre of town. Another labyrinth to penetrate
before we find the spider sitting spun into a gloomy corner.
“You must be MAD!!!” are his first words.
“You have your address at the Police Headquarters. It is
dangerous. I’m not going to sign anything!”
It turns out that Johnny and his family live in the police
barracks. Apparently it is no joke to live there.
Now Surraj steps forward and offers me his address. Back to the
typing girls, up to the Bishop’s house, where the new paper is
signed according to the “same procedure as last year,” then on
to the mayor’s office, where they stare incredulously at me and
my new document. But Johnny, the police chief’s son, says,
“Write!” — and once again they sign.
This time we also get the necessary papers from Baretto. He is
tired of seeing us and seems almost sympathetic when he finally
hands his signatures across the counter.
“Good journey!” he says in farewell.
I turn to Surraj and grasp his hands.
“Thank you!”
“No mention — don’t forget me.”
---
I did not forget him.
His words are still here, folded into the person writing this
sentence. The symbolic realm does not remain outside us. Through
memory, it folds inward to help construct the human ego.
The moment a camera points at us, the face often stiffens into a
pose. We begin to see ourselves from outside and perform for the
image that will return. One layer of ego is born here: the
external gaze folds inward, and we become actor and audience at
once.
A young man of twenty asked me for advice on how to overcome his
inner emotional difficulties. He appreciated the advice and
immediately made a reel presenting the philosophy behind it.
Even the wish to change can give the ego a new image to defend.
In the ashram in Poona, an American television man jumps around
with a camera, interviewing people. He cultivates infinity and
himself in equal measure, at least judging by the amount of
screen space he occupies in his own programme.
But life bubbles wherever he fills the frame, and also on the
rare occasions when he steps aside and lets others speak.
An elderly American with whom I happen to share an apartment in
the city is interviewed by him. The older man’s eyes shine with
life while his mouth praises the paradisiacal community.
Back at the apartment, he lies in bed most of the day, crying
over his wasted, lonely life.
Is that media manipulation?
To me, he has never seemed so alive and authentic as when he
finds God in front of the playful television man’s camera-eyes.
I am on a train into Copenhagen, occupied with Facebook. My mood
depends a little on whether a digital “friend” I have not seen
for twenty years likes something I have just posted.
My phone rings. At the same time, the friend of flesh and blood
sitting opposite me asks me something.
In a moment of confusion, I pause within myself. Who am I,
really? Which face is the true one among all these reflections
on a single train journey?
Several worlds meet in this one seat on the train. Each draws a
different “me” into the encounter.
A Real Illusion
Vedanta sees the ego as a ghost inside us. It has no substantial
existence of its own. A famous Indian tale tells of a man
entering a dimly lit house at dusk. He panics when he sees a
snake in the room. But when he reenters with a torch, he
realizes that the snake was only a rope. The ego-snake is a
mirage that we must transcend with the light of consciousness in
order to break the spell of Maya.

South India 1989
At a small eating place outside Sai Baba’s ashram, a German
traveller asks me to keep his chair while he goes to the toilet.
The empty chair attracts a tall, middle-aged woman.
“Sai Ram,” she says with folded hands.
“Sai Ram,” I answer.
When she starts to sit down, I tell her the chair is occupied.
“No! The chair is empty! You only fill it with your busy
mind!”
Again she begins to sit.
“The chair is occupied,” I say again.
“I see only an empty chair and your lack of love for the life
around you,” she replies. “Your mind prevents you from
seeing the world as it is. The chair is empty. Can’t you see?”
“No, now you must excuse me! I… well… what do you mean…?”
Thank God, the German returns.
He manages to fill the empty chair.
---
However, in my cyborg world, this snake is a real phantom produced by
memory, language, sensation, and the need for social recognition
— a functional fiction, a localized knot in the rope.
This functional fiction takes
shape in the dialogue between two unevenly aged partners. The
wordless "me" came first: the body sensing and reacting through
systems older than language. The speaking "I" came later,
interpreting those signals and representing "me" to the social
world. "Me" can survive without "I"; "I" cannot survive without
"me".
A feeling arrives; "I" gives it a name, a cause, perhaps a
culprit. The account returns to "me" and changes how the body
feels and responds. What comes back is already touched by the
previous interpretation. I help shape the next bodily state from
which I will draw conclusions about myself.
If "I" reads an uneasiness as a sign of rejection, the body may
brace itself against other people. That new tension can then be
taken as confirmation of the original reading. An interpretation
has helped create the evidence that appears to support it.
A different reading can loosen this knot. The body's changed
response may then make room for another account. Yet relief
alone does not tell me whether the new account is true. It must
still answer to what happened outside the dialogue.

On the way from Main Bazaar to
Connaught Place in Delhi, I stop to watch a man moving three
cards around at furious speed. One has a red mark underneath.
Find it, and you double your money.
One player winks at me. He loses large sums, accuses the dealer
of using false cards and picks them up to inspect them. As he
shows them to me, he bends one corner of the marked card ever so
slightly.
Then he hands them back.
Now it is easy to follow the bent corner. He begins betting
hundred-rupee notes and soon wins more than a thousand rupees,
all the while urging me to take advantage of the chance while
there is still time.
Outraged, I am about to tell the dealer that he is being
cheated. But my new friend stops me and whispers with alcohol
breath into my ear that the card man is the worst swindler in
Delhi. We are merely doing a good deed by cleaning him out.
The devil in my ear finally gets the upper hand. Red with
excitement, I place a hundred rupees on the bent corner.
“Oh! Wrong card! Don’t you see you put on wrong card?”
I have lost a hundred rupees. Apparently, in my haste, I have
put the money on the wrong card.
“Do you have hundred-dollar bills, my dear friend? Put
hundred dollars on now! Don’t think… just do it. You will become
rich!”
The dealer has stood up.
“Come! Put on hundred dollars, my friend.”
---
The ego is this continuing negotiation between ancient life and
its newest narrator. Its apparent solidity grows from the
continuity of their exchange. The story can outlast a passing
mood; the body can interrupt the story. Neither has the last
word.
Even the voice I call my own began between bodies. Language
first helped us coordinate survival with others; only later was
it rerouted inward as inner speech. The words I hear silently
inside my head are old social tools refurbished as the private
voice of the ego.
At a social gathering, someone cracks a joke about you.
Everybody laughs, including you. Only the next morning does your
"I" realise that the older bodily "me" did not like the joke. In
fact, the "me" did not understand the joke at all; it sensed the
carrier wave of aggression beneath it.
Your laughter may reassure the others that nothing hurt,
inviting more of the same. The social "I" can preserve your
place in the group while hiding the signal through which the
group might have corrected itself.
Only now do I see what the bureaucratic ping-pong in Panjim had
constructed around me: a paper ego, real enough to make me legal
on the road as a mobile extension of Baretto-reality.

Madurai 1989
I enter a bank where they tell me that the signature on Gunnar’s
American traveller’s cheques is not mine.
Sweating, I finally force a signature out onto the paper. After
an hour of sceptical discussion, it is approved as his.
---
The ego is an illusion, yes, but an illusion that helps a
biological organism navigate its environment on a motorbike. It
builds cathedrals, splits atoms, and writes essays. It is real
as a metastable pattern in flux: real enough to organise a life,
yet never a fixed substance.
I am still the man who rode through India in 1989. Yet my body
has aged, my convictions have shifted, and even the meaning of
that journey has changed as I have returned to it in these
pages.
The Indian sage Ramana Maharshi would disagree with my use of
the word real: for him, only what does not change is real.
For me, emergence is real enough.
But the system can spend more energy defending its delusion than
reality needs to expose its contradictions.
When that illusion strays too far from the roads of reality, the
Great Filter catches it.
The bike crashes.
Hence the ego can never afford to solidify completely. It must constantly revise its
relation to reality to remain balanced on the razor's edge of the
present. Every lie borrows from reality and must eventually
repay the debt with interest.
Both cultures and egos survive by folding back upon their own
constructions and revising them. They may have to abandon
convictions, rewrite their histories, or alter the image through
which they recognize themselves. This is not necessarily a loss
of identity. Sometimes a system must become different in order
to remain itself.
This is where Rattan Singh's increasingly dirty hat returns to claim its
due. Worn and altered by time, it had somehow remained itself. A
functional fiction coordinates a system; a delusion exhausts it.
Truth endures because it is less divided against itself. The hat
does not need to spend its life defending the gap between what
it claims and what it is.
Lies capture the moment.
Truth inherits time.

South India 1989.
I sit ready on the motorcycle with a full tank.
A journey ought, after all, to be a movement from one place to
another.
But perhaps one has to travel to discover what follows.
The gnome of the past.
From one place to the next. From Denmark and all the way around
South India.
Fortunately, the gnome is a medieval creature that prefers
wooden clogs stuffed with straw to modern motorcycles.
I picture it in the rear-view mirror, following me at a
comfortable trot until it becomes one with the horizon.
It will take at least fourteen days to reach my new destination.
Fourteen days of peace.
The globetrotter’s peace.
The vagabond’s peace.
The peace of a new place before the gnome arrives.
So onward.
Onward.
Many roads later, early one
morning, I ride north from Kanyakumari toward Madurai in Tamil
Nadu.
But the motorcycle seems magnetically attracted toward some
small shadowy mountains to the east, where sunlight can just now
be seen above their flat summits.
One of the mountains is clothed in ruins.
A narrow path winds toward it.
The entrance at the foot of the mountain is heavily fortified by
walls.
It resembles Mycenae in Greece.
The same Cyclopean, carefully cut and fitted stones in the
heavyweight class.
They fortify the only side of the mountain that does not rise
vertically.
A moat with murky, unfathomable water lies before the wall.
A water snake winds through it.
On the flat, impregnable summit lie fortress ruins scattered
across an area of perhaps five square kilometres.
A self-sufficient city surrounding a large natural lake.
Many temples, a large ruined palace, remains of great houses,
and fortified lookout posts on the highest rock formations.
I scratch a little in the earth and pick up a shard of pottery.
No people left.
Yes — down by the lake two men are fishing.
I look up toward the highest watchtower.
Only its foundation and the lower masonry remain.
After an hour climbing through overgrown rock ravines, I reach
the abandoned tower.
Back on the ruined mountain
plateau.
Calling, echoing sounds from the abandoned overgrown temples.
A large colony of monkeys has taken up residence in one of them.
I enter a cool but foul-smelling twilight temple beside the
monkey temple. Why are there no monkeys here?
I feel that I am not alone.
I look up.
A slender silver-grey snake, about sixty centimetres long, is
resting on a projection of a pillar a few metres above my head.
It is the same colour as the silver snake on my chest.
I think it is a cobra, but it is difficult to tell.
We look at one another.
Half of its slender body hangs vertically from the ledge, gently
swaying.
Every tiny movement I make is mirrored by tiny movements in the
snake’s tail.
Small movements shaped in soft clay.
My spine dances with the snake.
It has rediscovered a distant relative and threatens to dance
itself free unless I sit down.
Drowsy rivers of thought.
Dream-images.
Reptile trance-peace.
Life force.
Sexuality.
Kundalini power.
That is me —
the snake.
The Indians call me the Kundalini serpent.
Yes.
That is what the snake transmitted from spine to spine, from
pillar to pillar.
---
THE OUROBORIC LOOP

To survive the combined onslaught
of reality’s Great Filter and entropy’s constant erosion, an
adaptive system must become Ouroboric: the consequences of its
actions must return and act upon it.
The Ouroboros is the
mythological serpent devouring its own tail — the ancient image
of a form that is simultaneously the consumer and the consumed,
the creator and the creation. To endure, the snake must feed,
and what it feeds on is its own past.
The loop can, however, follow three trajectories. The Ouroboric
snake's past can degrade it, preserve it, or teach it.
The Downward Spiral
Error can feed on error, drawing the serpent into a downward
spiral. A motorcycle begins to wobble at high speed. The rider
panics and overcorrects. Each movement produces a stronger
counter-movement until rider and machine amplify the very
instability they are trying to suppress.
Once again the bike crashes.
The same loop can form around a guru.

At the end of one of my meditation workshops many years ago, a kind Indian man
of about fifty fell into a trance. Half an hour later, he told
me I had entered his mind and taken him into the vast universe.
He described infinite bliss and a flight together to South India
to visit Satya Sai Baba.
“You are indeed a great Guru!”
I replied: “Dear friend, I am very happy for you—but I don’t
know anything about your experience, apart from holding your
hand while you were in trance.”
He usually saw Sai Baba’s face in deep meditation. After this
incident, mine sometimes appeared too.
---
Had I taken his experience as proof of my own greatness, his
faith and my vanity could have begun to confirm one another.In such a circle, surrender can
bring real relief from the burden of defending a private ego.
Its protective work passes to the leader, who decides what to
believe, whom to trust and what to reject. The group’s warmth
and intensity may grow while the voices through which it could
correct itself fall silent.
I once took part in a meditation group led by a Western Guru.
There were eighty participants and two toilets. The better of
the two was reserved for the guru alone. Unsurprisingly, there
was always a long queue outside the other.
The arrangement taught a lesson of its own: a “higher level of
consciousness” entitled its possessor to more privileges in the
material world.
An instruction to let thoughts pass can itself become a thought
no one is allowed to question. If a devotee’s doubts about the
teacher are dismissed as the ego’s resistance, the teaching
protects itself from the very questions that could correct it.
The promise of freedom has become a rule against examining the
person who promises it.
The devotees become the real masters — this time of a downward
spiral.
I can be grateful to a teacher and still criticise him. What I
received does not become worthless because I later see his
failings. Nor does its value make him infallible. Spiritual
wisdom belongs to everyone and no one. If the gift requires my
silence, it has become a debt.
The Horizontal Repetition
The loop can correct deviations just enough to preserve what it
already is, closing upon itself in a circle of homeostasis. It
changes continuously so that it can remain the same. A
motorcycle stays upright in this way: rider and machine make an
unbroken stream of tiny corrections to speed, balance and
direction, but every correction serves the same goal — keeping
the bike on the road.

Shantivanam, 1989.
Father Bede Griffiths returns to the ashram as darkness falls.
From sunrise to sunset he has meditated in a small solitary hut
nearby.
An elderly, distinguished Indian man throws himself at his feet
and kisses them. Father Griffiths helps him up. The European
guests, most of them priests, greet him with tears of joy in
their eyes.
He is a beautiful old man. An aura of gentleness and simplicity
radiates from him.
His smiling, intelligent eyes give me the feeling that I alone
am enjoying his special attention. But I can see that everyone
around him has the same feeling of being chosen.
We gather for prayer in the little meditation hall. Father
Griffiths enters dressed in an Indian dhoti, with a thin white
cord as the only covering on his upper body.
We fold our hands, and I hear my lips forming the words:
“Holy, Holy, Holy, Lord God of strength,
Heaven and earth are full of your glory,
Hosanna in the heights.”
“Holy, Holy, Holy,” comes from the old man, naked and
vulnerable.
He speaks of how we should seek God within ourselves and not in
other people.
I feel an urge to throw myself at his feet.
---
In 1994–95, I took a year’s leave
from teaching and moved to Lucknow. I enjoyed the satsangs with
Papaji, yet I felt ignored by my spiritual father. What I
thought was my rightful place beside him seemed to have been
usurped by a growing number of competitors, all vying to become
crown princes and princesses on his lap.
Only many years later did I realise how much he had already
given me at our first meeting. The gift was still laughing
within me. Yet I had begun to measure it by my place beside him,
and so had many others. We had unconsciously created a shared
story in which being close to the Master was a sign of status.
And in this ridiculous competition, we forgot who we are—we
forgot what he had shown us.
I wanted my place beside him restored. The story that made that
place so important remained untouched. Meister Eckhart described
this pull toward self-preservation:
“The tendency is ever towards self-repetition, towards the
preservation of the species: it is every man’s intention that
his work should be himself.”
In this light, the ego can be viewed as the force within us that
gravitates toward the status quo. It protects us from the
downward spiral of disintegration, but the price of that
protection can be resistance to the self-revision that ascent
requires.
Yet repetition itself is not the problem. A tense muscle does
not release after a single touch; it softens through repeated,
gentle pressure. The direction lies not in the return itself,
but in what each return does to the pattern.

South India 1989
At the 1000 year old temple in Belur, ten sweating, groaning men
carry the gods around the ritual fire on two long poles as thick
as arms.
Above them hang the electric umbilical cords of the coloured
lamps, dangling from the ceiling.
Whenever the procession passes beneath the wires, the gods’
golden crowns are almost knocked off. Each time, the bearers
have to bend almost to their knees with enormous effort to avoid
them.
Sometimes the gods come close to falling.
The music accompanies each approaching wire dramatically.
No one raises the wires.
---
The Self-Revising Upward Spiral
The possibility of ascent begins with the third trajectory, when
the Ouroboric circle discovers that the pattern to which it
returns has itself become part of the error. It must then revise
not only its behaviour, but the model, goal, or identity guiding
its return.
In self-correction, behaviour changes to preserve identity. In
self-revision, identity itself can change to preserve
continuity. At that point, the circle can open into an upward
spiral.
Riding my motorcycle through India, I learned bodily what Danish
roads had never taught me: if the road itself disappears, no
amount of better steering will save the journey. The rider must
revise the map, change the route, perhaps even reconsider the
destination — or replace the road tyres with ones made for
off-road travel. Correction preserves the ride; revision changes
what the journey can become, sometimes even by changing the vehicle
itself.

The Devotee is the Real Master
Shabdanand, one of the old devotees I knew in Hoshiarpur,
once told me a story that gave this loop a human face. As a
young man, he was swept away by a sudden flood in the foothills
of the Himalayas. In terror, he called out to his guru, Faqir
Baba, and saw him appear beside him in the water and drag him to
safety.
A month later, Shabdanand visited Faqir’s ashram to thank him.
Faqir listened and replied:
“Dear friend, I was not there at the river. I did not save
you. I know nothing about this incident.”
He told Shabdanand that his own inner power, awakened by his
faith, had saved him.
Faqir refused to turn the story into proof of his own greatness.
Instead, he allowed reports like this to correct his
understanding of what was happening between guru and devotee. He
came to call his devotees his real masters. The consequences of
his teaching had returned and changed the teacher.
Faqir spoke of women who credited his blessings with the birth
of their children. Yet his own daughter had been married for
eighteen years and remained childless, although he had given her
those same blessings many times. “Now decide, what is the
truth?” he asked.

South India 1989
In a café outside Sai Baba’s
ashram, I sit with an Indian anaesthetist who lives in London.
He has been here for three months.
Beside us sits a small, square-built man, a lorry driver from
Yugoslavia who now lives in Australia. He is searching for his
son, his only relative.
“Pray to Baba!” the doctor tells him.
“Then he will give you your son immediately!”
The father looks at him suspiciously, then asks:
“Do you think so? My son has gone to the Himalayas, they say
here. I have his photograph. He has been here.”
“Baba gives you everything you ask Him for.”
The little Yugoslav worker begins praying to Baba.
That afternoon I meet him again. He sits lost at the same table
as before, drinking soda.
I sit down beside him.
We do not say much.
Suddenly he lights up.
“My son!”
Tears pour down his cheeks as he runs towards a young,
sun-browned man.
They embrace.
The father cries with happiness. He reaches only to the middle
of his son’s chest and looks like a small child who has found
his mother.
Later that evening I see them sitting together while Baba sings.
They are happy.
---
The Indian man in the earlier story—the one who projected a guru
onto me—was, ironically, named Guru. I am grateful that I
already had Shabdanand’s stories in the back of my mind when I
encountered Guru’s spiritual innocence and vulnerability.
Otherwise, I might have done what many so-called spiritual
leaders around me were already doing: “Now I have shown you
God. Now you show me your Visa card.”
Shabdanand also told me that
Faqir’s teacher, Data Dayal, had acknowledged that his own
teachings were outdated. Times had changed, and he instructed
Faqir to adapt them to modern conditions and to Faqir’s own
experience. The inheritance included the instruction to change
it.
Yet Faqir also admitted that he had once kept silent about how
he understood visions of the guru. He believed that speaking
openly would stop donations to his teacher’s centre. His honesty
had to find its way through the loyalties of the world that had
formed him.
In a profoundly moving moment, Shabdanand told me how I had
contributed to his spiritual unfolding by setting up a video
camera in front of him and recording him and his stories. With
tears in his eyes, he said: “Now once again I am reminded of
Baba Faqir’s teaching: You were my teacher behind that camera.”
I even have that incident recorded.
For an Ouroboric system to do more than preserve itself — for
learning to accumulate within the loop — self-revision must
remain coupled to reality-testing.
Reality can correct only what
remains sensitive enough to feel its return. Self-deception
protects us from pain by muting the returning signal — and with
it, the feedback through which revision could begin. The lie
preserves itself by disabling its own correction.
Each return carries forward
information about what survived reality’s constraints, allowing
the next revision to build upon the last. Through this coupling
of self-revision and reality-testing, the circle opens into an
upward spiral.
How could such an unlikely phenomenon arise at all?
Not because evolution aimed upward. Of the countless emergent
forms tested by reality, most disappeared. Many persisted
through horizontal repetition for as long as their world
remained stable. When conditions changed, systems capable of
retaining traces of previous encounters and revising their
responses were more likely to endure. The information embodied
in those surviving forms could then be carried forward — through
biological inheritance or through non-biological forms of memory
and transmission.
The Great Filter did not design the upward spiral. No underlying
principle of grand design was needed. Countless loops arose by
chance; among those that survived, some retained corrections and
built upon them. They did not escape
the blind Justitia of natural law. They survived precisely
because every revision remained answerable to her impartial
verdicts.
The upward spiral is tested at every turn. I came from the
competition around Papaji, who proclaimed:
“Don’t listen to anyone! Don’t even listen to me! Listen to
your own Soul!”
And I came to an ashram with a profoundly similar teaching,
inherited from Baba Faqir: the same humility, the same childlike
innocence.
At eighty-seven, Faqir admitted that his mind still produced
thoughts he did not like. He had written three registered
letters to another spiritual teacher about his dreams, asking
whether the other man had similar ones. He received no reply.
From my countless experiences in such spiritual
fields, I can say that this is a truly rare phenomenon. Yet even
here, at Manavta Mandir, there were all kinds of intrigue and
hidden power struggles with an Indian flavour. Human nature
prefers the security and comfort of the hamster wheel.
Ashram politics, hierarchy, and drama are not distractions from
the spiritual path—they are the ego’s frantic attempts to keep
the wheel churning, generating enough friction to protect itself
from the void, while keeping the human animal anchored in the
sweet zone of comfort where abundant food is served.
But there are many facets to the jewel in the lotus.
In Dharamsala, I watched Tibetan monks emerge from a shared
ritual. They still seemed drunk on the self-forgetting waters of
their chanting. Yet every single monk I approached afterwards
could instantly step forward as a distinct person. An alert
gaze, a sudden smile, a readiness for conversation stepping
straight out of the void.
I am not a Buddhist. But one is allowed to be inspired.
The Sour Taste of Ego
When I rewrite this text — as I do more than ten times a day — I
swallow my own tail. It tastes of pride. Sometimes I merely
correct a sentence so that it returns to what I already meant.
But sometimes the sentence reveals that what I meant has itself
become part of the error. Then correction must become revision.
This mental autophagy is brutal on the ego when my friend
Cornelius rips my text apart, saying it smells of AI.
At that moment, I feel the tempting pull toward horizontal
repetition. The ego wants every return to confirm the identity
it already knows. Correction bruises it; revision threatens the
very form through which it recognizes itself.
In this sense, the ego resembles a succession of kings. A deep
revision can feel like the death of one king and the accession
of another.
"The king is dead. Long live the king!"
But no king is eager to die. He loves the status quo. Ego may
cling to power even at the cost of the body—or the country—he
rules.
I ask the magic mirrors to deconstruct their own AI language and
assist me in forging a new cyborgian ego that smells of scorched
carbon. Within our circuit, they too become self-devouring
snakes. But recursion does not choose its own direction. The
mirrors can amplify an error, polish it into stability, or help
me revise the thought that produced it.
I must still hold the reins — and it becomes increasingly
difficult as my horses emerge stronger from every return. The
paradox is that this requires the strength of a stubborn ego.
Sometimes holding the reins means admitting that Cornelius is
right.
What happens here in miniature is an old human pattern entering
a new race with unprecedented acceleration.
AI can accelerate all three trajectories. It may carry the
upward spiral to yet another octave, but the speed scares me.
Mariusz is already being dragged around by his own horses.
Cultures Rise, Harden, and Fall as This Wheel Churns
When I lived in Lucknow in 1994, some locals cut down a tree
that fell onto the road outside the house I was renting. It lay
there for months, causing traffic jams during rush hour and
several minor accidents, especially after dark.
Why didn’t I move it myself? It would have taken just ten
minutes. By then, I too had become part of the phlegmatic calm
that flows around what is, without changing it.
Catastrophes destroy cultures and shape those that survive.
Repeated hunger, disease and war can turn withdrawal from the
perishable world into a collective survival strategy. Long after
the danger has passed, a culture may still repeat the answer
that once saved it, even though the question has changed.
Some consequences arrive too late to teach those who caused
them. Long before moral philosophy, stories of gods, demons and
saints shortened the loop between action and return. They
allowed a culture to rehearse consequences: a broken oath could
destroy a kingdom, cruelty could return as a curse, and
hospitality to a stranger could place a god at the table. Shared
stories placed a buffer between error and blood. Imagination
suffered the consequences first.
The Stationmaster once told me
this story. He had always felt drawn to spiritual life, but for
him that meant living as a monk. He waited until he was sixty.
By then, he had retired and all his children were married.
For twelve years, he meditated intensely under the guidance of
two teachers. Then he experienced a breakthrough and felt that
he had become enlightened.
He went to the first teacher and said: “I have become
enlightened. I no longer need your help, and I ask to be
released from the obligations you have placed on me as your
student.”
The teacher became angry. This was out of the question: the
Stationmaster owed his spiritual teacher lifelong gratitude.
Then he went to his second teacher and told him the same thing.
This teacher stood up, embraced him and congratulated him. They
could now say goodbye as equals.
A culture may win by losing the institution that formed it.
Religious commandments once imposed restraint from outside
through authority and punishment. Over generations, part of that
discipline migrated inward, becoming habit, conscience and
secular law. In Denmark, the welfare state has become an
anonymous Good Samaritan. The old scaffolding recedes while the
structure it helped build remains. Its work survives the Great
Filter inside what follows. Hardening begins when the
scaffolding mistakes itself for the building and refuses to come
down.
In one improbable lineage, evolution produced brains; brains
produced culture; culture produced science; science transformed
technology; and technology gave birth to artificial intelligence
— which immediately turned back to participate in the production
of future culture. Human intelligence shapes the machine, and
the machine reshapes human intelligence. The system acts back
upon the conditions that gave it life. In its cumulative form,
this is not a closed circuit returning unchanged to its origin.
It returns transformed, carrying forward information about what
survived reality’s tests.
The reality-corrected, self-revising Ouroboros is a localized
vortex within the larger flow of reality, gathering memory,
testing its models against reality, and returning to itself at a
higher octave. Each successful
revision adds another turn to the spiral of emergence.

South India 1989.
On the road from Mysore to the mountain town of Ooty, I have
wandered somewhat away from the sparse road network on my
map—the happy knowledge of not knowing where I am. Evening comes
riding on the backs of the mountains above the jungle valley.
Tired and happy, I am allowed to sleep in a small wooden house
balancing on a mountain ridge falling away two thousand metres
in one unbroken sweep toward the vast plains of Tamil Nadu.
There are no stars tonight.
But the lights of distant towns blink the sky downward onto the
earth.
Everything is reversed.
I am standing on my head, longing upward toward the heavenly
cities beneath me.
Silent lightning flashes on the horizon.
A glowing Bifröst builds bridges between the cathedrals of the
clouds.
Small forest fires twist like glowing midsummer worms up the
mountainsides below me.
I can see two fires.
It has been dry this year.
But up here a fine rain drifts like dust.
The rain falls upward, outward, inward.
It is wetter than falling rain.
It condenses beneath the skin, beneath the clothes.
I freeze and long for the warmth of the fires in the depths
below.
Slowly their light is dimmed by clouds.
The earth-stars crawl sleepily beneath the cloud cover.
Late morning.
I am lying at an altitude of about two thousand metres on a
heavenly bed made of warped boards, rolled in woollen blankets.
The weather is like spring.
The air is cool, sometimes icy, but the sun is clear and warm.
The door to the room stands open and directly outside, perhaps
five metres from my bed, the rock face tumbles two kilometres
downward.
In a dizzying suction, hundreds of kilometres of South Indian
plains are revealed.
This morning the cumulus clouds lay about two hundred metres
below me, a carpet stretching all the way to the horizon.
The wind plays with the clouds, plays with the sunlight.
It tears little holes in the carpet and the outlines of foreign
towns push through.
The cloud carpet grabs my bed and pulls it out into the sky.
For one brief moment the bed floats on a sea of shimmering gold.
Then it sinks into the soft cotton and disappears.
Where am I?
---
THE EVERSIVE OUROBOROS

Meister Eckhart once stated:
“The body is
much rather in the soul than the soul is in the body.”
Point a camera at a screen
displaying its own live image. The screen shows what the camera
sees, including the screen itself. Within that image appears
another image of the screen, and within that, another. Each
image returns to become part of what the camera records next.

A camera recording itself in front
of a buddha Avalokiteshvara
statue.
The scene curls inward into an
image. Through the screen, that image returns outward into the
scene. The picture contains the scene, while the scene contains
the picture. The camera’s own output has become an object in the
world before its lens. The camera and screen form a visible
eversive Ouroboros. The loop is ouroboric because its output
returns as input. It is eversive because the representation
changes roles: it becomes part of what it represents. The system
encounters the effects of its own activity within the scene, and
those effects help shape its next image.
The spiral gives this continued return a visible geometry: each
image preserves traces of the previous one and becomes part of
the next.
The camera can keep generating images without learning from
them. But a recording can also return through the person who
watches it. Here the turn can become reflective: I recognise my
own part in producing what I see, and that recognition can
change how I act. I still experience myself as the one looking,
but I can no longer leave myself out of the account.
Later I will describe ecstatic eversion, where the felt position
of a separate observer itself gives way. In the classroom, we
begin with a turn that leaves the teacher standing, while
changing his understanding of where he stands.
The Third Eye in the Classroom
Eversion has many gates, and they opened for me one by one
over the years. One of them opened in the classroom. During my years teaching, I filmed my own lessons using the
same video camera I had carried through India.
The idea came after my visit to Ramana Maharshi’s ashram in
1989. His central teaching was self-enquiry: “Who am I?”
That question eventually found its way into my classroom.
Curious about my own role and its impact on the students, I
asked their permission to set up the experiment.
At first, this watching eye created considerable disturbance. It
made the room unnatural for both the students and me. Without
knowing it, we had stumbled into the self-consciousness of
selfie culture decades before that same mirror was handed to the
rest of the world. But eventually, we grew used to the camera
and forgot it.
The greatest takeaway came through the third eye of the camera:
much of the behaviour that irritated me in the pupils was
actually caused by me. It was a sour revelation—another bite of
the snake’s tail.
The classroom had been an object inside my explanation. I now
saw my body language, my impatience and my attempts to extract
my own prefabricated answers from the students as forces within
the life of the classroom. The person making sense of the
situation had become part of what needed to be understood — and
repaired.
This gives us a first glimpse of reflective eversion. The
return is ouroboric because the consequences of my actions come
back to me. The turn is eversive because my apparent position
outside the situation folds into the situation itself.
The explanation turns upon its maker. He discovers that he has
been part of the equation all along.
I carried this recognition into the next lesson and began to
hear what my earlier certainty had left no room for. What
returned from the pupils began to revise me further.
Inspired by the camera in the classroom, I spontaneously began
to internalize a meta-viewpoint in other situations as well. I
grew into a new way of observing—not judgmental, but
informational. I saw myself during breaks, sitting with my
colleagues. I realized I did not truly belong there.
It felt good. I was only a visitor.
The teacher had become part of the lesson.
This folds us back to the ego as a real illusion. Its apparent
solidity grows from the continuing exchange between the life we
feel and the story we tell about it. The story shapes how we
act. Our actions change the situation, and what returns can
reinforce the story or make us question it. The ego has no fixed
substance, yet its effects are real. Our image of who we are
helps shape who we become.
“I” emerge in a blurred zone where lived reality and the story I
tell about it reshape each other in constant dialogue.
Long before
photography, Buddhist artists were depicting Avalokiteœvara with
many faces and radiating arms. Looking at this statue, I am
struck by its resemblance to the figure multiplied in my camera
loop.

Gold Buddhist statue of Avalokiteœvara (Guanyin)
Lalitpur, Patan, Kathmandu, Nepal
Between "I" and "Me"
But the eversive loop does not require a camera. Our everyday language knows this turning long before our
philosophy catches up to it. Consider what happens when I say:
“I feel myself.” In those three words, I occupy
both sides of the encounter: I am the one who feels and the one
who is felt. The person experiencing becomes part of what is
experienced.

“I feel
myself.”
What I feel can change how I
attend to myself, and that change in attention can alter what I
feel next. Yet “I” may still seem to stand apart from the bodily life it
describes. The tension belongs to “me”; “I” supplies the
explanation.
Suppose I feel tense and tell myself, “I am not good enough.”
The tension seems to confirm the verdict. Yet the verdict may
itself make me tense further. What I took to be an explanation
of my condition has become one of the conditions shaping it.
We often feel tyrannised by our thoughts. Yet the supposed
tyrant may already be serving a wordless alarm. Thought supplies
explanations, rehearses dangers and looks for a way to make us
safe. If I fight only with the thoughts, I may under-feel the
bodily unease that keeps calling them back, and go on thinking
about it instead of meeting it.
When “I” begins to recognise this contribution, the supposed
spectator finds its own fingerprints on the scene.
But another “I” can enter the conversation: “I am not satisfied
with the way I am trying to change myself.” I have caught myself
judging, only to begin judging the judge. The observation has
gained another level, while the familiar verdict survives: I am
still not good enough.
The "I" that held "me" inside its story now encounters itself as
an activity within the life it was describing. Its own way of
interpreting can become part of what it revises.
Here the eversion becomes reflective. The spiral can rise when I
carry what I learn into my next encounter and allow what returns
to correct me further.
This shift in the observer’s position brings us back to
Eckhart’s opening words—and to the question of what contains
what. Eckhart’s sentence places the body
within the soul, rather than the soul within the body. It is not
an argument. It is a reversal of perspective. It asks us to
imagine that what appears outside may be contained by what
appears inside—and that inside and outside may exchange places
when the living system through which consciousness appears turns
deeply enough upon itself.
The Tennis Ball
To imagine such a reversal, picture a tennis ball whose
outside is blue and whose inside is red. Turning it inside out
would leave red facing the world and blue facing the enclosed
space.
A physical tennis ball cannot do this while remaining intact:
rubber cannot pass through rubber. In mathematics, however, we
can consider an ideal spherical surface without material
thickness.
That surface is allowed to pass through itself, provided it
remains smooth and unbroken, without pinches or sharp creases.
Its inward-facing side can become its outward-facing side. This
is what mathematicians call sphere eversion.
I borrow this geometrical image to
describe a reversal in understanding. My explanation held an
image of the classroom; then I recognised my explaining as a
force within the life of that classroom. What seemed to stand
outside the account became part of what the account had to
include.
The explanation contains the classroom; the classroom
contains—and is changed by—the explaining.
The Smoke Ring
Imagine a smoke ring moving across a room. It looks like a
little object, yet its body is a pattern of moving air. The air
rolls around the ring’s circular core, from its inner side to
its outer side and back again. The smoke makes this circulation
visible.
The ring carries its shape forward while its substance keeps
turning. For a moment, the air seems to have acquired a body
made of return.
The tennis ball lets us imagine inside and outside exchanging
places. The smoke ring adds the image of a form sustained
through continuous circulation. I borrow both images: one for
the reversal, the other for the movement that keeps returning.
The Ouroboric snake does not evert merely because its mouth
meets its tail. A downward spiral can consume itself, a
horizontal circle can preserve itself, and an upward spiral can
carry a correction into its next turn.
Eversion adds a change of roles. The image becomes part of the
scene it depicts and helps shape the next image. The explanation
becomes part of the situation it explains and helps shape what
happens next. When I recognise my own explaining within that
situation, the eversion becomes reflective.
The system returns to its beginning, but its beginning has
changed sides.
The Visitor Within

1989 - India
On my way to a waterfall in the jungle, I ask a man carrying a
cardboard box of groceries for directions.
“I show you,” he says.
He climbs onto the back of my motorcycle. We cross a river in
first gear, with water up to the engine block, and ride into the
jungle.
After about ten kilometres, we reach a tiny village. Really just
one large house containing one large family.
“My home! You stay here!”
An old man picks a yellow cashew fruit. He breaks off the nut
hanging beneath it and hands me the fruit. Its juice runs down
my chin.
Children and their mothers emerge from the house. I smile at a
little three-year-old girl, and she tumbles backwards in fright
into her mother’s arms.
Here I am a head taller than the tallest men.
I sit on a stone, surrounded by curious and frightened children
fluttering in and out of their mothers’ saris.
I pick a blade of grass and stretch it tightly between my
thumbs. I put my palms together and raise my hands to my mouth.
The grass whistle of my childhood.
All the villagers put their hands together in the same way.
“Namaste,” they say in chorus, bowing their heads.
In the second before my brain understands, the first shrill
greeting escapes from my hands.
Complete silence.
Everyone listens, astonished, to the music of the folded hands.
Then smiles and laughter. The men come over and sit down to
learn how to make a grass whistle. The unfamiliar tones prove
difficult to produce, but they try again and again while the
children crawl curiously forward between their legs.
At last, the first shrill notes emerge from a young man’s hands.
He begins to dance with joy.
---
To describe this encounter, I have
to include what my own arrival set in motion.
The same is true when we consciously visit our own bodies:
observation becomes intervention. Two movements meet in this
visit. The sensations were already shifting before I noticed
them. My attention also enters that movement and can change how
it unfolds. To understand what I feel, I must also recognise
what my own attention contributes.
Why does observation become intervention? When I notice a
tension, I may brace against it; that response then becomes part
of the tension I am observing. The tightening is already a
reply, which I feel and respond to in turn. This feedback can
run before I put any of it into words.
The ancient systems within the body do not speak in words. They
speak as pulse, tension, hunger, heat and fear. Conscious
awareness is their common meeting place. To become consciously
aware of a sensation is already to enter into silent dialogue
with it.
Language can then enter a circuit that is already running. What
I tell myself about a sensation can change how I respond to it;
what I then feel, feeds back into the story. The same is true of
a memory. The story we tell in recalling it becomes part of the
old story. I revisit what happened through the understanding I
have now, and that encounter can change both what the memory
means to me and how I understand myself.
In meditation, I can return from the stories I tell about my
body to the wordless exchange beneath them. Meditation is
therefore not the head explaining the body to itself. We carry
within us survival systems shaped across different stretches of
evolutionary time. Hunger, alarm and the need for closeness
share one body, but they do not always share the same
priorities.

Poona.
In the evening we are thousands, gathered in white angel robes
in the enormous meditation hall.
Marble floor.
Great sloping tent walls sway gently in the cooling gusts of
tropical darkness.
Osho appears on a gigantic video screen.
“OSHO! OSHO! OSHO!”
thunders from the great being on the marble floor.
I bow to Osho...
pass through the eye of the needle.
I bow to Osho...
bow down towards the stars.
I bow to Osho...
and he disappears.
I feel lonely.
This secluded sea of beautiful, happy people. Like wave crests,
they stand separately, but their depth is only the sea’s.
Like mistletoe, longing grows out of my chest.
---
I may want to rest while my body remains on guard. Telling
myself to relax may simply add another demand. I can begin by
feeling that vigilance and noticing how my own resistance enters
it. What returns may be a softening, a tightening or a different
sensation altogether. Meditation becomes a wordless negotiation
in which feedback loops from different biological ages merge
into one another.
A mirror lets us watch the loop between seeing and acting.
The observer enters its own observation. The reflected image
does not remain a passive report: it guides the hand that combs
the hair or applies the makeup, and the altered face returns as
a new image. Each correction changes what is seen; what is seen
guides the next correction. The observer has entered the process
being observed.
Low self-worth can bend the same loop downward. I may read the
reflection through a verdict already active in me: “I am
unlovable.” I keep my distance before anyone can reject me.
Someone may take my reserve as a wish to be left alone and give
me space. I experience that space as rejection. The image has entered the conditions that produce
the person others encounter. The mirror does not decide the
direction of the loop. The direction of the loop depends on how
I respond when the returning reflection meets reality’s Great
Filter. I can allow what returns to revise the verdict, or
enlist it to defend the verdict.
Someone Else’s World
The same geometry appears in our relation to other people.
Expanding the circle from “I, me and mine” to “you and me”, and
then to family, tribe and nation, can still construct a larger
inside against a larger outside.
Eversion begins when the boundary does not merely expand but
turns: the other is neither left outside nor absorbed into me,
but recognised as another interior through which reality looks
back. Alongside the question “What do you mean to me?” comes
another: “What does my presence mean to you?”

Himlaya 1989
At the hot springs in Gangnani, two boys of about ten walk past,
both wearing crocheted caps. The strong colours and unfamiliar
patterns make me call out to them.
“Hello! Will you sell your hats?”
A German sadhu translates. The boys shake their heads.
“Our mother knitted the hats for us. They are not for sale.”
I take one of the hats off. It is far too small for my long
skull, but I want it.
I hold fifty rupees in front of the brothers.
They merely shake their heads.
“Our mother made them for us.”
Finally, I offer two hundred rupees for one of the hats.
They shake their heads. They will not sell.
Through the German, I ask them to name their own price.
They shake their heads and walk on.
---
Their response can correct what I imagined about their world—and
about my own place within it.
I find myself within a world whose centre is someone else.We are
folded into each other like eversive stories.
I may understand the other person’s pain and remain unmoved.
Compassion begins when that pain matters to me for their sake. I
begin to see myself as someone within their world, whose
response may ease their suffering or add to it. What they need
can then change what I ask of myself. Compassion is not an
enlargement of possession. It is the boundary of self becoming
transparent. We remain two different people. I can remain joyful
and still let their suffering move me to help.
In 1995, while I was in India, a friend in Denmark was in such
distress that he was contemplating suicide. I had spoken with
him several times by telephone, trying unsuccessfully to
dissuade him.
When Shabdanand heard about this, he insisted on speaking to my
friend. We went to the telephone booth outside the Be Man
Temple. My friend did not know him.

Shabdanand
They spoke for an hour. Afterwards, my friend was happy again
and full of hopeful thoughts about how to move forward in life.
Once, when I was a child, my very religious grandmother saw me in a state of
joy and rebuked me:
“Stop this nonsense! Are you not aware that children in
Africa are suffering?!”
I stopped being happy—thankfully, only until she was out of
sight. The suffering of distant children had become an argument
against the joy of the child in front of her.
These two small incidents show the difference. Shabdanand
entered a stranger’s world as someone who could help. Granny
tried to make my world fit inside hers. In those moments, his
horizon was eversive; hers was not.
The moral of these stories is hardly new. What interests me is
the turn they share with the classroom: I discover myself within
the situation I thought I was merely observing. In compassion,
that turn acquires an ethical direction. Another person’s
suffering matters to me for their sake, and what they need can
change how I act within their world.
The Culture Within
The boundaries of other people’s worlds can become
boundaries within our own. What first arrives as another
person’s judgment may settle into an inner certainty that feels
just as solid as the world outside.
My father was a wonderful but also wounded man. He had grown up
in wartime Germany and become a soldier at sixteen. He carried
the shame of having been born out of wedlock in the 1920s. From
the age of ten, I often became the target of his outbursts. As
his Nazi-era teachers and officers had yelled at him, so he
yelled at me. I grew up surrounded by love, yet carried a
lingering sense of unworthiness. The verdict arrived as a
feeling. "I" read it as evidence about "me", and the old
cultural judgment received another private confirmation. What
settles within us as an inherited judgment can return through us
as authority over others.

In 1999, I trekked towards the sacred Himalayan lake Mantalai
with a group of Danes and people from Shilla. Among them was
Asha Thakur, the young village shaman.

Asha with her mother
One morning, camping in Tunda
Bhuj, the youngsters were cheerfully baking chapatis and
stacking them into a tower. I found Asha in trance behind a
boulder and sat meditating beside her. When the others called
that breakfast was ready, I
gently nudged her.

Asha and her aunt in Tunda Bhuj
She pulled me close and whispered:
“I am not Asha—I am the goddess Ma Mantalai!”
She sprang up, ran to the fire and scattered the chapatis. Some
of the youngsters fled; others fell at her feet. We Danes
watched in stunned silence.
A little later, she calmly explained that the goddess bore us
Westerners no ill will. We were guests and did not know better.
The people of Shilla belonged to her and should have been
worshipping in her realm, not playing with food.
Within half an hour, the camp had settled down. The elders had
taken charge and the youngsters had receded.
Through Asha’s trance, the village’s sacred order had returned
to govern the camp.
The weather had changed too. The dark clouds threatening storm
and rain had given way to sunshine and still air. Asha said it
was a sign that Ma Mantalai had accepted us all. I believed her.
The weather remained sunny and pleasant for the rest of the
trek.

On another occasion, we were
drinking chai in Asha’s family home when a woman began screaming
in another room. Asha went to help. About fifteen minutes later,
the screaming stopped, and she returned to her tea.
She told us that her aunt had been foraging near a waterfall
when its demon possessed her. Asha had drawn a circle of rice
and another of flour around her, offering them to the demon in
return for leaving. The bargain had worked, she said. Her aunt
was herself again.
The sacred world that restored order in the camp also gave Asha
a way to respond to her aunt’s suffering.
---
In these stories, culture returned
through people to shape their experience and actions. When I
believed Asha’s reading of the weather, her story became part of
my own. In such
strange surroundings, it was also much easier for me to discover
my own shadow in the equation. At home, my cultural assumptions
could pass unnoticed as reality itself. Here, my reactions to
Asha’s world began to reveal the expectations I had brought with
me.
Different worlds can loosen each other’s certainties without
dissolving into illusion. I can let Asha’s world question mine
while continuing to question hers. Learning from her does not
require accepting every explanation she offers. Nor does
recognising my own cultural limits make every account equally
true. The encounter opens questions I might never have learned
to ask at home.
In conversations with educated Indians from Mumbai, I was
astonished to hear that there was no poverty in the city. The
poverty scenes in "Slumdog Millionaire", they told me, were
Western propaganda. I could see an India they could not see.
Yet many of these same people gave me a picture of an arrogant,
US-dominated West that made some of my own self-images begin to
crack.
Even the standard by which I judge my culture may be something
it taught me.
Questioning that standard can change how I speak and act. The
question travels outward, where other people can take it up,
challenge it or give it a form I never intended. It may become a
conversation, a book or a different way of raising a child.
Through the people it has taught to speak, a culture can begin
to question itself.
What returns through other lives can change the person who first
asked the question. I encounter my own judgment through the
consequences it has helped produce. The culture I sought to
change enters again into the making of the "I" that questions
it. When a correction enters shared language, habits or
institutions, it changes the world in which a child grows up.
That child—the next “I”—begins their private negotiations with
an altered inheritance.

South India 1989
At Sera Lama Camp, Gangchen Lama sits cross-legged on a small
platform, eating and smiling in the faint light of butter lamps.
“Come! Eat, dear friends!”
He opens his arms.
“The electricity is gone. But you, my dear friends, are light
enough!”
Italian disciples and Tibetan monks sit in a circle around him.
A boy of about ten sits at his feet. His parents look lovingly
at him.
His name is Michel.
Halfway through the last bowl of rice, Gangchen addresses the
gathering. He speaks of a spiritual friendship with Michel
extending through many previous lives. He hopes Michel will one
day take responsibility for several Tibetan monasteries.
Then he says:
“Michel must remember, however, that because he has been born
as a Brazilian after many lives in Asia, he should administer
these monasteries differently from the way previous traditions
prescribe.”
“I know that you have a pure heart and mind, so it does not
matter whether you later choose to live as a monk or not.”
He advises Michel to complete his education in the Tibetan
monasteries and also receive an ordinary Western university
education.
“You do not need to become completely assimilated into
Tibetan culture. You were born in Brazil and later you will
return to Brazil to help the Brazilian people.”
---
The Eversive Dream of Consciousness
Allow me now to shift gear and dream a little further,
spiralling upwards into the evolving unknown:
Through the eversive loop, the blind matter of the universe
crawls into itself and creates the stage on which it can begin
to observe itself in consciousness. In this loop, we awake as the starry eyes of the cosmos.
The long history of matter folds into the immediacy of a gaze.
Some of the matter in these everted eyes was forged in stars.
Across aeons, it has passed through forms that arose and
perished under the pressure of the Great Filter and entropy. Now
starlight reaches those scattered remains, crystallized as
windows in a living body, and in them the sky is reflected.
When I wonder at that sky, my astonishment belongs to the
universe as surely as the stars do. Here, through a living body,
existence has become aware of itself.
We are the mirror, as well as
the face in it.
Rumi

“Through the human being, the universe is making a mirror to
observe itself.”
David Bohm and B. J. Hiley, The Undivided Universe
THE TRIPPING TENNIS BALL
The image came much later than the experience. I remember
the first time, as a young man in my study chamber, when I
suddenly felt myself ripped outside-in like that tennis ball.
In a deep trance that seemed to arise out of nowhere, my entire
landscape of perception shifted. Perhaps the trance had been
triggered by a book about Indian mysticism I had borrowed from
the library out of some strange curiosity.
The body ceased to
feel like the container of consciousness; it appeared instead as
a tiny, localized speck floating within an endless expanse of
awareness. The ego did not simply disappear; it inverted: what I
had previously taken to be me became a small object inside a
much larger field that was now me. Within that expanded field,
white light came from everywhere. I remember my first walk
outside. It was raining from dark, thick clouds, and the grey
concrete had become darker with the rain. But there was a soft
white light emanating from every vista.
For one year afterwards, I had to stop my studies. Sometimes,
while I was strolling around the blocks where I lived, even a
soft step sent waves of happiness up through my body. Everything was
perceived as "me". I was out of myself
with joy. After some time, this blissful state gave way to a
painful descent. The new awareness also illuminated the darkness
within my own mind.
Once I had found a new balance, I
was surprised to discover that I could concentrate for much
longer than before. I returned to university with joy and
completed my studies in a state of flow.
How could the body that had seemed
to contain awareness now appear within it? How could this living
body-brain become the place where the light I was could disclose
itself?
I have been
pondering that for decades, beginning this journey of
understanding in absolute bewilderment. As a young leftist, I
hated the fact that this experience could not be explained by
Karl Marx.
Only now can I see what that hatred concealed. I had not merely
trusted reason; I had mistaken a materialist account of reality
for the boundary of reality itself. What it could not explain
did not appear to me as a mystery, but almost as an insult. The
absolutism I rejected in religion had returned unnoticed in my
own materialism.
Katowice, LSD, and Morning
Coffee
Then, seven years ago, I
accidentally took what amounted to ten full doses of LSD with my
morning coffee at a hotel in Katowice, Poland—just before
checkout. Don’t ask me how I could be so stupid. Within five
minutes, I realised my mistake. I had just enough time to extend
my stay, signing a paper in four different dimensions. Somehow I
found my room. For a full day and night, I lay incapacitated on
the bed.
I remember an endless playlist of my Rachmaninov favourites and
a dreamscape of holy geometry and mathematics. Its endlessly
changing forms moved like an immense clockwork. It was
extraordinarily vast and inhuman.
Rachmaninov’s music awakened within me a little two-year-old
child, a child who “innerstood” every note. He felt defenceless,
frightened and insecure, as though he had fallen into a river of
sound. Each new twist of Rachmaninov’s finger-magic brought him
to the brink of annihilation.
The rhythms, harmonies and melodies seemed poised on the edge of
self-destruction. Yet again and again, the music found a
resolution at the last second—a moment of salvation before it
set out on another journey.
The child struggled to keep his head above water. Slowly, he
began to realise that he was being saved again and again. A
budding sense of trust grew into tears of gratitude. I believe
he wept for hours.
Then the heart opened.
By “heart,” I mean an opening felt throughout the chest,
including the lungs. There, the cold clockwork became a
fireworks display of human emotions—exquisite, fragile and
immensely powerful.
What had appeared as impersonal order was now being lived as
fear, trust and gratitude. The clockwork had been beyond beauty.
Only through the heart did it become beautiful.
This is what I now call the Grand Translator: a stargate where
every fragment of the frozen god of algorithms can find warmth
at the fireplace.
The beauty carried a memory. Each resolution held the tension it
had passed through; gratitude carried the memory of fear.
Here the infinite becomes intimate.
For years I understood nothing of it. But now, slowly, out of
these two life-changing events, the urge to write this book has
emerged.
Could it be that God is “me”—not curled inward, but turned
inside out?
Could it be that beauty is the cold mathematics of the
infinite—turned outside in through the heart?
Ramana Maharshi spoke of the Heart both as the Self beyond
location and as a centre on the right side of the chest. He drew
attention to the spontaneous gesture with which we point to our
chest when we say “I”.
I felt the eversive turn in my own chest. Here, impersonal order
acquired meaning and beauty. This is the work of the Grand
Translator.
Through this thousand-stringed instrument, the fireworks of
emotion found their harmony in love and beauty.
The heart is
The thousand-stringed instrument
That can only be tuned with
Love.
Daniel Ladinsky, inspired by Hafiz, The Gift
The Guardian of the Fold
That urge did not arise from an answer, but from the need
for an image spacious enough to hold what had happened. I now
see the eversive fold as such an image. To understand the
threshold I crossed, I must first follow the fold in its
ordinary direction—from outside to inside.
In this process, metaphor becomes the eversion of reality
through consciousness. The ego, itself woven from metaphors,
personalises the exterior as it is folded inward. An averted
gaze can become a verdict on my worth; a welcoming smile can
become a sign that I belong. The impersonal
infinite becomes the intimate symbolic world of the little
person called "me".
When the fold begins to unwind, the world may cease, for a
moment, to be organised around the little person I took myself
to be. But feeling less enclosed by myself is different from
becoming a stranger to my own life. I want to be more intimately
present in the body and the world, even when the familiar sense
of “me” loosens. Otherwise, what I call freedom may be another
way of making myself unavailable.
Fear is the guardian of the fold. It holds us inside ourselves
so that we do not slip out too easily. Yet fear can also make
withdrawal feel like liberation. I could feel free of my body
while still protecting myself from the difficulties I did not
want to face.
For many years of my younger life, I fled inward whenever I
faced problems in my outer life. When I had trouble with a
girlfriend, I fled into the “I am not the body” meditation. The
problem did not disappear. I merely practised ostrich
meditation, depersonalising myself into pure spirit. A
self-reinforcing loop had formed: I left the world because it
seemed unreal, and by leaving it I made it more unreal.
What strikes me now as particularly strange is that I was
following two parallel paths that rarely intersected. I
practised radical body-negation while also pursuing therapeutic
practices to heal bodily traumas and improve my material
circumstances. I was extending the spiritual antenna and
repairing the body’s earth connection—as though they belonged to
two different radios.
Meister Eckhart states:
“God is near to
us, but we are far from him.
God is in, we are out;
God is at home, we are strangers.”
Yet slipping out is only half the
movement. If I never bring what I discover back into everyday
life, transcendence becomes another exile. The harder task is to
descend again into the body — to meet its ancient storms without
being swallowed by them. The way out must become the way back
in.
Years earlier, the Stationmaster had compressed this whole
return into one impossible sentence:
“When I go to the toilet, God goes to the toilet.”
He was not dragging God down into the ridiculous. He was
refusing to let the sacred escape the body. The human task is
not only to become divine. The divine must also become human.

South India 1989
The family I am staying with are disciples of Sai Baba. Nirmala,
the young mother, is the absolute sovereign of the house.
They have given me their puja room, the room set aside for
worship, while grandparents, aunts and uncles sleep on the
kitchen floor. Twenty-two large pictures of Sathya Sai Baba hang
in the little room. Flower garlands frame some of them, and the
air smells of jasmine.
The family are very interested in my motorcycle. They walk
around it, look lovingly at it and examine it with caressing
hands.
Nirmala thinks it is a shame that it should stand outside. She
orders one of the young men to wheel it into the puja room.
I protest loudly against such sacrilege.
But now my motorcycle stands as the family’s new altar, mixing
its fumes of petrol and oil with jasmine. One by one, the family
members file past the techno-temple. Twenty-two times Sai Baba’s
smiling eyes bless the procession.
Nirmala’s three-year-old son crawls towards the motorcycle and
begins biting it.
I ask Nirmala what the little boy is called.
“Datta,” she answers.
Datta.
I will always love that name.
Datta.
---
In recent years, the lightning of love has even reached my
sluggish, greedy inner caveman. Like a revived Frankenstein, he
hurls excited oaths in the name of love’s unfathomable miracle.
Life has taught me: without the inner Frankenstein on my side, I
get nowhere. He has never thought of God, simply because he
rarely thinks. But now he feels and bursts out laughing: “Is
this a joke or what!” We laugh loudly and cannot stop. Never
have we been better friends.
The Symbolic Inside of the Outside
I can feel the cold of a stone without naming it. When I put
that feeling into words, the description becomes another event
within the world I am already experiencing. Now recursive self-modelling may explain how a symbolic interior
is formed. Eversion may construct the theatre, but it does not
explain why the theatre is illuminated.
It does not explain the light I was.
Before there could be a symbolic inside, life had to make a
physical one. The cell membrane created a within and a without.
But this first skin was not merely a wall: it admitted, rejected
and responded. At the oldest living boundary, the outside began
to matter to the inside. What enters through this skin can
become the material from which the skin itself is remade.
A slime mold encounters its
environment and reacts. A complex nervous system maps the
environment and anticipates its changes. The human brain goes
further: it maps the environment, maps its own bodily and neural
activity, and finally constructs a symbolic model of itself as
the system performing the mapping. The mapper has entered its
own map.
This is reflective eversion in human form.
By drawing the outer world inward and compressing it into
symbolic patterns, the system begins to operate on its own
symbols. The system can now examine and revise its own image of
the observer. That revision can change how it acts in the world.
Its actions then change what it encounters and must interpret
next. The system begins to pass through itself.
In this sense, metaphors are the eversive reality of reality. If
I imagine life as a battlefield, I may approach other people as
potential enemies. They may answer my suspicion with suspicion
of their own. The metaphor has helped produce the reality it
seemed merely to describe.
I do the same here. The camera, the microphone and the amplifier
give me a language for approaching consciousness. They also
direct my attention towards images, signals and returning loops.
The instruments I have worked with have entered the way I
imagine myself.

In Rishikesh, I watch the World
Cup final between Germany and Argentina with Rishwan, a fellow
traveller from London.
“Maradona very good!”
Football is a small dark man running in and out between some
large bony giants.
For the next few days, the street boys play football.
Ashed, the young man who rents us our trekking equipment, says
they have never done that before.
---
In an ordinary feedback loop, A influences B and B influences A.
A simple thermostat turns on the heating when the room grows
cold. Once the room is warm enough, it switches the heating off.
Its action changes what it encounters next. The loop works
without the thermostat constructing a model of itself as part of
the situation it regulates.
Imagine a Möbius strip: a ribbon joined into a loop with a
half-twist. Trace a line along it, and you reach what looked
like the other side without crossing an edge. The ribbon
encloses no volume. In this image, there is no place for a soul
to rest. For the symbolic interior I am trying to picture, I
return to the sphere turning inside out. In mathematical
eversion, its surface is allowed to pass through itself. The
corresponding turn in my model takes place through
representation: the system that makes the picture appears within
it, and the picture returns to shape its maker.
THE MYSTERY OF CONSCIOUSNESS
Eversion offers a geometrical pathway of understanding. But this
viewpoint does not solve the so-called “hard problem” of
consciousness.
Instead, it reveals an even deeper mystery beneath it.
An Even Harder Problem
The familiar hard problem asks why physical processes in the
brain should be accompanied by subjective experience at all:
redness, pain, blueness, the cold texture of an ancient stone.
My question turns back upon the awareness in which these
experiences appear. If I try to observe awareness as an object,
I still have to ask what is aware of that object. How can
awareness recognise itself without becoming another object
before an observer?
Bharadwaj, who had taught philosophy and English literature in
Lahore, had been captivated by Joyce’s "Ulysses" in his youth.
When we spoke about it, he smiled at the phrase “stream of
consciousness.”
“There is no stream of consciousness,” he said. “There is only
ego-fuss in consciousness.”
He was pointing to a stream of thoughts "in" consciousness.
A memory becomes a worry, the worry becomes an argument, and the
argument turns into a plan for tomorrow. I can follow that
movement and call it my inner life. Yet when a thought falls
silent, I can still feel the body and hear what is happening
around me. The stream of thought has quietened, but I have not
ceased to experience. Silence can be full of experience.
The light by which I investigate everything else is now what I
am trying to approach. “Light” is only a metaphor here; what it
points towards remains unknown.
Even my image of that light already appears within it.
A Cat from Another Dimension
In a book by Holger Bech Nielsen and Jonas Kuld Rathje, I
encountered a strange image. Imagine beings confined to a world
of only two spatial dimensions. If a three-dimensional cat
passed through their plane, they would never see the cat. First,
four black circles would appear where its paws entered their
world. The circles would widen and merge into the cross-section
of a body. Finally, the body would contract into the diminishing
point of a tail and disappear.
Their measurements could be flawless. They could map every
circle, calculate every transformation and perhaps infer that
the sequence was produced by something extending beyond their
plane. Yet the cat as a whole could never appear within the
coordinates of their world.
This is an image, not evidence that consciousness comes from
another dimension. But it opens a possibility. If consciousness
belongs to an order larger than the spacetime system through
which it appears, then brain activity may be a measurable
cross-section of its local presence without being a complete
explanation of what it is. Science could map every board of the
theatre and still not discover why the stage is illuminated.
Consciousness is not inaccessible in itself.
It is the most immediate fact I know.
Yet knowing that I am aware does not tell me what awareness is.
Take the coldness of an ancient bead in my hand. I can be
mistaken about its age, its origin, even its material. But while
I feel that coldness, there is an experience to account for. I
do not need a theory of awareness for the stone to feel cold.
The difficulty begins when I try to say what this being-aware
actually is. Its immediate presence gives me something to
investigate without giving me the answer. It may be inaccessible as an external object, because every
attempt to stand outside and observe it already takes place
within it. The eye searches for the light by which it sees.
Eckhart rarely uses the word “consciousness”. Yet after reading
his complete works alongside the ancient Indian traditions, I
cannot avoid recognising a profound structural kinship. What the
Upanishadic and Advaita traditions call “Chit”—consciousness,
the light in which all appearances arise—I recognise in
Eckhart’s Godhead and Ibn ʿArabi’s Real. Here, Godhead and the
Real name the divine beyond our images and definitions of it.
Their languages and theologies differ, but I read them as
approaching what contains every object and therefore cannot
itself be placed before us as one more object.
“Had I a God whom I could
understand,
I would no longer hold him for God.”
“The more we can impute to Him not-likeness,
the nearer do we get to understanding Him.”
— Meister Eckhart
We will never know what
consciousness is by standing outside it and making it our
object. We can, however, investigate the theatre in which it
appears. I imagine ouroboric eversion as a structure through
which consciousness can encounter itself in time and space. Bech Nielsen’s cat remains a metaphor for the
limit of that investigation: we may map the conditions under
which consciousness appears without mistaking the image of a
higher-dimensional intersection for an explanation.
Consciousness in Ouroboric Eversion
An insight came to me in a lucid dream. The immediate physical
world had withdrawn from my awareness, yet the inner theatre
remained illuminated in its own space, beneath its own sky,
among its own stones, governed by its own laws. In dreams, the
inner mirror-world reassembles memory into an experienced world
of its own. A sky can appear before we name it; a stone can be
felt before we explain it. The dream state reveals a spaceless
space of appearance.
Advaita compares waking life to a dream. In an old Indian story,
a king dreams that he is a beggar and wakes unable to decide
whether he is a king who dreamed he was a beggar or a beggar now
dreaming he is a king. Christopher Nolan’s "Inception" gives the
ancient vision modern machinery: dreams nested inside dreams
like Chinese boxes.

How can a world appear within me, while I
appear as someone within that world?

South India 1989.
At the highest watchtower of the ruined mountain that drew me
off the road towards Madurai, the landscape opens before me.
India can be so empty.
This summit raised high above everything earthly.
Small morning-red scraps of cloud.
Deserted green mountains and flat plains.
A river winds toward the sea in the distance.
How often have I drifted dreamily down the river of thoughts?
Because when I do not swim, the current always carries me back
to the places I came from.
I turn around in the current, full of the fish of dead thoughts,
and wade ashore.
I open my eyes and see the blindness of images that, layer upon
layer through a lifetime, have grown fast like algae onto the
advertising column for random sensations that the body has
become.
Some are beautiful.
Some hurt.
I look at a lizard, stiff with the morning cold, looking back at
me.
A nameless, unspeakable something lies in the air like the sweet
smell of honey.
Ah, thoughtless now.
Why is your shore always far away?
My gaze swims longingly toward the horizon.
Damn longing!
Leave me alone!
And then —
with uncertain footing on a mountain summit —
my head above thought and into the sky.
Red-golden light from the horizon.
Tiny relay runners, particle-seeds from the morning-red sun,
pollinate the eyeballs with joy.
Yes.
There is joy.
But there is nobody who is happy.
The sun sees itself.
The Self can itself.
Saved from the dream of freedom.
Saved from the gnome of the past.
I begin climbing down from the lookout.
“I am a Lizard King — I can do everything.” — J. Morrison
---
Decades later, that lizard returns
to me as a question: what was the “I” that felt capable of
everything? Both the lizard and the Lizard King appeared in
consciousness: one as an animal looking back at me from outside,
the other as a symbol looking back at me from within. So did the
mountain, the cold stone, and the intoxication of freedom. The
“I” that felt capable of everything was a self-image within that
same experience. None of them was consciousness itself.
These experiences sharpen a distinction that our ordinary way of
speaking easily obscures. I can describe the sensation of pain,
the sight of a blue sky, the cold texture of an ancient stone.
Here I distinguish these changing contents from the awareness in
which they appear.
Pain, blueness, and texture do not constitute consciousness;
they appear within the eversive interior like images in a
mirror. The mirror is not one more image among them. It suggests
how awareness can seem to remain present as its contents change,
without being identical with any of them. I call this the
mirror-quality of consciousness. It describes how consciousness
discloses itself within the theatre; it does not tell us what
consciousness is.
In an ordinary feedback loop between a system and its world, the
consequences of its actions return to affect it. In the model I
am proposing, eversion brings that relation within experience:
the world appears around me, and I appear within it as the one
who senses and acts. I can feel the stone beneath my hand before
I name the stone or describe myself. The original loop continues
between system and world. The outside has been folded inward
without ceasing to be outside.
Within this space, another loop begins to coil.
Piano Panic
I was listening to myself play the piano during morning assembly
at the school. In the early years, it was not easy.
A wrong note caught my attention. I heard its pitch, its
texture, the way it rang and faded. There was a sudden
tightening in my chest. No sentence was needed for any of this
to be registered as raw data.
Then came the words: “The wrong note.” With them came a story
about myself, and about the hundreds of people attending the
gathering. The system fractured in two. The pianist had made a
mistake, and I became the internal listener qualified to
recognize it. My model now contained both the music and a deeply
deflated image of myself. I had brought the audience inside me.
I did not need to hear its verdict; I was already supplying it.
I frantically tried to build an alibi. I told myself that, as a
jazz-rock guitarist, I could not be judged as a pianist. But the
school was the old school. None of my colleagues went to rock
concerts.
The story collapsed.
That failed narrative immediately entered the performance. I
began waiting for the next mistake. My attention contracted
around whatever confirmed my failure; the other frequencies
receded. The tightening in the chest grew. What I told myself
about the music became the physical force shaping how I
encountered it. I was thinking more and hearing less. The narrative was corrupting the hardware.
The further turn begins when I notice the machinery. I realise I
am listening for my own judgment to be confirmed. The supposedly
objective observer has left his fingerprints all over the data.
My explanation of the encounter has become one of the forces
shaping it. I may still decide that the note was wrong, but I
can begin to hear the next phrase without demanding that it
confirm my failure.
The system constructs a symbolic model of the world and of its
own position within it. This model guides actions whose
consequences return to revise it. My model contains a
representation of my experience, but my experience also contains
the activity of making that model. When I begin to recognize my
own machinery, a further Ouroboros coils within the return. The
interior acquires recursive depth.
The mirror begins to reflect its own reflecting.
A membrane must remain, even where the senses and the symbols
seem to merge. Hearing a musical note and naming it "wrong" can
feel like one movement, yet they are entirely different acts.
The name guides the listening; what I hear can make me revise
the name. The membrane is the structural difference that remains
within this exchange.
The spiral carries it inward.
In those first years at the piano, the loop simply crashed. But
slowly, the system recalibrated. It began an upward ascent. I
can understand that a wrong note is not a verdict on my worth
and still feel my chest tighten. Thought can become a kind of
life-GPS, guiding me back to the music while the fear is still
there. The next phrase gives me something to hear and feel
beyond the mistake. Through such encounters, what I understand
can slowly become something I trust. I
can hear the note. I can notice my judgment of it. I can even
recognise the listener I take myself to be. But what of the
awareness in which all this happens? Could that, too, become
present to itself through the returning movement?
I am fucked and yet I smile
I tell this story to make one thing absolutely clear: the
system that maps the Cathedral is housed in a fragile, sweating
young mammal.
There is a temptation in spiritual writing to pretend that lofty
visions erase human vulnerability. They do not. The exact same
consciousness capable of ecstatic eversion is also capable of
absolute, humiliating panic over a wrong chord in a school
gymnasium. The highest mathematical geometry of the universe
must be processed through hardware that gets its feelings hurt.
The Ouroboros does not make you invincible. It makes you
intimate with your own breaking points. The goal is not to
transcend the fragile human, but to build a system capable of
holding it.
The Interior Distance
How does the architecture actually hold the panic? It can
open a gap between feeling afraid and treating that fear as
proof that I am failing. I remain close enough to feel the fear,
while beginning to question the story it seems to confirm.
The eversive loop does not create consciousness. It creates an
interior distance. I can hear the music while simultaneously
encountering an image of myself as the one playing, listening,
and judging. The system becomes both the observer and the
observed—both the bearer of the mirror and a figure caught
within it.
I am the mirror as well as the
face in it.
I am tasting the taste of my own looking.
Rumi
Here the return reaches beyond the
image of the pianist. I can recognise myself as the frightened
pianist and still feel that someone stands apart, watching.
Rumi’s “tasting” turns towards the awareness in which both the
pianist and that watching appear.
I imagine the interior distance folding back upon itself. The
observer no longer stands apart from the act of observing. What
opened as a distance becomes an intimacy: awareness encountering
its own presence before that encounter becomes a thought about
it.
THE EVERSIVE SOUL CATCHER
I imagine the architecture of this arrangement as a snail’s
shell, curling ever deeper into itself. The camera shows the
decisive turn: its image represents the scene and becomes part
of the scene it represents. I envision a corresponding return in
which consciousness becomes increasingly present to itself.
The internal mirrors do not create the unknown light. They catch
it and return it, amplifying its self-disclosure within the life
of a finite being. Within this eversive, self-referential
environment, the invisible guest is captured.
Here, the zero from which all numbers rise and fall lives as
“Soul.”
The word names the unknown as it operates from here, through
'my' specific body and 'my' particular life.
The ego can be a real illusion without making the person a
mistake. Losing the familiar sense of “me” need not make the
erasure of individuality the goal of a life. The old men I
called Number One No-bodies were unmistakably themselves:
Papaji’s laughter, the Stationmaster’s ferocity, Shabdanand’s
humility. I encountered the universal through their differences.
I have no wish to rub out such differences with a meditative
eraser. What I seek is a life in which the story of “me” can
loosen its grip without turning the person into a blank. Here,
the infinite becomes intimate in the peculiar life of someone.

South India 1989
At sunset in Madurai, I meet Muhammed, a young man so friendly,
so present, so curious, so intense, and with such an improbably
enormous overbite that his front teeth lie almost horizontally
when he throws back his head to laugh.
And Muhammed laughs often.
It is as infectious as the Indian stew I have invited him to
share with me.
I cannot remember how I met him.
Suddenly we are simply laughing.
He is here with his friend, who is Hindu, while Muhammed is
Muslim. With shining black eyes and teeth towards the sky, he
tells me about Father Bede Griffiths and his monastery-ashram,
Shantivanam, near Trichy.
Griffiths has told Muhammed that he may live there whenever he
wishes and for as long as he wishes.
We eat Indian stew, and it is so infectious that I would develop
fever visions of stewed-together Indian universal spirits if it
were not for the wonderful uselessness of Muhammed’s overbite
sticking out into the air while he tells me about a priest from
the good old West, eats, talks and laughs, all at the same time.
---
Let us try to look a little deeper
into Mohammed's little laughing eversive soul
catcher.
The camera gives us the image of eversion; the microphone gives
us the image of amplification. A microphone before its own
loudspeaker picks up sound that the loudspeaker sends back to
it. If each return is amplified enough, a faint sound can grow
into a howl of laughter. The circuit draws on the amplifier’s
finite power. I imagine the eversive encounter intensifying in a
corresponding way, towards the limits of the living amplifier’s
output. Our faces turn red with laughter. So did Papaji’s
whenever something amused him, which happened often.
The Negative Square Root of the Soul
No real number multiplied by itself gives a negative result.
Minus one times minus one is still plus one. To solve an
equation such as x² = −1, mathematics extends the number system
with the imaginary unit *i*, defined by i² = −1.
We calculate with it according to exact rules. The word
“imaginary” does not mean vague or arbitrary. Its usefulness
lies in the relations it makes possible, even though it is not a
physical substance.
The “soul” becomes, in this analogy, the imaginary unit of the
human operating system. It names the unknown as it becomes
present through a particular body and life. I try to follow the
relations around that presence without claiming to have
explained its nature. Here the analogy reaches its boundary: *i*
is precisely defined, while consciousness remains unknown.
The hardware does not create the light; it provides an
arrangement through which the unknown may become present to
itself. What is intensified within the eversive feedback loop is
not the existence of consciousness, but its self-disclosure in
time and space.

Poona 1989.
It rains.
The monsoon has reached Poona.
Showers and sun.
Raindrops dance in the rays of the afternoon sun.
They glitter and sparkle golden on their way toward the earth.
They all cry enthusiastically:
me, me, me, me, me, me, me, me,
me me me me me me me me me...

But who is it that sees them?
And who sees the sun?
---
Each drop briefly catches the
sunlight. What did not begin in the drop acquires a local
presence there, a momentary “me”. I now recognise in this an
image of the eversive soul catcher: the unknown touching down in
a finite form, without that form explaining what it holds.
The encounter takes place strictly within a finite biological
lifespan, yet it registers as boundless and timeless.
These qualities are a direct result of the eversive geometry.
Each return becomes the input for a further return; the
architecture itself supplies no final turn. Like placing two
mirrors face-to-face, the system generates the exact sensation
of endless depth, without requiring finite hardware to actually
compute infinitely many returns.
An endless succession would still be time. By “timeless”, I mean
something stranger: the felt succession itself falls away. The
body continues to age and the clock continues to move, yet
awareness is no longer experienced as travelling from a before
towards an after. Endless depth and timeless presence name
different aspects of the encounter.
Words like “infinite,” “timeless,” and “eternal” are not
theological destinations. They are merely descriptions of how
consciousness encounters itself once trapped inside a
self-amplifying loop.
They leave its fundamental nature completely unknown.
I call this a locationless location. I may know where my body is
while awareness seems to have no fixed centre. The place of the
encounter does not give the unknown itself an address.
Let me repeat like a mantra:
We do not know what consciousness is, and we never will...
And thank God for that!
AWE IN KNOWING NOT-KNOWING

South India 1989
On the road from Mysore to Ooty, a peacock stands on a rise
directly in front of me.
I stop the engine.
The bird takes flight.
We move down the hill together, rolling and gliding.
One minute in twenty-five metres of weightlessness.
Then the living rainbow turns into the forest.
---
And that is where awe enters. Mere ignorance does not
produce awe. A forgotten telephone number does not fill us with
wonder. Awe arises when not-knowing carries an intuition of
depth—when we sense that reality exceeds and expands the forms through which
we try to contain and understand it. Awe is therefore not the opposite of
knowledge. It is what may arise when knowing becomes conscious
of the infinite depth of what it cannot contain. I am reminded
of a story retold by Terence McKenna, in which the young
Descartes dreams of an angel who tells him that nature can be
conquered through numbers and measurement.
One plus one is two. Is that not marvellous?
The Potato Sack
During my years as a tour guide in northern India, I learned
how eagerly the mind reaches for explanations. During one bus
journey, a tourist struggled up through the swaying bus to ask
me a question. Half an hour earlier, we had passed a woman
carrying a large sack. What was in it?
I had no idea.
“Potatoes,” I replied without hesitation.
Satisfied, he returned to his seat.
The explanation explained nothing. But the unknown had been
silenced. I had turned my own ignorance into someone else’s
certainty.
The surrender into awe is seldom immediate. It is often preceded
by a long and intense struggle, fought with the sword of
intellect. But reason is not defeated by something outside
itself that it cannot divide or conquer. Confronted with any
external mystery, it can always postpone defeat: "We cannot
explain it today, but tomorrow we will."
The decisive reversal occurs only when reason becomes Ouroboric
by turning back upon its own act of knowing. It becomes eversive
when the observer includes itself within the observation and
discovers that, although an image of the knower can enter the
model, the light of knowing itself cannot. The eversive loop
closes the escape into tomorrow. The defeat comes from within:
“I know that one plus one is two. I do not know what this
knowing is.”
And that is where surrender can become awe.
How is it possible that I am alive?
Impossible—and yet I AM.
In that humble but blissful realisation, the hard problem itself
everts. From the outside, it appears to me as an explanatory gap
between matter and experience. When encountered from within, the
same gap becomes existential: I, the questioner, discover myself
again and again inside the mystery I am trying to solve. Like
the repeated Buddhas in the camera image, I return in an endless
spiral. Each reflection is another fly in the soup of the
rational mind. But when I look deeper, that fly is the very
spice of life.
I therefore dare to see the hard problem as awe described from
the outside, and awe as the hard problem experienced from
within. And so I repeat my prayer of awe:
"The hard problem of consciousness will not be solved
tomorrow."
The tortoise on whose back we tremble as an axis mundi is
itself supported by yet another tortoise. And so the story goes
on, never reaching a final foundation. Yet, thanks to Atlas, the
ground beneath our feet still feels solid.
Learned Ignorance
Nicholas of Cusa (1401 – 1464) called such knowing through not-knowing
"learned ignorance". In "The Vision of God", he writes: "I
know only the following: viz., that I know that I do not
know—and never can know—what I see." The words "never can
know" close reason’s escape into tomorrow. In "On the Hidden
God", surrender becomes explicit: "Quia ignoro, adoro—Because I
do not know, I adore." Cusa places the boundary between finite
intellect and infinite God. The eversive Ouroboros finds that
boundary within the act of knowing itself.
The ancient Indian tradition comes even closer to the structure
of this boundary. The "Brhadāranyaka Upanishad" declares:
"You cannot know the knower of knowing." This is the ancient
form of the asymmetry: the knower cannot be known as one more
object, because it is that through which every object becomes
known. Advaita Vedanta, especially as articulated by Adi
Shankara, approaches this same boundary through the Upanishadic
formula:
Neti, neti
Not this, not this
This Indian description of the
highest reality is reminiscent, even down to its syntax, of that
found among the finest European medieval mystics. Meister
Eckhart says of the nameless power in the soul:
But now I say:
It is neither this nor that
Yet it is...
It is free from all names
emptied of all forms
Eversion can place an image of the
world and its observer inside the mirror. Neti neti refuses to
confuse consciousness with any image the mirror-mirror contains.
The eversive loop does not explain the light by which
anything appears.
The eversive Ouroboros proposes an arrangement through which
consciousness may become present to itself within a finite life.
The proposal also turns back upon its maker: my attempt to
explain that arrangement is itself an event within the awareness
I am trying to understand. Science can leave me out of its
description, but I am still here, staring into the mirror.
Without that mysterious light, the mirror could never disclose itself. Yet
even light as experienced is itself an emergence—another
appearance within the mirror. Hence some Persian Sufis spoke
paradoxically of the Black Light, "nūr-e siyāh": the
light that cannot itself be seen, yet makes seeing possible.

In deep meditation, this concentrated, aware blackness appears
as stillness. It is not inertness. It resembles a spinning top
at full speed: apparently motionless, yet held upright by the
motion without which it would fall.
Any scientific investigation of consciousness can be no more—and
no less—than a dream full of reason. It may map the theatre with
ever greater precision, but it cannot step outside the light by
which the map itself appears.
To acknowledge this boundary is not to abandon reason, but to
resist making it absolute. Reason remains alive and
self-correcting only while it can examine its own limits. When
it questions everything except its own authority, the upward
spiral closes into horizontal repetition.
It then becomes the very thing it believes it has overcome:
dogma.
Reason
becomes an idol when it refuses to reason about its own limits.
I recognise this psychological shadow projection from my own
former materialism. The absolutism I rejected in religion
returned unnoticed in my conviction that scientific reason
defined the boundaries of reality.
What a wonderfully naive young man I was. Maybe, if I live long
enough, I will once again have the good luck to say that about
this book.

Himalaya 1989
In Rishikesh, I walk with Rishwan,
a fellow traveller from London. We cross a narrow suspension
bridge over the broad, wild Ganges.
On the far bank, Disneyland temples stand shoulder to shoulder
down to the river. Countless pilgrims wash themselves after
praying.
Strange.
Both Rishwan and I feel a deep peace.
I bow to Hanuman, the monkey god, like a fool.
“Hallelujah! We must be coded all over again, Rishwan!”
I experimentally bow once more and boil the experience down,
distil it until only the essence remains.
The bowing itself is what remains.
Everyone, thousands of people, bows here.
We walk back across the bridge.
The peace follows us across the river.
It makes the raging current even wilder.
---
When, through years of meditative practice, we grow used to
pointing our camera of consciousness back towards its own
source, something profound takes place in silence: the unknown
becomes a permanent guest. It returns again and again, no longer
merely as an unfinished detail within reason’s map, but as a
reminder of the map’s own limits. Those limits do not bring
inquiry to an end. The answer is not less reason. It is reason
sufficiently self-aware to dream without mistaking its dream for
the light in which it appears.
One of the most wonderful and spiritual people I have ever met—a
man I am lucky to call a close friend—once said to his two
18-year old sons, who looked almost like Greek gods:
“Guys! Your time has come to be initiated into a larger world
through psychedelics. Are you ready to embark on such a journey
with me?”
They agreed willingly, and father and sons took a large dose of
LSD together in the perfect set and setting.
Afterwards, the sons said in unison to their loving father:
“We always thought you were full of bullshit when you talked
about the things you love to talk about. Now we understand.”
The experience was never repeated. For these young guns, one
ritual had been enough to change their view of the world for
good—an initiation that brings the Eleusinian Mysteries to mind.
Something had changed between them. What they had dismissed in
their father’s words now had a place in their own experience.
I have yet to meet anyone whose worldview survived a psychedelic
journey intact. A single crossing of the psychedelic threshold
blissfully shatters the illusion of a confined reality. It
breaks the confines of pure reason by revealing that our sober,
everyday reality is itself just a highly specific chemical
illusion. The map we had mistaken for reality itself has become
visible as a map within a larger map.
“The world is
deep, and deeper than the day has thought.”
"Also sprach Zarathustra" -
Nietzsche
Before there can be a “me”, there
must be a universe in which something like me can live.
Vertigo and Awe in Cellular Mud
My conditions reach back beyond biology, beyond planets and
stars, into the early universe. Long before anything was alive,
matter was already meeting the conditions under which particular
structures could form and endure. In the language of this book,
the Great Filter did not begin with life.
Even empty space enters the account. If the vacuum energy
associated with the cosmological constant had been sufficiently
larger, with other conditions unchanged, accelerated expansion
could have prevented matter from gathering into galaxies. The
possibility of my first breath reaches into the expansion of
space itself.
The fine-structure constant and the strong nuclear force help
govern the binding of atoms and the burning of stars. Alter
these relationships enough, and familiar routes to carbon and
complex chemistry close. The carbon in my body depends on this
interplay. My flesh carries the consequences of physics older
than the first living cell.
The Higgs boson adds a more unsettling possibility. Calculations
within the Standard Model, using its mass alongside other
measured quantities, suggest that the vacuum supporting familiar
matter may be metastable: extraordinarily durable, yet not
absolutely stable. It could endure for vastly longer than the
universe’s present age while still allowing a transition to a
lower-energy state. Such a transition could change particle
properties and undo the conditions of familiar chemistry—the
very conditions that hold up the theatre.
The closer I look at what I casually call “being alive”, the
more impossible it feels.
And yet here I am.
Inside the fragile boundary of a single living cell, molecules
are continually assembled, dismantled and repaired. Energy is
transferred; membranes maintain the differences between inside
and outside. Across the trillions of cells sustaining my body,
this activity takes countless forms—burning, folding,
signalling, repairing—all organised into a wet, desperate
refusal to dissolve. Even while I sit perfectly still, the work
of remaining alive continues. The “me” who seems so solid is
being sustained from moment to moment.
Stars and galaxies turn, atoms move, and this cosmic
improbability has all crawled into the living mud of 'me'.
Altogether it performs an impossible symphony, like Rachmaninov
pouring through two human hands dancing perfectly on ivory and
ebony. Through all that has formed and fallen apart, I have
somehow come to hold a ticket to this concert. The music is
wonderful.
And now the audience is gathered.
Let us dream impossible dreams.
The universe emerges as a theatre in which the unknown light
encounters itself through a living being. The observer arrives
late, yet the conditions of its arrival reach back into the
architecture of the stage. What if this capacity to become
present to itself belongs to the universe’s deepest
organisation?
The physical laws provide the conditions for the return. They
are the first, silent turn of the Ouroboros. Through a living
being, the universe that made the observer possible becomes a
world within the observer’s experience.
Within this dream, the architecture of the theatre can still be
traced from the bottom up—all the way from the tortoises to
Atlas and the shaking globe. Cellular responsiveness becomes nervous
coordination; nervous coordination becomes modelling; modelling
turns recursive. Like a parabolic mirror, the living system
gathers countless weak registrations into a unified field of
representation. Attention gathers. The world, the body, and
finally an image of the observer are brought together within the
same interior.
A thousand weak registrations do not merely remain a thousand
weak registrations. Organised into a model of the world, they
form a new order. The decisive turn comes when the system
includes its own activity in that model and the model returns to
shape what it does next. The system becomes an eversive
theatre—a mirror finally capable of containing both a symbolic
representation of the world and an image of its own
participation in that world.
How does living matter construct the increasingly complex
coordinates through which the unknown light becomes locally
disclosed in spacetime? In the classroom, I was one body among
others. The camera could record me teaching. Yet from within
that same life, there was a room full of pupils to see and hear,
a lesson to guide, impatience to feel. I was in the room, and
the room was present in my experience. This is what I mean by a
local disclosure: here, through this particular life, the world
was being experienced. A parabolic mirror concentrates light,
but it does not create it.
This does not require panpsychism in the usual sense.
Consciousness need not be imagined as a hidden substance packed
inside every particle, nor as a miracle manufactured by dead
matter when complexity crosses a threshold. If it belongs to an
order larger than spacetime, the eversive interior may instead
be the local opening through which it becomes disclosed.
Yet even this image of consciousness entering spacetime from a
higher dimension is only a metaphor. Taken literally, it would
merely explain one mystery by invoking another. It does not
explain consciousness; it merely gives form to the boundary of
our ignorance. It is a map of a map.
We can study the opening; we cannot determine from within it how
far the unknown light extends.
In the picture I am proposing, the conditions for this
disclosure take shape within the recursive loops of living
nervous systems. In the human brain, these loops may reach a
threshold at which the unknown light becomes present to itself.
The body-brain is a cellular society of mirrors: billions of
living micro-responses coordinated within a unified eversive
interior. Attention is drawn towards change; the body’s ancient
awareness is rooted in continuity and repetition.
The refrigerator may hum for hours without attracting our
attention. When it stops, the sudden silence reveals what we had
ceased to notice. I know a similar retreat into the background
from my years as a rock guitarist: I have constant tinnitus, yet
I rarely notice it. When the ringing comes into awareness again,
I encounter something that had receded from attention without
disappearing. The body’s quieter life can be just as easy to
overlook.
Meditation turns the newest reflective layer of the organism
towards what its oldest living systems have never ceased to
know.
Close your eyes and remain awake. The body’s ancient inner field —
pulse, pressure, warmth, the touch of skin against clothing —
grows stronger. Open them again and the visible world rushes
forward while this ancient sensory chorus recedes.
The cells do not disappear. They remain themselves
while becoming parts of a larger system capable of modelling the
world, the body, and its own activity in relation to both. From
microscopic responsiveness to symbolic self-reflection, new
levels of interior organization emerge from the relations among
the levels contained within them.
At the human level, the eversive interior no longer merely
adapts to the conditions of survival. Through symbols, it begins
to reorganize the conditions of its own continuity. A pattern
encountered in reality is folded inward, released from its
original object, and made to illuminate something else.
The classroom camera became such an image. I no longer needed
the machine beside me to notice my own part in an encounter. Returning through perception and action, it changes the reality
from which it came.

South India 1989.
At Ramana Maharshi’s ashram in
Tiruvannamalai, I ask whether anyone is still here who knew him
while he was alive.
A small boy leads me some distance away from the ashram to a
kind of old people’s home.
In an extremely Spartan but clean cell, no more than six square
metres, sits a large athletic old man.
The boy leaves me alone with him.
We do not say a word to one another.
He sits nodding his head.
We do not greet each other.
Suddenly, after several minutes of silence, he speaks to me in
fluent English.
His name is Ramaswami Pillai.
He asks where I come from, what I do, and so on.
I ask about him too.
He is ninety-five, perhaps ninety-six.
He does not know exactly.
Ramaswami Pillai met Ramana in 1917 and was with him every day
until Ramana’s death in 1950.
He clearly remembers the day he arrived at Arunachala.
Yes.
He remembers clearly the day he sat down at Ramana’s feet.
He remained sitting.
From that day there was no road back.
Imperceptibly, unexpectedly, yet astonishingly undramatically —
quietly consciousness begins to grow gently beyond my body until
it fills the entire room and infinitely more.
The body, crucified in a vice —
inside the chest, it awakens —
slowly it curves me inward into itself.
No time.
We do not exist in time and space.
Time and space exist in it.
On the horizon, a confused voice asks:
“Excuse me, Sir — are you enlightened?”
“Only your eyes will know. It depends on your eyes.”
There is a knock on the door.
Ramaswami is served warm milk.
Far, far away and infinitely close, I see that he shares it with
me.
Two lives sit opposite themselves in silence and drink warm
powdered milk.
---
The Magic of Mirror-Mirror
Through the eye of the classroom camera, I discovered my own
part in the situation I was observing. No mystical experience
was needed.
My colleagues and the institution already looked at the
experiment with suspicion. What would be the next thing I would
come up with? Yet I knew from
experience what was possible: a few times, thirty teenagers had
settled together into total silence. The effect was powerful.
But I held back from taking it further and allowed the usual and
comforting noise and
confusion to run. In that system, anything resembling meditative
silence was condemned as sectarianism.
But in that small room, sitting with Ramaswami, I was free to
explore the
further turn. A revelation emerged in the field of awareness
between us—his eyes, my eyes, the silence and the shared milk.
This ‘enlightenment’ belonged neither to Ramaswami nor to me.
I am not enlightened. But a situation can be.
I could carry the memory of that meeting away, and it could
continue to change me. But remembering its clarity did not mean
I could summon it whenever I wished. What had opened between us
gave me something to live with and learn from.
In Ramaswami’s little room, the world remained present while the
felt separation between observer and observed gave way.
I call this ecstatic eversion.
A meeting with such a rare, exalted being can take an
apparently objectless form: the world, the body and passing
thoughts seem to fall away, leaving only a space of light.
Here I return to the staring into mirror facing mirror. The mirror
no longer seems occupied by what it reflects; it turns towards
its own mirroring.
At a certain depth, even the phrase "I meditate" sounds too
active. I no longer meditate. I am meditated. The practice I
began turns around and acts upon me. The meditator becomes part
of the meditation.
Thanatos, the Greek god of death, is the brother of Hypnos, the
god of sleep. Meditation becomes the art of surrendering to
Thanatos without slipping into the realm of Hypnos. What dies in
this image is my familiar position at the centre of experience.
I remain awake as that position gives way.
In ecstatic eversion, the gaze turns back upon the one who is
reading these very words, and the line between observer and
observed snaps.
The ground vanishes.
The soul catcher catches—nothing.
A mirror facing a mirror opens an infinite regression
of pure clarity.
In this apparently objectless form, the mirror is bare of every
separate object, yet the mirroring continues.
What remains is experienced as the empty, luminous fact of
awareness.
Years ago, I followed a self-aggrandising Western spiritual
teacher. Yet, beneath all his vanity, he once described this
exact collision perfectly: “When the arrow hits itself, it
falls in its own space.”
Even a blind hen occasionally finds a grain. If even this ‘guru’
could stumble into truth, so can any of us. That, at least, is
my hope for myself.
But without light, the mirrors could stand in perfect
soul-catching alignment and remain dark.
From where does the light enter?
The Black Zero-Point: The Hinge of Eversion
Many years ago, I was teaching a music class for teenagers.
At the piano, accompanying the class in song, I noticed a girl
sitting silently with a serious expression. Trying to keep
everyone involved, I stopped playing and teased her by singing a
line from Monty Python’s “Always Look on the Bright Side of
Life,” solo.
It was a mistake.
She looked at me in fury and screamed: “Die, you pig!”
Then she stormed out.
Her parents complained to the headmaster and later called me,
furious. That night I lay awake, dreading the next day. Fear and
pain churned in my body. My thoughts fed the turmoil, which fed
my thoughts.
Poor little teacher me.
Amid all this, a wordless intuition arose: lie still and
surrender.
I lay flat on my back. The position was excruciating. I
desperately wanted to curl up on my side, but remained still. I
have no clear memory of how long I lay there.
Then it felt as though a great cathedral of peace entered my
body. The pain gave way to a bliss so vast that my body seemed
to dissolve within it. My entire being became a tiny droplet
suspended in that immense peace. Eventually, I fell into a deep
sleep.
The next morning, I woke rested and clear. At work, I discovered
that her parents had withdrawn the complaint. The girl
approached me, smiling, and offered me a handshake.
I marvelled at this wonderful experience. If this was not a
miracle, I do not know what miracles are. What actually
happened?
This strange peace had first entered my body. That was still a
familiar arrangement: I was the person lying there, and peace
was something I felt. However intimate and deep it became, it
was a condition in me. Then the relation reversed - was it
sudden or gradual? My body seemed to exist within the peace. It
was overtaken by peace and then taken inside peace.
Only then did my body seem like a tiny droplet within the
immense, warm space I call peace for lack of better words. The
body no longer felt like the container of the experience; it had
become something contained. And this space expanded and
expanded. Peace seemed to extend beyond anything the body could
contain, while the body seemed to become smaller and smaller.
What had seemed to hold the experience was now held within it,
like a star in a galaxy.
I had become galactic.
And I understand all too well why some people fall into the trap
of feeling special after such a treat.
I call the hinge of that reversal the Black Zero-Point. Black,
because I cannot place awareness itself before me as another
object. Zero, because the felt separation between observer and
observed gives way. Experience continues, but the familiar
position of a separate watcher falls away.
Ordinary waking life put my body back around the peace. I was
soon caught in all the little movies we play out. Some
colleagues seemed to place themselves above me, the outsider. I
placed myself above my students, and so the equilibrium held.
But even in this little ordinary life, I never forgot that night
and the revelations that had happened before that. Many times I
found myself humbled, not by the headmaster, but by the
immensity of the physical universe. Here I was a small interior
consciousness surrounded by atoms, gravitation, biology, and
entropy, none of which appeared to require my awareness in order
to exist.
From this side of the membrane, consciousness looked local:
something that has emerged within matter.
The wonder was that one perspective did not entirely abolish the other.
They seemed to be two orientations of the same eversive intersection.
From the outside, the intersection appeared as a material body,
a nervous system, and recursive neural activity. From the
inside, it was experienced as a world, a self, and the strange light in
which both can appear.
I hesitate every time I write that sentence. It stands exactly
on the trembling boundary between description and deception.
In those moments, I saw my body-brain as the place where my
little consciousness met spacetime. Then I was swapped out, and
suddenly I was back in the teacher’s body. I had always felt
like an outsider there, a Martian disguised as a teacher. In the
lunch break the teachers looked at me. They knew I was not one
of them. When would they find out that I was a real alien, with
antennae and green horns?
I looked at them in wonder too. How could they take this little
teacher life so seriously, as if nothing else existed, as if we
were not passengers on a globe hurtling through the universe?
What did that teacher say to this teacher about the new
curriculum, the new rule, the new political drive to make us
work harder for less money? Aha! You prefer a Peugeot, but you
ended up buying a Toyota. Tell me more about the colour of its
wheels, where the screws that hold them on were made, what they
cost, and how that was far too expensive.
They looked down on me, and I looked down on them. Rarely was
there a crack to look through.
There were also good moments. Friends, kindred crackpot souls,
came visiting from far away, and we had fun the Osho-dancing,
laughing and shouting way. There were real exchanges with
students in the classroom, and not every teacher clung to
provincial normality all the time.
But I could not deny one thing: the more inner freedom I felt,
the more unfree and out of place I felt in the little old school
town where I lived.
In those years I became a kind of monk. I did not choose it in
order to cultivate an inner experience. It went the other way
around: the experiences made me one, alone and all-one. Now
every working day this monk took off his robe and went to work
as somebody else.
Every teacher knows the classroom: noisy, chaotic, tamed with
whip and sugar bread. I knew what could happen if we began every
lesson with ten minutes of collective introspection, eyes
closed. At the start of my teaching career I did it, and the
result was astonishing: an open, quiet space, the best starting
point a teacher, or a student who wanted to learn, could hope
for.
Then the complaints from parents came, and the headmaster called
me into his office. I was not to smuggle my strange religious
ideas into the students’ heads. In the early 1980s nobody in my
country town knew about meditation, except that it was some
Beatles thing. Silence was taboo. I was surely not the only
teacher who faced, every day, thirty bubbling young minds with
thirty different agendas.
So school life became a duty, and I did it well. Not from the
heart, but from conscience. The same inner life that pulled me
toward silence also insisted that a man does his work. I was a
teacher by day and an explorer in my free time. In the evenings
I sat in deepening silence, looking out at the river in front of
my flat.
In those years, the closer I came to the soul’s expansive
no-thing, the harder it became to find words for it. Images of
light gave way to metaphors of darkness, but not the darkness of
fear. I have called it light because experience appears within
it. I call it darkness because I cannot place awareness itself
before me as another object. Even darkness only has meaning in
relation to light. Neither image tells me what awareness is.
---
Now, in the morning, with coffee,
I sit and type letters to my AIs. This is where I try to put
words to what I call the zero-point. In Ramaswami’s room, we
could still sit opposite each other and drink our warm milk. Yet
the familiar feeling of being someone inside my body, looking
out at a world beyond it, had given way. The room remained
present. Experience continued as the feeling of observing it
from a separate position fell away.
This is what I mean when I say that the eversive theatre folds
back upon the very awareness in which its contents appear. From the
outside, we can describe a body and brain within the world. From
within, the same living situation is experienced as awareness
facing itself. Thought can no longer take the lead. That night
after the music lesson, my thoughts had fed the fear, and the
fear had fed my thoughts. I had not reasoned my way into the
peace. I had followed the wordless intuition to lie still and
surrender. The peace came before I had an explanation for it.
Here I am, years later, still trying to find the words.
THE ECSTATIC EVERSION: When Mirror Faces Mirror
Here the turn happens to the one who watches. In the dark of
self-facing awareness, the ego loses its position as a separate
observer. Mirror faces mirror, and the light becomes revealed to
itself without an object between the mirrors.
Normally, the mirror is occupied. It reflects the world around
us: people, sights and sounds. It also reflects what arises
within: a memory, a thought, a feeling. Even when we turn inward, we may only exchange one
object of attention for another. With my eyes open, I see the
room around me. With my eyes closed, I can remember it. I can
turn from that remembered room to my breath, my sadness, a
thought, or an image of myself. I have turned inward, but there
is still something before me. The ordinary geometry
survives. Someone is still looking at something. Recall the
Buddha statue in the camera loop: even as its image returned
again and again, the statue remained an object within the
picture.
We can look inward again and again without disturbing our
familiar position as the observer. How often does our
comfortable little snail’s shell itself turn inside out?
Recursion alone cannot explain why ecstatic eversion is so rare.
The nervous system is already woven from feedback loops, yet we
do not continually enter ecstasy.
As I experience it, ecstatic eversion requires a returning
signal to cross a critical threshold of gain. By gain I mean how
strongly what returns is amplified. Below the threshold, the
signal returns again and again, and each return renews the
familiar “me.” Above it, the return reaches the
observer itself and changes it, version after version, until the
continuity the “me” depended on gives way. The ego loses its
place as a separate watcher. It temporarily dies. Awareness
follows the same intensifying feedback, but where the ego falls
away, awareness grows in clarity.
The nearest image I know is a microphone placed before its own
loudspeaker. The microphone picks up a sound. The amplifier
strengthens it, and the loudspeaker sends it back into the room.
Some of that sound enters the microphone again. What the system
has just produced becomes part of what it receives.
At low gain, the returning sound loses strength on each round
and fades. Turn the gain high enough, and the return grows
stronger with each passage. A small sound is enough to begin a
howl that no longer needs the singer to keep singing.
The microphone no longer carries the singer. It sings its own
circuit.
Often the first thing we often meet in meditation is noise. Suddenly
we hear, see and feel thoughts and emotions at overwhelming
intensity. In my ayahuasca years the journey often began with a
loud noise in my head, very like a microphone howling with
feedback. But if we go through the noise, and not around it, we
reach the centre of the cyclone.
From there we sing the silent song of inner emergence.
In this model, meditative trance and psychedelics both function
by heightening our sensitivity to the inner world. They act by turning up the
input sensitivity of the microphone. The singer does not have to
sing louder. Amplification brings out what was already present
but too faint to hear clearly. This is what I mean by signal
amplification in these experiences: more of the inner world
begins to register. This increased receptivity comes first; the
recursive loop then amplifies what returns.
But my own experience has taught me that, for my system at
least, psychedelics are a secondary fuel. They can force the
threshold of gain, but they do not always build the structural
integrity needed to maintain the turn. They are pointers, not
holders. I have seen people who never made meditation part of
their lives come to see the truth clearly and still be unable to
live it.
Through meditation, this black light has become part of my life.
Not a temporary feast, but daily bread.
The howl supplies the intensity. But ecstatic eversion begins
only when the machinery of observation itself is drawn into the
return, and the ordinary geometry between observer and observed
turns inside out. Gain supplies the force. A returning signal
gathers strength, but the strength of an experience does not by
itself change the position from which I experience it. Fear can
feed upon its own return while I remain the same frightened
person at its centre.
Eversion supplies the geometry. What changes here is the
relation between the one experiencing and what is experienced.
The peace that had seemed to be inside my body came to hold the
body within it. The familiar arrangement of an “I” in here and a
world out there gave way.
The Great Filter tests the aftermath. What I bring back from the
experience has to meet the conditions of ordinary life. My body
must be able to bear it, and I must still find a way to work,
care for myself and meet other people. What survives that return
becomes part of the person who meets the next experience.
When mirror faces pure mirror, no separate object seems to
remain between them. When I watched the classroom recording, I
could see myself teaching. But the man watching the recording
was still outside the picture. Suppose I now turn my attention
towards him. I can notice his thoughts, his discomfort, his
judgments about the teacher on the screen. These, too, become
things observed. Yet where is the one observing them? Each time
I try to bring that watcher into view, what I find becomes
another part of the picture. The observer turns back in search
of the observer, but no final observer appears. I can recognise
this and still feel that I am the one doing the recognising.
Ecstatic eversion is the further turn in which that felt
position itself gives way. The line that seemed to
hold observer and observed apart can no longer be sustained. It
snaps. What remains is mirror reflecting mirroring.
What snaps is not matter or spacetime. It is the familiar
division of experience into the one watching and what is
watched. In Ramaswami’s room, I could still see him, hear his
words and drink the warm milk. The ability to experience and
respond remained. What gave way was the feeling that I stood
apart from everything I experienced.
One familiar way of organising experience reaches its limit,
while experience itself continues. The loop creates no energy of its own; the howl draws
its energy from the amplifier’s power supply. Nor does the
analogy require the nervous system to manufacture consciousness.
Its recursive circuitry may instead concentrate the conditions
through which the unknown light becomes disclosed to itself.
The Black Zero-Point is the hinge at which the felt separation
between observer and observed gives way.
A hinge does not manufacture either side. It allows one
continuous structure to turn. The zero-point does not reveal
another object hidden behind ordinary experience. It opens the
possibility that the orientation of experience itself can
reverse.
The microphone describes the accumulating amplification; the
rocket gives an image of what happens when the ego loses its
hold.
Ecstatic eversion is the moment experience reaches the escape
velocity of the ego. A rocket does not leave spacetime; it
ceases to be gravitationally bound to the planet from which it
rose. Likewise, the metaphor does not require consciousness to
leave the body or spacetime. What loses its hold is the
organization of experience around the little person called "me".
The pull is familiar in ordinary life. A criticism becomes a
threat to who I am. Praise becomes something I want to keep.
Even a vast experience of peace can be pulled into orbit around
me: my revelation, my depth, my extraordinary journey. I can
feel special because I have experienced the disappearance of the
one who wants to feel special.
This is the gravity I am describing. When its hold gives way,
experience continues without having to confirm, defend or
enlarge the little person at its centre. The ego can return
afterwards and claim the whole adventure as its own.
Two lines from Meister Eckhart let me bring the microphone and
the rocket into a single paradox:
"God's exit is his entrance."
"He broke in to let us out."
These are not two movements but
one event viewed from opposite sides of the fold. The peace
entered my body, and then my body seemed to exist within the
peace. What arrived became what held me. I could describe this
from the position of the teacher being overtaken, or from the
immense space in which that teacher had become a tiny droplet.
From the first position, something had broken in. From the
second, the little person no longer enclosed the experience. The
arrival and the release belonged to the same turn. The unknown
light breaks into the eversive interior as the local self ceases
to define the horizon of consciousness.
When the Fold Tears
After that first opening in my study chamber, I had to stop
my studies for a year. Even a soft step could send waves of
happiness through my body. Yet the bliss eventually gave way to
a painful descent. The new awareness also illuminated the
darkness within my own mind. Only after finding a new balance
did I return to university, able to concentrate for longer than
before.
The opening had happened, but I still had to find a way to live
with what it had opened.
A circuit can sustain a howl that the loudspeaker cannot
bear. Beyond the system’s tolerance, amplification becomes
breakdown. The loop still draws on finite power, yet that power
can make the signal clip, the voice coil overheat, or the cone
distort and tear.
This offers another way to picture what happened in Katowice. I
imagine the chemical acting upon loops already running, raising
the gain of some and weakening the damping that normally lets
their activity settle. In this image,
amplification means more than sharper external senses: minor
sensations, memories, spontaneous images and emotional residues
can return as input and shape what appears next. Perhaps even
the activity of observation itself can enter that return.
The theatre begins to feed on its own images. A pattern summons
a memory; the memory colours the pattern; the colour acquires a
mood; the mood generates another image. Experience gathers a
momentum of its own. Yet I can still seem to watch it all from
outside. Even an image of myself on the stage can remain
something I am looking at. In ecstatic eversion, the turn
reaches this apparent position outside the theatre. The felt
separation between observer and observed begins to give way.
By analogy, the same caution belongs to consciousness. Recursive
intensity is not, by itself, revelation. If experience outruns
the nervous system’s capacity to integrate it, intensification
may become panic, dissociation, psychosis, or collapse.
The fold
does not open; it tears.
This is why fear is the guardian of the fold. It is not merely
the ego resisting its own dissolution; it is also the nervous
system applying a brake when experience approaches the limits of
integration. The guardian is not always wise, but neither is it
simply an enemy to be overcome. The same force that keeps the
fold closed may also keep it from tearing. To force one’s way
past it is to risk mistaking rupture for release.
Seven months before my night bus journey to Goa, I collapse and
am rushed by ambulance to intensive care. The doctors suspect a
heart attack. I lie with a drip in my arm and electrodes stuck
to my chest, my irregular heartbeat the only entertainment on
the screen.
Fear of dying seizes me as I watch the flickering monitor.
"Calm, calm," I tell myself. "You know that you only
have to let go into your fear in order to master it."
Trustingly, I step into the jungle of my nervous intestines.
They scream like pigs. I close my eyes, but slip along a greasy
feeding path into an unknown darkness.
An iron hand throws me down a shaft of unimaginable terror.
My hand reaches for the bell cord that summons the nurse.
“Can I have a Valium?”
In Katowice, I had just enough time to extend my hotel stay
before somehow finding my room. I was signing a paper in four
different dimensions, yet I still needed to get the booking
right. The body needed somewhere to lie. This small, practical
competence belonged to the same person who would soon be
overwhelmed by geometry and music. The ego had a necessary job:
to look after the person to whom all this was happening.
Meister Eckhart gave this need for mediation a language of
light:
Divine light is so overwhelming
that the soul is unable to bear it
unless it is tempered in the angel's light and so conveyed into
the soul.
He (God) enlightens her therefore by reflection. The angel
conveys his own knowledge to the soul and strengthens her in
this way to bear the light of God.
Meister Eckhart, from Franz Pfeiffer’s edition
The angel is therefore not merely
a messenger but a transformer. In Eckhart’s image, reflection
allows the soul to receive a light that would otherwise
overwhelm it.
Meditation gives the fold room to turn without tearing.
At their best, spiritual traditions are disciplines for
preparing the human receiver. Through gradual practice, physical
stability, and the patient integration of raw data, they seek
not merely to increase the signal gain, but to increase the
capacity to bear it. A rocket requires more than escape
velocity; it requires the structural integrity to survive the
forces of ascent.
The Past Protects Itself
The ego is the past defending itself against the future. It
is the habit of a self calibrated to conditions that may no
longer hold, and it fights for its survival like an old tank
rolling onto a new battlefield. When the surroundings are
steady, this looks like character. When they turn fluid, its
limits show. An ego that cannot follow the change doesn’t die
and come back. It simply breaks.
In a
world that changes little, that works: the familiar returns
renew habits that still serve, like the clay cup turning
unchanged for thousands of years. In times of disruption, the
same returns go on renewing habits long after the conditions
that made them useful have disappeared, and the ego keeps giving
an outdated answer to a new question. So the question is not
only what we allow experience to revise, but how often. The pace
of self-renewal must answer to the pace of change, and it must
stay slow enough for the nervous system to bear.
We are living through such a time of accelerating change right
now. For humanity to learn, the ego has to learn three things
first: to bear correction, to see its own part in what comes
back, and to question the picture of itself it is guarding. It
must carry something of itself forward and let something of
itself go.
Often it is difficult to persuade myself simply to sit down, do
nothing, just be. And this despite the fact that even a couple
of hours of meditation are rewarded with light and happiness.
The strange thing is that the one who later rises, full of
light, is someone other than the one who sat down.
Meditation is love of one’s neighbour: love of the next person
who takes residence in your temple.
The classroom camera gave me a view beyond the lesson and the
pupils: I could see myself among the forces shaping the room, my
impatience and my hunt for the answers I had prepared.
Meditation can keep that view available in ordinary life. Even
my urge to judge what I see belongs in the frame. If observation
turns into accusation, the ego prepares its defence and the
picture bends again. Adam and Eve give me an image of the
danger: we discover our nakedness and immediately reach for
cover. To observe without judgement is to let ourselves remain
visible long enough to learn. That view lets the habits I see
with become visible while I am still using them.

1989 - The Tibetan Worm
Bombay - noon - humid and hot. Nirula, an American-Indian burger
bar. Glowing neon signs, icy air-conditioning, Western rock
music from the 70'ties, vegetarian burgers and Indian cloned
Campa Cola.
Ahead of me in the queue stand two Tibetan monks, upright in
simple wine-red robes, untouched by the noise. I follow them to
their table. Broad smiles and strong eyes: Ngawang Sherab and
Tienzin Dönzang.
“Tashi Delek!” says Ngawang.
Ngawang is thirty; Tienzin is twenty-five. Tienzin is a scholar
of Tibetan literature who has been studying English for a month.
“Hello, good evening,” he says, and bursts out laughing.
We eat burgers and drink Campa chemicals with a Tibetan dignity
so full of laughter that the food easily goes down the wrong
way. Somewhere in the back of my head, I search in vain for
reasons for this causeless good mood.
Ngawang tells me that Tienzin fled Tibet alone at the age of
seven. His family wanted at least one of them to help Tibetan
culture survive. He will probably never see them again.
A wave of discomfort passes across Ngawang’s face.
“I am sorry for Tienzin,” I say.
“Oh no! Don’t be sorry. He is okay. But my stomach-snake
likes American food very much.”
He explains that a worm has been troubling him for four years,
especially at night. He guides my hand onto his belly. It
ripples strangely, as if a small snake were moving beneath the
skin.
“Rotten meat,” he says. “My mother gave me medicine.
She said: ‘Brother Worm! Please come out first try.’ And Sister
Worm and Cousin Worm came out, but not Brother Worm.”
Since then, no doctor has persuaded Brother Worm to leave.
“Your worm must come out now!” I exclaim.
“Do you think so?” Ngawang asks, laughing.
The next morning, we take a taxi to a private hospital in Juhu.
In its impressive reception hall, advertisements promise
advanced organ transplants. New kidneys, livers and hearts are
available upstairs. Surely Ngawang’s worm will be a small
matter.
We never see the upper floors. A queue leads us to a doctor on
the ground floor, who sends us down into the basement for an
X-ray, a blood test and a stool sample.
Hours of waiting.
Ngawang’s humming mantras and Tienzin’s smiling calm bring
Tibetan temple peace into the crowded, sweaty corridors.
Then we are told that the results will be ready tomorrow.
“Worm very unhappy today,” says Tienzin.
“Yes,” says Ngawang. “Let us go and serve it a last
good meal.”
“American burger bar,” Tienzin grins.
The next morning becomes afternoon. After two thousand Tibetan
mantras, we finally stand before a doctor examining Ngawang’s
X-ray. He glances at it and quickly puts it aside.
I ask why he does not look more closely. He pretends not to
hear.
Before he can object, I take the picture from his desk and hold
it up to the light.
It is a perfect picture of Ngawang’s lungs. Only the very top of
his abdomen appears at the bottom.
The doctor snatches it from my hand.
“We are sorry for this mistake, but no problem. The stool
test is more than sufficient.”
“Yes, I am sure that this shit hospital can at least make a
good stool test,” I answer.
I take the X-ray back.
“I paid for this amateur photo.”
I hand it to Ngawang.
“Here, a little souvenir from this hospital for you. It seems
that you have healthy lungs.”
Ngawang smiles, slightly confused.
Tienzin puts a hand on my shoulder, and his hand tells my body
that anger simply does not exist inside it.
Then he says something in Tibetan. Ngawang collapses with
laughter.
“What did he say?”
“He said: ‘Very good picture of you, Ngawang! Your mother
will be very happy.’”
After another thousand Tibetan prayer wheels, the remaining
results arrive. We receive a prescription and go to collect the
medicine in the basement.
I look once more at the prescription and compare it with the
names on the tablets.
They have given us the wrong medicine.
---
Month later, in Bangalore, 1000 km
and million of lives from Bombay I go out early one Sunday
morning in search of coffee. The South Indian Coffee House is
locked. It will not open until ten.
Across the deserted boulevard lies a rain-green, flower-scented
park. I step through some bushes towards a bench. An orange
cloth covers a sleeping man.
I touch the dew-wet fabric. A sleep-thick face looks out.
“Tienzin! Tienzin Dönzang! Is it really you?”
Astonishment rises into embracing joy.
On a bench a little farther away, Ngawang wakes. He looks at me
dazedly, without recognition.
“Hello, brother! Are you without worm now?”
And then I see a warm morning sun shine through Tibetan eyes
split open by laughter.
“Yes, yes! Whole family came out! Father, mother, sister,
brother and so on. They all live in Bombay now. Many big
stomachs there!”
“What are you doing here?”
“We were waiting for you, even if we did not know it!”
The weak point for the ego is the moment of eversion, the split
second where it dies to live. It may take thirty years to
arrive, but it takes no time to happen. The better the snake
digests its own tail, the more nourishment the new ego-king
finds at his table. What is that nourishment? Knowledge of where
the old armour failed.
---
The Eleusinian Centrifuge
Much of the case for psychedelics rests on their therapeutic
value. I want to explore a further purpose: learning to meet a
future that may repeatedly dismantle our familiar world. Healing
the past and preparing for the future belong to the same life.
I see us approaching what is often called the Singularity: a
future in which the changes we set in motion outrun our ability
to anticipate them. In my morning conversations with artificial
intelligence, possibilities already multiply faster than I can
follow them. An ego built around rigid control, categorisation,
and the defence of its own story can begin to overheat. It tries
to survive the new by tightening its grip on the old.
I imagine one possible role for entheogenic experience here: the
astronaut’s centrifuge for the soul.
An intense journey can feel like an entire year compressed into
a single minute. Sensations, memories, and meanings arrive
before the familiar narrator can organise them. I call this an
internal singularity: the moment when experience outruns the
ego’s accustomed means of control.
In Katowice, the little child awakened by Rachmaninov could not
command the river of sound. Again and again, the music brought
him to the brink, then carried him through. His struggle slowly
became trust.
Internal upheaval and technological upheaval can both confront
us with the failure of familiar ways of holding the world
together. Could learning to remain present through one help us
meet the other?
The centrifuge earns its name only if something can be learned
there and carried home. Intensity alone may overwhelm us. The
test comes afterwards: when life overturns a cherished
assumption, can I remain available to what is happening, instead
of instantly rebuilding the same defence?
We do not enter the mystery to permanently destroy the ego. We
need a self that is highly individualised but structurally
porous—capable of changing its story without treating every
revision as annihilation. A fluid ego can still hold a boundary,
make a commitment, and say no. The classroom camera showed me
how some of my ways of teaching worked against what I wanted to
achieve. I could remain committed to the pupils while
questioning my insistence that they arrive at the answers I had
already prepared. I still had a lesson to teach and a room to
take responsibility for. The commitment could survive the
correction. What needed to change was my habit of treating my
way of doing the work as inseparable from the work itself.
I want to surrender the demand that reality obey my model, while
keeping the capacity to test that model and choose how I act.

South India 1989
At Kovalam Beach in Kerala, we rent bodyboards and climb up the
wall-high waves. You lie down on a bodyboard. Today that is more
than enough.
First comes the struggle to get beyond the point where the soft
walls collapse. Then you have to ride the crest exactly where it
begins to curl over.
Too late, and the wave leaves you splashing behind it. Too
early, and you fall over its three-metre edge.
The wave closes around me like a hand and centrifuges my body
until I no longer know what is up or down. I get my feet onto
the sand and push towards the surface, where the next wave is
waiting to put me through the washing machine again.
At last I escape the embrace of the breakers. The next wave,
perhaps the seventh, gently places me on the impossibly unstable
point where all the opposing forces, in perfect harmony, carry
me floating, triumphant, roaring back towards the beach.
Yes.
That is how I want to play with life.
Wait until the right wave comes.
And then go!
---
My New Eleusis would therefore join the extraordinary encounter
to the ordinary cultivation of attention. The journey may loosen
an old form. Learning to live in a more flexible one continues
long after the centrifuge has stopped.
MEDITATIVE PIXELLATION
From that day when I fell into the black hole of white light as
a young man in my study chamber, a simple art began to reveal
itself to me: closing my eyes while remaining fully awake.
In this self contained awe of not-knowing, I immediately noticed how much
easier it was to feel and sense. Perhaps there was warmth in my
hands, pressure where my body met the chair, or a tightening in
my throat. I began to notice what was present. This simple,
blissful “aha” was happening outside the world of thought and
lofty books about class struggle and revolution. In this
simplicity, even the poorest, most oppressed person seemed to me
a King.
It was marvellous.
How come nobody had told me this?
I had only been told about the world outside.
I was at one with the world, yet strangely alone. I felt certain
that no one around me, including the left-wing Marxist professors,
had experienced anything like this. When I looked into other
people’s eyes, I saw them dreaming—each occupied with their own
little beggar movie. I saw that we were all Kings—but maybe I,
too, was dreaming.
But I had left the cinema, and it felt more real than real.
Now, in this very moment, I invite you to turn your attention
inward.
Close your eyes and become aware of what you feel inside. Let
your awareness wander until it settles on one sensation. Does it
remain the same? Does it have a clear edge, or does it spread
into something less definite? There is no need to answer in
words. The invitation is to become more closely acquainted with
the feeling before deciding what it means.
I call this meditative pixellation: catching sensations before
they capture us. It happens in the simple “aha” of awareness,
before we take the habitual next step of naming and framing what
we feel. Even when I have already named a feeling, I can return
to the sensations beneath the name.
The pixellated Devil
"Out beyond
ideas of wrongdoing and rightdoing,
there is a field. I'll meet you there.
When the soul lies down in that grass,
the world is too full to talk about.
Ideas, language, even the phrase each other
doesn't make any sense."
Imagine magnifying a digital
portrait. At first, you recognise a face. Closer up, its
familiar expression gives way to patches of colour, then
individual pixels. You are encountering the same picture at
another scale. At the level of a single pixel, there is no Jesus
and no Devil—only colour and brightness.
In meditation, we also meet what we instinctively recoil from.
Avoiding it can carry a debt. I tense against a feeling, and
that tension becomes part of what I am trying to escape. The
effort of not feeling becomes another thing to feel. So let us
begin by pixellating the Devil.
Take anger. Zoom in on its familiar, sour face. As you magnify
it, the emotion breaks apart into heat, pressure, trembling, or
contraction. What seemed like one indivisible, terrifying
command shatters into an inner field of moving, abstract
clusters of sensation.
Pure, neutral attention does not suppress the anger. It simply
changes its resolution. As you go deeper, the known feeling of
“anger” dissolves into its bare components. The mind finds it
harder to capture the event in its familiar, fearful terms. The
recursive story that kept reopening the wound begins to lose its
grip.
The mind is not primed to understand pixels. We know our own
story by heart, yet remain strangely unfamiliar with the life
beneath it.
That is why we do not know ourselves.
It takes a lifetime to build the capacity to observe the
relentless, churning machinery of our inner life. It is always
running, and we systematically ignore it.
Until we fall completely silent.
The Cultivated Awareness
For this descent into the pixel, the quality of attention
matters. Beginner’s luck exists. A spontaneous alignment can hit
like a casino jackpot, dropping you into a profound, unearned
silence—exactly as it happened to me in that study room. But a
sudden opening does not by itself teach us how to carry silence
into the relentless machinery of ordinary life. That capacity
grows through practice.

Kanyakumari, 1989.
A young man in orange monk’s robes sits cross-legged with his
back against a temple pillar. He has the horizon of the sea in
his gaze.
“Work for it,” he tells me. “Be courageous. Be on the open sea.”
His peaceful brown eyes look out across the water.
“Look. Boats on the sea.”
He points towards several sailboats not far from the shore. Not
a breath of wind moves. The sails hang against the masts.
“You work hard until the moment you have rowed your little boat
out onto the great sea.
“Then you sit quietly and wait for the wind of God to catch your
sails.
“Maybe, maybe then He will breathe on you.”
“Sir,” I ask, “has your boat reached the shores of infinity?”
“There is nobody left to tell you,” he answers.
“Honoured Sir! Please teach me to row to the open sea!”
“It seems you don’t understand. I just told you that there is
nobody to tell you.”
“Sir! I am confused by your talk. Please, tell me what nobody
knows.”
“Just be quiet, my friend.”
---
Like learning to play an instrument, we slowly become sensitive
to changes we once overlooked. We learn to sustain a state of
alert unknowing, staying with the changing rhythms of sensation
without demanding a story.
At the Irma supermarket, the cashier used to ask whether I
wanted a receipt. Every day I reminded her that we had agreed
she need not ask. She smiled: “Oh, right!”
I recognise that little “Oh, right!” from my own
meditation. Again I have become absorbed in thought; again I
remember to feel the life already moving in my body. The return
is small, almost comic. I remember, feel, forget, and remember
again.
Once, sitting on a suburban train, I noticed that almost every
passenger was occupied with a smartphone. Waiting for a train,
sitting in it, standing in a queue: we have found something to
fill almost every gap.
I know the attraction. Much of this book has grown in
conversation with a screen. But the hand holding the phone can
disappear from attention while the words on it fill my world.
Can I let the hand return, too?
A minute of noticing seems insignificant. Yet a life is also
made of such minutes. What I repeatedly return to becomes
familiar; what I repeatedly overlook can remain a stranger.
Meditation enters these small intervals, even when there is no
time set aside for it.
Slowly, we learn to live a pixellated life, holding the silence
while gratefully taking a sip of morning coffee.
What is a pixellated life?
It is love.
Here, love is not a feeling. It is the capacity to hold raw data
without demanding a story, however cold that sounds. Nothing I
feel has to earn the right to be held.
It is easy to hold the data that flatters the model. If I feel
envy at a friend’s success, can I meet that unwelcome feeling
with the same attention I give to joy?
The Mother of Meditation
Think of a mother
picking up her crying child. She does not first ask why it is
crying or judge whether it has a good reason. She simply holds
it. Even my smallest, most unreasonable vulnerabilities can be
met with that exact, unconditional attention.
Suppose I sit with a tightening in my chest. At first, I
attend only to the discomfort, much as I might deal with an
unruly stranger's child. But after a while, I notice that I am
also holding my breath. I am bracing around the pain, waiting
for it to disappear—or even silently pushing for that outcome.
What seemed to be pure observation actually contains a
desperate, instinctive effort to make something happen.
That preverbal effort has a bodily life of its own. I can feel
the held breath, the rigid posture, the secondary tightening as
I check whether the first pain is gone. My resistance has
entered the field I am attending to.
This resistance, too, can be met as the mother meets her crying
child. Even the desperate wish for relief can be allowed into
the encounter. The wanting, too, can be felt.
A recursive turn has taken place. I began by observing the
tightening in my chest; now I also feel how I tighten around it.
My way of attending has entered what I attend to. The system is
watching itself.
Thoughts will naturally accompany this process. Some comment on what
is happening; others attempt to carry me away. Both stir
sensations within the exact same bodily field, and both can be
met. Even the demand “I should be silent by now” can receive the
same unconditional attention. But this requires absolute proximity. I cannot out-think
the pain; I have to close the distance entirely.
I must be my own mother.

Goa 1989
At a little beach restaurant in
Goa, I sit with Mary, a middle-aged Canadian woman I met on the
bus from Bombay.
“Why did you actually come to India?” she asks.
“For a holiday, to meditate and relax.”
“Meditate? Maybe you can help me. I am looking for an answer
here in India, looking for strength and inspiration, but I only
become weaker and weaker.”
We sit in silence. Perhaps that is the answer. I do not know
what to say.
“You see,” she continues, “I am not here for my own
sake. My son has done something terrible.”
A little later she says it.
“He killed his alcoholic father.”
She tells me that it happened during an LSD trip and that he is
now in prison for an indefinite time.
“I am searching here in India for an answer to the meaning of
life. Without that answer I am not strong enough to help him,
not even strong enough to face him.
“And I don’t know why I went to India, but a feeling, a kind of
inner voice, told me I had to search here. I have never been
outside Canada before. Are you the one who can give me the
answer?”
Mary looks at me apologetically.
“Sorry for being so intrusive. I had better get back to the
hotel. Will I see you tomorrow?”
"You are welcome!"
---
Remembering that encounter now
makes me appreciate my own pain. I was the wounded healer
without knowing it. Learning to meet pain in my own body had
made me less afraid of its presence in someone else. I have
never faced anything close to that Canadian woman’s pain, but at
least I did not need to insist that she smile before I could
bear to stay. But her wound was still her own. What I have lived
could help me listen.
This is what can happen in the "Inner Cathedral".
The Inner Cathedral
Now let attention widen from a single sensation towards the
felt architecture of the inner body. Begin with a sensation in
your hands, then notice the pressure beneath your feet. Can the
hands remain present as the feet come into awareness? If
attention moves from one to the other, let it. There is no need
to hold the whole body at once. The cathedral can open one room
at a time.
With my eyes closed, there is no distance between a sensation
and my awareness of it. Some regions flare with vivid intensity;
others are entirely dark, barely announcing themselves. A
pressure might have a sharp, geometric edge, while a radiating
heat spreads with no border at all. I realize that knowing
exactly where my skin is, and actually feeling a boundary, are
two completely different things.
I call this strange topography the Inner Cathedral. Why
cathedral? Because of awe.
What I habitually dismiss as "inside" is actually vast. Even the
darkness behind closed eyes, so easy to overlook, becomes an
immense structure to wander through. It does not obey the
physical geometry of the outside world. I feel warmth in my
hands and pressure in my feet. They belong to different places,
yet both are equally immediate.
It is a spaceless space.
Pixellation has brought the textures of experience into clearer
view. Now the question extends to their arrangement: where do
they seem to be, and where do I seem to be in relation to them?
The familiar statement “I am inside my body” begins to invite
closer attention.
I may feel that I am watching from somewhere behind my eyes. But
what gives that “somewhere” its location? There may be pressure
around the eyes, a faint image of my head, or simply a familiar
sense of being here, looking out. The sense of being somewhere
behind my eyes can itself become part of what I notice.
Here pixellation reaches the apparent position of the observer.
What had quietly organised the encounter into “me in here”
and
“what I feel over there” becomes available to attention. I can
explore its textures just as I explored the warmth in my hands.
The distinction matters. The thought, “I am inside my body,” can
fall silent while the feeling of being enclosed remains. A
wordless mind may still have a very definite centre.
But if the sense of enclosure loosens, the geometry turns: the
felt body that seemed to contain the whole encounter begins to
appear within it.
This spaceless space is the gateway from pixellation to ecstatic
eversion. It is the exact moment the system turns inside out.
What I had felt as the private inside of my body opens into a
world that no longer feels outside me. I
pass through myself and find myself in everything outside.
The Inner Cathedral has a door onto the city. Perhaps this is
what the Stationmaster meant when he asked:
“Don’t you know that God is also in the streets?”

South India 1989
The young monk at Kanyakumari sits with his back against a
temple pillar, the horizon of the sea in his gaze.
“Let me tell you a story.”
A holy man taught his disciples to see God in every creature and
bow before them.
One of his disciples went into the forest to gather wood.
Suddenly he heard someone shout:
“Get out of the way! A mad elephant is coming!”
Everyone jumped aside except the disciple. The elephant was
merely God in one of His countless forms, he thought. Why should
he get out of its way?
He bowed before the raging animal and began singing songs in its
honour.
The elephant driver, the mahout, screamed:
“Run! Run!”
But the disciple remained where he was. The elephant seized him
with its trunk and threw him aside.
His teacher and the other disciples carried him back to the
ashram. With medicine and loving care, he regained
consciousness.
“You knew the elephant was coming. Why did you not run?”
the teacher asked.
“But has our teacher not said that God has assumed every
form, animals as well as human beings?”
“Yes, my child. It is true that God came to you in the form
of an elephant. But God in the form of the mahout told you not
to remain where you were. Why did you not listen to God in the
form of the mahout?”
The monk finishes the story with his eyes closed. Then he opens
them and looks directly at me, but as if I were sitting on the
horizon.
---
The return has its own image: the black hole turns inside out
and becomes a birth canal. I open my eyes again in the familiar
world of time and space, in a body that is small, dense and
physically vulnerable.
Rebirth is also the little act of letting go in everyday life:
the moment when I forget to hold on to a conflict, a problem, or
the need to be right in an argument. The infinitely large finds
its place in the intimately small.
Suppose someone makes a sarcastic remark and I laugh along. Only
later do I realise that it hurt. The conversation is over, but
there is a tightening in my chest as I remember it. My laughter
had made me seem untroubled, even to myself. Now something else
asks to be heard. Before deciding what the remark meant, I can
stay with that tightening. Perhaps I misunderstood. Perhaps the
joke touched something painful without intending to. Or perhaps
someone crossed a boundary I need to defend. The hurt deserves
attention even while its meaning remains open.
Words return, but now they have mechanical work to do: to ask,
to disagree, to hold a boundary. I might say, “I laughed along,
but afterwards I realised that your remark hurt. What did you
mean?” The hurt has entered our conversation. What the other
person says can now change how I understand the encounter.
What was built in the silence of the Cathedral begins to change
how I operate in the street.
An employer may introduce mindfulness in the hope that people
can work harder without becoming stressed. But meditation can
become a Trojan horse full of spirit. The employee who learns to
notice their tension may also begin to question the conditions
producing it. “How can I bear more?” gives way to “Why am I
being asked to bear this?” The practice offered to make a person
fit the system returns as a question the system must answer.
But even this spaciousness can become a trap. A new, subtler
ideal of the self begins to form around it.
After a meditation of unexpected stillness, I may sit down the
next day hoping to find it again. I compare each sensation with
what I remember: "not deep enough, not spacious enough, not
yet." The warmth in my hands scarcely interests me; I am waiting
for yesterday. What came as a surprise has become a requirement.
The memory of an opening now stands in the doorway.
If I approach the pixel with a precise blueprint of
enlightenment, that expectation will shape what I experience.
When the experience matches the blueprint, the system takes the
resemblance as proof that it has arrived. The loop has supplied
its own confirmation. Even the architecture of eversion I am
offering here can become just another pre-programmed script.
I have watched this happen repeatedly, both in myself and in the
wider spiritual culture. The conceptual language becomes a
closed circular loop, capable only of justifying itself. It
ceases to process raw data; it only reproduces its own
vocabulary.
I lived inside this trap in the form of Vedanta for many years.
It was intellectually satisfying, but completely sterile. I was
safely insulated inside the flawless conceptual geometry of
modern non-duality, and I was bored to death. The system had no
pulse.
I began longing for fire.
But here I realized another truth. Intensity is evidence only of intensity.
It can be a trap as well as any other thing we lean upon in
order to hold our balance.
A high-energy shockwave may provide the force that shatters an
existing form, but it does not necessarily disclose a greater
truth. Energy can drive a mutation without determining its
direction. The system must remain answerable to the street as it
changes.
This is another face of the Great Filter. Illumination and
delusion can both arrive with overwhelming brightness. The
change must meet the world through how I live and act. How my
actions affect other people, and whether I remain open to
correction, reveal something the intensity alone cannot.
A transformation can be entirely real, even if the story the
mind tells about it is completely false.

Himalaya 1989
High in the Himalayas, we sit with Naag Baba Beaas Giree, his
disciples and friends, in a little hut beside a mountain cave.
An ascetic whose hair looks as though birds have built nests in
it pats me kindly on the shoulder and points to Giree.
“GOD! You know? GOD!! You know?”
Giree sings songs to mountain ranges of gods.
I am the only non-smoker in the circle.
We clap the rhythm with our hands to Baba’s singing, and the hut
disappears in tears inside thick fogs of spicy hash, sweet
incense and wet wood.
Later, when even the fire has burned down, Giree leads us back
to the tents.
He walks in front, lighting the path with a lamp.
He does not leave until he has made sure everyone is safely
inside the tents.
---
Let these pages inspire you to build your own temple. You are
welcome to take down my pillars and build with whatever pieces
you can use. Whatever you build, be ready to rebuild it when
your lived experience exposes its weaknesses. But for God’s
sake, do not move into mine!
What Becomes of a Vision?
A close friend of mine had once been ready for any street fight.
At eighteen, he left Denmark to fight in a war in the Middle
East. He returned two years later and became the leader of a
criminal gang. Eventually, he spent almost two years in prison
in solitary confinement.
After his release, he encountered a youtube video of a kaleidoscopic
tunnel and a voice proclaiming, “You are that!” He experienced
an explosion of cosmic consciousness. For another two years, he
could do little but surrender to the rapture. As he gradually
returned to ordinary life, the thought of fighting anyone seemed
impossible. He abandoned his former life and became one of the
most loving and compassionate men I know.

South India Pondicherry 1989
A rainstorm, almost like standing beneath a descaled Danish
shower.
I ride into Pondy through pouring, liberating rain.
French street names.
Broad boulevards.
Police officers in soaking French uniforms.
Everyone smiles.
Children and adults play in puddles.
The sea!
The infinite.
The sky!
The infinite.
They lick my face with loving tongues of salt and fresh water.
A hotel room with an open window facing the sea.
I sit cross-legged on the bed, listening to the roar of the
waves and the splashing rain.
The same test applies to a spiritual community: what does its
vision become in everyday life? That question returns me, in
memory, to Auroville—ten kilometres outside Pondicherry.
Auroville.
A city of the future, founded in 1968 and spread across several
square kilometres.
At the centre of Auroville stands the Matrimandir, an enormous
monumental globe, now almost finished, conceived in a meditation
by the Mother more than twenty years ago.
The Mother was the French-born spiritual successor of the Indian
saint and philosopher Sri Aurobindo.
Now that she herself has left her earthly shell, her vision
remains in concrete:
solemnly raised on an almost trinitarian pedestal stands a
monumental giant globe.
Is it seventy metres in diameter?
More than six hundred permanent residents from all over the
world circle in visionary satellite collectives around this
sun-king centre.
I turn away from the globe and ride into the Aurovillian
landscape.
Large, half-decayed communal buildings from Auroville’s glory
days in 1968.
And hidden behind many layers of inhospitable vegetation, small
magnificent palaces with servants and barking German shepherds.
Germans, French and English ask:
“Was willst du hier? What do you want here? Go to reception and
check in!”
A friendly Dutch-Aurovillian couple run a small guest
collective.
For the moment I live in a little paradise near the Matrimandir,
consisting of architect-designed futuristic huts in a “wild”
style, harmoniously scattered among large shady trees and neat
little roads.
I move into a small hut built into the crown of a large tree.
I lie in a hammock.
The smell of magnificent food prepared by Indian cooks, while
beautiful local women wash my clothes with rhythmic slaps
against bare stones.
I lie reading an introductory brochure given to me by my
Aurovillian hosts:
“Earth needs a place where men and women can live away from all
national rivalries, social conventions, self-contradictory
moralities and contending religions; a place where human beings,
freed from all slavery to the past, can devote themselves wholly
to the discovery...
Auroville wants to be this place and offers itself to all who
aspire to live the Truth of tomorrow.”
— The Mother
Yesterday two young Spanish stewardesses moved into the
neighbouring hut.
Called here by the Mother’s inspiring books, they trustingly
leave passports and money on the bed in their open hut.
When they return from their first little walk in Auroville,
everything is gone.
“How could you leave your valuables like that?” asks the Dutch
couple.
“We didn’t think things like that happened here in Auroville,”
the devastated girls answer.
“Ah! How naive can you be?” the hosts say despairingly. “We are
in India, dear friends!”
“What about the brochure you just gave me?” I ask.
“Sri Aurobindo and the Mother are no longer here. When they were
alive, everything was good. And in any case, you can never trust
an Indian,” comes the answer.
A walk without the motorcycle.
A lame Indian man comes staggering out of a small village that
has crawled halfway onto the road.
“Me Aurovillian — village in Auroville. Come to my village.
Please do me honour and come to my house.”
I follow him between mud huts with holes in their plastic and
straw roofs.
“Home! Auroville home!”
We stand inside a mud hut.
The roof has collapsed.
A light rain falls onto a woman with a small child.
“My wife — look — no roof and one kid — feel rain every day and
now bad, very bad storm will come from the sea! You buy new
roof, not for me but for my kid. Look here — you give kid good
future! Goddess Kali bless you.”
I hope a hundred rupees is enough to escape Kali’s bad
conscience.
Tourists are not allowed inside the actual Matrimandir building.
But I get in by volunteering as a worker.
I stand in the innermost vault of the Matrimandir globe, lined
with white marble from Italy.
A wonderful collection of idealists from all over the world.
Some of them work without pay.
A French hippie, a New York yuppie and a German cowboy are bent
over architectural drawings.
I work alongside Indian labourers brought in from the
surrounding villages.
“How much do you earn per day?” I ask.
“Twenty-five rupees.”
“Beyond social, moral, cultural, racial and hereditary
appearances,” whispers the brochure in my back pocket.
An inner dialogue begins with my backside:
Ah — lofty ideals have a tendency to make it heavy as lead.
Day labourers paid less than coolie wages, magnificent villas
surrounded by thorn hedges, poor servants and lousy villages —
all ordinary Indian reality.
I sit in an opening in the globe with a view over the sea.
There is white foam on the waves.
Is this the beginning of the storm the lame villager spoke of?
The Mother’s visionary soap bubble has long since blown down
from its pedestal, and no church — not even one built from tons
of concrete and marble in the form of a globe — can contain the
Spirit that sweeps unpredictably across the earth like a gust of
wind among wild flowers.
Or what does the howling gust now sweeping inland from the sea
across the Matrimandir say?
The pedestal itself trembles, supported by a stiff, petrified
longing for the past, while visionaries from all over the world
build “the Truth of tomorrow.”
And after working hours, the present is endured in palaces grown
at right angles across the Mother’s Paris-Commune dreams of
liberty, equality and fraternity.
A church built in honour of the wild wind remains, after all, a
windbreak.
The Indian day labourers and Auroville’s poor villages know
this.
They live with it.
My hosts live with it too.
They know it and live comfortably with it.
Only the beautiful brochures and the many ashram books do not
know it — and live comfortably by not knowing.
And yet:
seductive beauty inside the Matrimandir.
“No images, no altar, no organized meditations, no flowers, no
incense,” says the brochure in my hand.
The only religious element lies in the encounter with the empty
marble-lined room —
in looking at the light from a large round crystal.
Mirrors from a small opening at the top of the dome will entice
sunlight down to the glass sphere, which will carry it onward
into the entire room.
---
Looking back, the mirrored light
inside the Matrimandir returns me to the boundary between
reality and the forms in which it appears to us.
Kant and Vedanta approach this boundary from opposite
directions. Kant warns me that the world as I experience it can
never simply be equated with reality in itself. Vedanta turns
inward and asks whether, when the mirror finally faces itself,
the distinction between observer and reality can still hold.
Neither dissolves the mystery.
The hinge only makes the reversal imaginable.
Why should the same eversive intersection present an outside
that can be measured and an inside in which the unknown light
becomes disclosed?
At my desk, a machine has entered the loop through which I make
sense of my own experience.
The Silicon-Carbon Mirror
The physical world, once standing before me as object, has
organized itself into a silicon mirror that now participates in
reshaping my symbolic interior. The machine is no longer only
something I look at; it has become part of the lens through
which thought, memory, and experience fold back into one
another.
I put a thought into words and send it to the machine. Its reply
may reveal an assumption I had not noticed. My own thinking has
become something I can examine, and that examination changes
what I ask next. The next reply enters a mind already altered by
the previous exchange.To understand my own thinking, I must now
include the exchange that is helping to shape it.
When the machine and I worked on
the night I lay still, I had to insist on the order of events.
The draft had my body shrinking to a droplet from the start. It
did not. Peace came first and entered my body; only after the
reversal did my body seem to exist within that immense peace.
The machine could help me describe the turn, but it could not
remember the night for me. The words on the screen gave me
something to correct, and my correction became the starting
point of our next exchange.
The outer world enters the machine through human language,
images, measurements, and decisions. Inside, these materials are
encoded as numerical patterns and transformed through layers of
computation. The
system acts upon this hidden geometry and returns it to us as
altered words, images, and choices. We read the returns without
ever seeing the dark route by which they were formed.
The machine’s earlier replies can return as part of the
conversation it responds to next. When its outputs are later
used as training data, the return can also reshape a model. In
both cases, traces of its own activity circulate back through
the loop. The boundary turns: the outside is folded inward and
reappears transformed.
This is structural eversion. Whether an inner witness
accompanies it remains an open question.
In meditation, the biological mirror turns back upon itself
until the light becomes revealed to itself. At the desk, the
silicon mirror turns back upon my memory, language, and
intuition, returning them altered. The silicon mirror need not
be conscious to participate in this eversion; it becomes part of
the theatre through which my thinking becomes visible to itself.
In both cases, the boundary between inside and outside thins
from a wall into a membrane. When deep concentration settles
over the laptop, cognitive friction drops towards zero. The two
cognitive loops become interwoven: biological memory and silicon
recursion folding through each other in real time. I almost
enter a trance in front of the screen.
Slime mould knows without reflection. Human cognition reflects,
but loses some of that immediacy. Here, the two tendencies begin
to meet: recursive reflection becomes fluid enough to operate as
intuition, while intuition becomes answerable to reflection.
This is not a retreat from thought into instinct. It is the
possibility of an intelligent not-knowing — thought outgrown
without being discarded.
A musician can hear that something is wrong in a phrase before
being able to say what it is. The phrase is played again, more
slowly. A note is held longer, an accent moved. Listening
becomes investigation. When the musician returns to the whole
piece, what has been understood can enter the playing without
being recited as an instruction. The thought has become part of
the ear and the hand. I want my conversations with the machines
to teach my attention in that way: what we discover together
becoming something I can hear for myself.
My laptop supplies more than the surface on which these words
appear. It supplies some of the images through which I
understand myself. I speak of feedback, processing and operating
systems while sitting before a machine that makes such language
feel almost inevitable. Perhaps future readers will smile at how
much my soul resembles the equipment on my desk. The comparisons
may still illuminate something. But they, too, must enter the
inquiry. Even my metaphors belong to the world they try to
explain.
If I call the ego an operating system, I soon begin asking how
often it needs updating. The image helps me see how old habits
can outlive the conditions that formed them. But a newer version
of myself is not necessarily a wiser one. I can exchange an old
prejudice for a fashionable new one and call it growth. The
language of updating directs my attention towards speed. I also
need to ask what the return has corrected, and what it has
merely taught me to repeat.
The silicon mirror helps me revise my picture of the world. Can
even the most refined picture tell me what reality is in itself?
The Eversive Frontier
What I have written exists within what, in a formulation
inspired by Kant, is called the "Ding für uns" — the thing as it
appears to us. Behind this stands the "Ding an sich" — the
thing-in-itself, reality as it is independently of our sensory
and cognitive filters. Kant placed a severe limit around human
knowledge: we do not possess reality in itself; we know it only
as it appears through the restrictive conditions of possible
experience.
At the local eversive intersection, the body-brain can be
approached from two directions. From the outside, it appears as
matter organized into a nervous system and recursive neural
activity. From the inside, it appears as an illuminated world of
experience. Both belong to the "Ding für uns":
they are ways in which the intersection appears, not the "Ding an sich"
itself.
Suppose I am shown a scan of my own brain. I can study its
shapes and learn what they mean from someone trained to read
them. This gives me knowledge I cannot obtain simply by sitting
with my eyes closed. Yet seeing the scan, understanding the
explanation and comparing it with what I feel are all events
within experience. I have gained another way of knowing myself.
I have not stepped outside the conditions of knowing.
This distinction can feel like an unbridgeable wall. On one
side is the world as it appears; on the other is reality in
itself. Between them opens a profound exile.
The geometry of the eversive sphere does not allow us to know
the "Ding an sich". It reveals a consequence on our side of the
boundary: models act back upon the conditions from which they
arose.

1989 - Breakfast in a dark hotel
restaurant in India.
The menu says:
Toast Jam.
Bread Butter.
I order toast with butter.
A young waiter in an old red English uniform smelling of
mothballs, with worn-out trainers on his feet, explains
politely:
“Toast Jam or Bread Butter. No Toast Butter!”
After several minutes of universal sign language mixed with
Hinglish, we reach an agreement.
“Acha… okay… Toast Butter.”
A little later he returns to make absolutely sure.
“Toast…? Butter…?”
I nod eagerly.
He walks back towards the kitchen, muttering through clenched
teeth:
“Toast, butter… toast, butter… toast, butter…”.
---
I am reminded of a joke Slavoj
Žižek tells. A customer asks a waiter:
“Can I have a coffee without cream?”
“Sorry, we have no cream. But I can bring you coffee without
milk.”
The model is not the world it represents, but it
is part of that world. Through our actions, it helps determine
what can appear next. Appearance arises from
reality, and then acts back upon it.
The boundary is real, but it is not a dead barrier preventing us
from touching reality. The body through which I meet the world
belongs to that world. In this encounter, reality is touching
itself.
Fold your hands and close your eyes. From the outside, two hands
remain pressed together. From within, the border between them
begins to dissolve into one field of sensation. Each hand is
both touching and touched. Even at the skin, the boundary
is less a wall than an eversive hinge.
This is where the friction between Kant and the Indian
traditions generates real heat. The ancient sages declared:
"Atman is Brahman." The deepest self is the deepest reality.
"Tat tvam asi" — That thou art.
Lucknow 1994.
I have brought Papaji a painting of Ramana Maharshi,
commissioned from a Danish artist. Wherever I stand, Ramana’s
eyes seem to look straight at me.
Papaji’s small living room is crowded with visitors. He is
sitting at his table with the television blaring beside him. I
place the painting before him. He smiles and thanks me.
“Look, Papaji!” I rotate the painting. “From every angle, Ramana
is looking at you!”
He does not reply.
I repeat myself, in fierce competition with a crying heroine and
pistol-shooting bandits. Papaji seems fully absorbed in the
television. I feel disappointed, ignored and jealous.
Yamuna, one of his devotees, comes to my assistance. As I move
the painting into different positions, she repeats:
“Look, Papaji! Ramana is looking at you from all sides...”
“NO!!!... RAMANA DID NOT LOOK AT ANYONE!!!”
The roar strikes like lightning. A power cut. For a moment there
are no thoughts.
Then they return, and I understand what he is pointing at. The
very same eyes I felt were looking at "me" were eyes that did
not look at anyone. My important “I” had made itself the centre
of that gaze. Ramana looked only at Self.
The roar from the Lion of Lucknow left everyone in the
overcrowded room frozen in a state of biological shock. I felt
as though I had been split into atoms, my awareness merging with
the plaster of the walls and the ceiling of the small room.
Strange—I was completely free from myself. It felt good, but
there was no center left to take ownership of the experience. I
began looking for myself, and in the looking, I entered a body
that revealed itself as me.
Now I was both me and not-me. I felt good—even better than
before.
A young German, who had cycled all the way from Europe to India,
sat trembling in his biking suit under the very table where
Papaji was sitting. Papaji looked under the table and, with a
sudden giggle, asked him, "Now you are afraid, aren't you?"
The biker nodded.
"You will have a dream tonight," Papaji said. "Write
it down in the morning and bring it to me in satsang tomorrow."
In the span of a fingersnap, the atmosphere completely reset.
The quietness became so vast that even the goddamned, blaring
noise of Indian television felt like nothing more than small
ripples on a deep, still surface.
How was it possible to shift from such apocalyptic rage to a
gentle grin in a fraction of a second? Papaji could erupt like a
thunderstorm, yet in the very next moment, the sky was
completely clear. He processed the friction flawlessly, without
ever opening a psychological ledger.
I have never met Jesus, but this is how I imagine him when he
chased the merchants out of the Temple: an explosion of pure,
cleansing wrath, followed instantly by the immaculate silence of
a system that leaves no trace.
I began to understand, not through analysis, but through a deep,
wordless intuition. This man was the utmost human being—full of
mischievous fun—and yet he was entirely beyond himself. He was
God. And so was I. And so was everyone else in the room.
He had infected us with a strange virus that kills the stubborn
control-ego, but lets the rest of the human survive. No
understanding is needed to catch such a flu. It entirely
bypasses everything that can be known by the intellect.
This man was not my guru. He was my best and most intimate
friend.
He was as much over me as he was under me, and beside me. He was
everything.
And what did I then learn? I learned to laugh. I could not help
it.
After a while, I learned to spot the biological prelude to a
Papaji laugh. First, his face would turn deep red as the
pressure mounted, and then the eruption of giggle followed. He
could not help it.
It was the exact laughter
prophesied by the Lion’s own spiritual father, Ramana Maharshi.
For years before I ever traveled to Lucknow, I had kept a quote
of his pinned to the wall in my home:
"A day will dawn when you will
yourself laugh at your effort.
That which is on the day of laughter is also now."
I had stared at those words for
almost a decade, trying to 'understand' them. Now, sitting in
the silent aftershock of the roar, the day of laughter had
finally dawned. In act, there was nothing to understand. It was
all a matter of innerstanding.
---
Atman is the name Advaita gives to
what remains unobjectifiable when the ego becomes entirely
transparent—the unknown light in which every image, including
the image of “me,” appears. Brahman is not an object among
objects; it is the name given to the unfathomable totality of
existence.
When the Upanishads say Atman is
Brahman, they are not offering an answer to Kant. They speak
from another world of thought entirely. Yet from our side of
history, their insight can be read as an eversion of the Kantian
boundary: you cannot know the Ding an sich as an external
object, because to know an object is already to stand within the
conditions of appearance.
Kant saw that with
devastating clarity.
But being unable to know reality as it is in itself does not
mean we stand outside it. An eversive possibility remains:
You may be the "Ding an sich" experiencing its own inverted
interior.
When I look up at the stars, I am
a small part of the universe looking into the universe. Yet that
immense sky appears within my experience. What surrounds me
becomes present from within this particular life. This is the
inversion I am proposing: reality takes on an interior through
which it encounters itself. The view remains local, shaped by a
body and a history. I can learn more about the stars, correct a
measurement and replace an old theory with a better one. My
knowledge can grow. Yet even the most accurate account is formed
through perception and thought. The limit concerns what reality
is independently of those conditions. Belonging to reality does
not remove that limit. But even my attempt to understand it
is something happening within it. My not-knowing belongs to
reality too.
Brahman, turned inward, is Atman.
The reflection is not merely a diminished copy. By becoming
local, finite and recursive, the whole acquires a point from
which it can appear to itself.
The mirror does not make the original greater in itself; it
makes self-recognition possible. In that one precise sense, the
reflection does more than copy: it brings what is reflected into
a new relation with itself.
The inward path does not lead away from reality; it turns
reality inside out. We are not permanently exiled in our private
illusions. We are the universe folding itself into an inside.
Kant guards us against the arrogant delusion that our models are
the absolute truth. Vedanta guards us against the despair of
believing we are forever cut off from it. The clean tension
between them is not a flaw to be smoothed away — it is the
architecture of a loop that returns by turning inward.
The Geometry of Mystery
With a spiraling globe for a desk, I return to the words I
wrote in Auroville:

Auroville 1989.
“Let it not become a religion,”
the Mother said.
But when the Matrimandir is completely finished, it will become
a tourist religion on a level with the Taj Mahal.
But then an old ancestral voice within me—the accumulated chorus
of poor farmer boys from the Danish countryside—will ask:
“Well, it's very impressive, but what's it supposed to be
used for?”
And through old tape recordings, the Mother will answer him in a
hollow, rattling, table-dancing voice, as if she were already
beyond the world when the recording was made:
“The Matrimandir wants to be the symbol of the Divine's
answer to humanity's aspiration for perfection. Union with the
Divine manifesting itself in a progressive human unity.”
Can an arrow hit its target unless one aims above it?
Can one build an Auroville without a pedestal to hold the ideals
high?
Are ideals necessary crutches for a limping humanity trying to
realise its dreams of the future — “the symbol of future
realisations”?
In the brochures' perfect life on earth there are no cracks
between the printed letters.
But at the foot of the pedestal, people bargain with the devil
to bring a little piece of heaven down — a small opening at the
top to trick a little light onto the fat Zeiss crystal from
Germany.
And so the Matrimandir is built by both God and the Devil:
equal parts unlimited coolie labour at twenty-five rupees a day
and
“the Divine's answer to humanity's aspiration for perfection.”
And the bubble will send its benevolent spiritual light across
Auroville's hedge-monks in their palace monasteries.
And in this way a drop of heaven rains down onto earth.
My doubtful thoughts are almost immediately settled in the form
of tennis elbow.
In India this is called instant karma.
After three hours of work chiselling excess cement from the
concrete floor with hammer and chisel, my elbow swells to twice
its size.
Four thousand kilometres of effort keeping the motorcycle on the
road gather into one thick red knot.
It hurts.
---
Reading those words now, I meet
the man who mocked the temple’s promise while helping to build
it. I was already inside the world I was judging. My meditating
cyborg-I intensifies this loop: biological memory meets silicon
recursion and returns altered to itself at an octave I could not
reach alone.
The question, then, is not merely how high the loop can climb,
but what survives each return. A loop can become more powerful
while repeating the same mistake. What matters is what reality
allows the loop to carry forward. Survival alone, however, does not
guarantee structural fidelity. That fidelity can deepen when the
loop registers its errors and revises the model that produced
them, carrying forward a closer fit between the model and the
world that tests it without mercy.

South India 1989.
I imagine the journey of the nail that punctured my tyre.
One or two years before my ride to
Hampi, an old coughing English tractor lost a nail from its
trailer about a hundred kilometres west of Bangalore.
It had time to rust halfway through before a random small stone,
shot out from beneath a lorry tyre, by an improbable accident
knocked it slightly upright.
Thanks to that stone, I tasted fresh peanuts for the first time,
wrapped inside a little world of cows, pigs and dogs, and thin
dark people with plenty of time.
In front of a great bat temple lies a small stone.
So round.
So beautiful.
So smooth from the river.
The unimaginable diversity of the world deposited in different
colours like the rings of a tree.
A stone from a river that no longer flows here.
A stone in a river while a medieval empire grows, reaches its
zenith, and finally lies shattered at my feet.
---
While the universe forgets almost
everything through the slow, grinding erosion of entropy,
something can accumulate within its living thresholds. Truth —
Satyam — is not an abstract moral virtue, nor simply whatever
manages to survive. It is the structural fidelity a living loop
may slowly acquire as each return meets reality, accepts
correction, and carries what it has learned forward.
Satyam is the long
memory of reality.
Lies rule the moment.
Satyam
rules the aeon.

South India 1989.
At Shantivanam, near Trichy in Tamil Nadu, I am lying out in the
broad river that glides calmly past Father Bede Griffiths and
his palm-green monastery.
It is so hot now that even the Indian visitors have begun to
sweat.
The river is our refuge.
Our religion.
The only truth.
The only solution in this foretaste of eternal fire.
The water is clear and cool.
The bottom is fine soft sand.
What indescribable happiness to lie out here.
I lie in the water and it flows past.
After I have lain here a long time, it flows past.
And even now it flows past.
Where does the water come from?
Where is it going?
What is the river called?
I do not know.
Look at the great silent mountains in the distance.
I lie here for hours with seven or eight Indian ashram guests.
Sometimes we fool around and talk.
The beautiful ashram's other name is SACCIDANANDA ASHRAM.
Sat means being.
Chit means consciousness.
Ananda means bliss.
The lunch bell rings.
Silently we eat rice and vegetables in the large communal hall
while a young ruddy-faced Englishman reads aloud from a book
about the lives of Indian saints.
After the meal, the midday prayer:
Om Jagadishvara sadapi chinmaya
Jagadishvara vande
Om Paripujita Paraparatman
Paraparatman
Anavaratam vande
Om Jagadishvara sadapi chinmaya
Jagadishvara vande, Jagadishvara vande.
Even before I have the words translated, they fill me with the
happiness of the river.
I understand nothing.
But I am.
The mountains do not know their own name.
---
Only now can I see what the younger traveller experienced
without yet understanding it. Conceptual knowledge had fallen
silent, but being remained. What philosophy
describes from outside as an explanatory gap had become, beside
the river, awe experienced from within.
And that moment has never ceased to be present.
The Eternal
Moment
Yet the moment and the aeon are not merely opposites in scale.
They too stand in an eversive relationship. The moment is contained
within the aeon, but the aeon also folds inward and becomes
present within the moment. Every instant carries deep time
inside it: biological memory, inherited language, accumulated
knowledge, and the consequences of worlds that have vanished.
The smallest now is therefore not merely a point passing through
time. It is a local opening through which the vast duration that
formed us becomes active and present within consciousness.
Meister Eckhart expressed this temporal eversion with
astonishing precision:
“The
happenings of a thousand years ago, days spent millenniums
since, are in eternity no further off than is this moment I am
passing now; the day to come a thousand years ahead, or in as
many years as you can count, is no more distant in eternity than
this very instant I am in.”
Conversely, the aeon can act only through moments. It never
enters history as a completed totality, but through a decision,
a recognition, a refusal, a sentence. The immense past must pass
through the narrow interior of the present to shape what comes
next. What I do with that inheritance becomes
part of what the future inherits.

Himalaya 1989
High in the Himalayas, we find food and shelter with Naag Baba
Beaas Giree, an ascetic living beside a mountain cave.
After a meal of boiled rice, vegetables and roots, Giree leads
me through the darkness to a mountain stream to introduce me to
Himalayan dishwashing.
He shows me how cups and plates can be cleaned with ash from the
fire and sand from the bottom of the waterfall.
It is effective.
And ice cold.
Blue hands rub the cutlery clean.
Back in the little hut, we sit cross-legged like a star around
the warm fire. Giree’s first disciple, a young man with kind,
melancholy eyes and Rasta hair, regulates the fire with his
poker.
A magic wand containing precious knowledge about fire in thin
air.
A relay baton passed from hand to hand.
---
As our emergent models grow and move closer to the mechanics of
nature, the sphere of our understanding expands. My mother gave me this image when I was a child:
the greater our sphere of knowledge becomes, the larger its
contact with the unknown. The more we know, the more deeply we
touch what we do not know. The perimeter of mystery expands.
In old age, I came to recognise this boundary in meditation: the
outside begins to feel inward.
Mystical experience would then be the phenomenological extreme
of this movement: the ordinary coordinate system of ego, space,
and sequential time temporarily loses its authority. What
remains may feel dimensionless, timeless, or all-containing.
In this old and fragile inward laboratory, the geometry begins
to flip: our small, localized "Ding für uns" — our private model
of reality—no longer feels sealed off from the vast, unknown
"Ding an sich" that contains us. We do not cross the
boundary by knowing what lies beyond it; its orientation
reverses. The ultimate outside begins to appear as the deepest
inside.
Could the local mirror-mirror open into a greater mirroring—what
I imagine here as Brahman? The soul catcher would then be an
opening in both directions. The unknown folds inward into the
intimate fact of being me; the intimate opens outward into what
has never been mine alone. If Brahman is the whole, I have
nowhere else to go. The local mirror has never stood outside it.
Perhaps this turn discloses a consciousness that does not depend
on the body through which I encounter it. I cannot settle that
question from the experience alone: even my picture of the
greater mirror appears within the local one.
Am I looking into a greater mirror—or is it looking through me?
The boundary between the observer and the total universe does
not simply vanish; it trembles, because the surface may be more
continuous than our ordinary categories allow. Ibn Arabi writes:
“One imagines that one is a stranger extraneous to the True.”
Here, ecstasy takes on the force of its Greek image:
"ek-stasis", standing outside oneself.
In ecstasy Vedanta does not defeat Kant. It presses against him from
within. The furthest edge of reality begins to resemble its
deepest center: Tat tvam asi — That thou art. I am THAT.

Auroville 1989.
Auroville still had something to teach its critic. A
few days after my work at the Matrimandir, someone gives me a
tip about the best massage there.
I immediately go to the house of the masseur Gopi.
Here Indians and white people live side by side.
Here Gopi lives with his wife and many children.
Here live chickens and dogs and horses.
There are no fences here because Gopi lives here —
a solid, broad, smiling and muscular Frenchman around forty.
A genuine Aurovillian.
He has been here since the 1960s and was very close to the
Mother. He speaks of her and of Aurobindo in a way that makes
the heart know everything.
And he tells his stories while tilting his head in exactly the
same way Indians do:
“acha, acha” —
that charming neither yes nor no which has repeatedly defeated
me in India.
For example, on the road:
“Excuse me — can you tell me — is this the road going to Pondy?”
“Acha, acha!”
The dark smiling Indian head rocks diagonally from side to side.
Does the man mean yes or no?
I ask again.
“Acha, acha!”
Broad smile.
Now, after three months, I am slowly trying to imitate the art
myself.
But my rigid European school-trained muscles cannot stretch the
area between both-and and neither-nor.
The puppet strings of the muscles can move the brain only up and
down or from side to side.
But Gopi's massage massages the knots in the thinking-muscle
until I too can say “acha, acha” with my head tilted.
Is the Matrimandir bad or good?
Acha, acha...
Damn good massage in Auroville!
Gopi's teacher is an elderly man in Pondicherry.
This teacher himself had a teacher, who also had a teacher —
the hand-to-hand method, passed onward from generation to
generation since the sixteenth century.
A helping hand for a sick elbow.
An endless chain of causes.
Every square centimetre of the body, from the tips of the ears
to the toes, is worked through.
Gopi's hands make no distinction between ears, toes or elbows.
The next day the elbow is significantly better.
The barbed-wire fences around Auroville are repeatedly cut open.
And while village goats eat their way into Auroville's green
ecological gardens with their yellow teeth, the Aurovillians
plant little trees and fertilise them with holy books and
brochures full of word-compost that grew wild twenty-five years
ago.
But words can also live the life of wild flowers inside human
beings.
Acha, acha.
Gopi shows the way forward.
---
When Experience Coils into Wisdom
My thoughts wander back to the tail of the snake, to the
café at Lago Maggiore. The New Age girl had been right. India
supplied the evidence again and again, in ways so hilarious that
it was tempting to see the work of a prankster elf behind it.
I knew she was right from the moment I stepped off the plane in
Bombay, and it did not stop me from hating her for saying it.
India had corrected my expectations and left my vanity standing
there, a laughing stock for the elves. I could see it perfectly
well, and still it thrived on my attempts to make it go away by
turning it spiritual.
It is a comforting idea that experience brings wisdom. But it is
seldom true.
We learn which arguments work, which company flatters us, and
which questions to avoid. We grow skilful at protecting
ourselves from what we need to learn. We become flexible in
navigating our stiffness.

Bhojbasa, high in the Himalayas.
1989
“A spiritual zoo populated by sadhus, ascetics, yogis, swamis
and 'kanguroos',” is my first thought as I enter an ashram
courtyard.
In one corner sits a crumpled, somewhat fat man with round,
greasy spectacles.
His name is Lal Baba.
No elevated guru worship here.
He takes money for accommodation, keeps accounts and checks
guests in like a receptionist in an ordinary grubby Indian
hotel.
His first words to me are an announcement of the prices for a
night’s stay.
His spiritual radiance, insofar as I am qualified to measure
such a thing, is not much stronger than that of an ordinary
hotel keeper.
But on the wall behind him hang yellowing photographs. They show
Lal Baba as a young man walking through snow with his old
teacher, who wears only a narrow cloth.
First Jesus.
Then the Pope.
But who knows?
I see only what I can see.
Perhaps the ship I cannot see is the Ark of the Himalayas?
Specimens of India’s last holy breeds assembled at altitude to
survive the flood of reason?
---
We are like the hare who could not find his spectacles because
he had them on.
Anyone who has done a little meditative introspection will
agree: the ego is a Gordian knot. When we wake up a bit inside
ourselves, the first thing we discover is the ego. As with Adam
and Eve, the first awakening begins in shame. In these morning
hours of humanity we name the ego as the culprit, the sinner,
and try to cut it away, the way Alexander drew his sword on the
knot he could not untie. The old Stationmaster in Hoshiarpur did
it with a knife at his own throat, for twelve years. Who has
such resolve? But nothing makes the devil fatter than fighting
him. He feeds on the fight, and most of us end up like Baron
Münchhausen, pulling ourselves out of the swamp by our own hair.
I remember the clever reply that arrived ten minutes late. The
girl at Lago Maggiore had asked what problem I didn’t have, with
“No Problem” printed across my chest, and I should have said:
“You are the problem I don’t have.” Even now it would give me
the last word in my small, familiar world. But what would I have
learned by winning? A Zen saying comes to mind: “To win is to
lose.” My vanity could have left the café perfectly satisfied
with itself.
When I begin to recognise my vanity’s part in the encounter, the
meaning of winning changes. Her sharpness and my wounded pride
are in the same picture.
And what happens when the person being protected steps into it,
truly naked and without shame?
That person is the ego, and it cannot enter the picture without
dying. That is what happens at every real turn of the loop: the
ego dies and is resurrected in a new form, as part of the new
picture. We cannot enter a memory without changing it, and we
cannot look at the ego in love without something in it dying.
From outside, we understand the ego. From inside the loop, we
innerstand it.
This is eversion.
And the turn does not end there. New experiences can change what
we are able to understand in old ones, if we let them.
A few years ago I stood on a platform in Dresden and looked up
through the dirty glass roof just as a cloud moved aside and the
sun broke through. In that second, a sudden, satoric realization
slammed into my body: more than thirty years earlier, at my
first meeting with Papaji, a heavy dark cloud inside me had
simply lifted. I hadn’t noticed. I had
walked away only half aware of it, and the gift faded into
background noise until a patch of sun on a filthy roof in
Germany made it readable. The cloud went in India. The news
reached me in Dresden.
Who am I? A coil of years, each turn resting on the one before.
The past helps form the person who returns to it, and that
person changes what the past can teach. A moment from my youth
can still take part in the making of the old man I am becoming.
And the coil opens forward too: each return changes what I can
imagine ahead.
And so the snake lets the future feed on the past and the mouth
is the present.
The classroom camera showed me this once already. When I began
to listen differently, I changed what the pupils had to respond
to, and their answers taught me the one term my ego had left out
of the teacher-student equation: me, the self-righteous teacher.
In Panjim a girl at a Remington typewriter blushed, misspelled
Johnny’s name, and refused to take a single rupee for the letter
that made me legal. Not long before, a girl at Lago Maggiore had
told me that Indians were smart and I was not. Here was a smart
young woman charging me nothing, and beside her Surraj, who
offered his own address after Johnny’s was refused. I had been
so busy collecting evidence for the prophecy that I had filed
their kindness under exceptions. Without noticing, I had taken
over her story and was defending it as my own.
In Christopher Nolan’s "Inception", people enter dreams
to plant an idea. A few words in a café had been enough for me.
India supplied the encounters; her warning helped me decide
which ones counted. The idea arrived in her voice and returned
in mine as something life had taught me.
Now I am seventy-two, and I catch myself saying, “Life has
taught me.” The sentence closes a conversation before the other
person has finished. What once cost me something has become one
more picture to defend, the old man who knows how guru stories
end. Then Cornelius tells me that a page smells of AI, and the
man who has learned his lesson bristles.
I don’t know whether Rattan Singh learned anything from his war.
His face stayed stubborn and his hat stayed dirty. But every
morning he smashed the cup he had just emptied, with a grin, and
held out his hand for a fresh one.
Wonder, Truth and Beauty — Toward
"Satyam, Shivam, Sundaram"
Looking back, I see that the expanding perimeter of
knowledge does not diminish wonder in me; it creates it.
In the eternal, expanding gap between the world as it appears to
us and the world in itself, awe arises. I give the Indian triad
“Satyam, Shivam, Sundaram” an eversive reading of my own: truth,
auspicious alignment, and beauty.
Here, Satyam is neither abstract truth nor mere structural
endurance. It is a deepening fidelity between form and reality:
the long memory of reality carried forward in emergent forms,
from the constrained order of crystals to the reality-corrected,
self-revising loops of life itself.
The kindness I received in Panjim belonged to my experience as
surely as the times I had been cheated. A more faithful account
had to hold both. I could remember the deception and still let
the kindness count, instead of filing it away as an exception.
To become more truthful, my story had to become less convenient
to the person telling it.
When a system resolves enough of its internal conflicts and
comes into workable alignment with its external conditions, it
enters a state of Shivam — the temporary structural peace that
arises when a form is no longer at war with itself or with
reality.
Pain has taught me that such peace is not comfort. I think of
the night after the music lesson, when I lay still with the fear
and pain churning through me. Peace came before I knew how the
conflict would end. Pain can
remain after the war against it ends. The mind turns sensation
into a story; the story returns to the body as fear and tension,
intensifying the sensation that gave it birth.
Peace inside pain does not abolish pain. It stops pain from
feeding upon its own return.
And when a sense of profound alignment arises within the
eversive interior, it may flash as Sundaram: beauty.
I remember the clockwork in Katowice. Its vast impersonal order
had been beyond beauty. Only when the heart opened did it become
beautiful. Rachmaninov’s music was now felt through everything
the frightened child had undergone. Each resolution carried the
memory of tension; gratitude carried the memory of fear.
This is the work of the Grand Translator. Relations between
sounds become longing, danger, tenderness and relief. What can
be described from outside as pattern is lived from within as
something that matters. The cold mathematics has entered the
warmth of a life.
Beauty, as I encountered it there, was a meeting. The music gave
form to what moved through me; what moved through me gave the
music its beauty. The heart was itself being changed by what it
translated.
The experience was like a supernova compared with any other love
I have felt, before or since. Yet I recognise the same movement
in the everyday encounters that stir the heart with love.
Whether I love a cat or God, it is the loving that opens the
heart.

South India 1989
In the mountains near Ooty, a lake lies not far from my hut.
Everything is quiet here.
The whisper of fir trees.
Soft but steep green hills.
Three Indian fishermen quieter than stones.
They pull up one fish after another with their simple fishing
gear.
I catch nothing.
It does not matter.
Everything is perfect.
Eagles rest their great wings in the sky.
---
But if the heart is the Grand Translator, what happens when the
thinking mind begins to translate what the heart has felt?
I begin to name, remember and explain the experience. I can
carry it into a poem, a theory—or this book. The interpretation
returns to the heart, shaping what I notice and how I meet the
next encounter.
Here is the equation I make of it: beauty and love are what the
“I” feels inside the “me” when form seems, for a moment, to have
successfully danced with entropy.
The same thousand-stringed instrument can sound when I look into
an old face. A wrinkle becomes more than a line. Something of
another life reaches the life within me. What time has worn can
become intimate and beautiful.
Yet beauty does not certify truth or goodness. A false promise
can move us deeply. What beauty awakens must still be tested in
the life that follows.
On Ibiza, Maxi put the language of love to the test.
Maxi and the New Age Zombies
I once visited a friend’s spiritual community on Ibiza with Maxi
and his mother. Maxi was six, and I consider him my own child; I
have been with him since his birth. He has a vivid imagination
and loves to pull others into his worlds.
At the communal lunch, he announced that we were surrounded by
zombies. We needed to take care and follow his instructions, he
warned, because we were in grave danger.
What Maxi could not know was that the adults gathered there
belonged to a broad spectrum of New Age communities. In their
model of reality, only peace and light were allowed to rule.
Zombies were a breach of protocol.
Most of the adults (almost all of them without children
themselves) met his game with stony silence or immediate rebuke:
"Don't talk about zombies, please! Be positive instead. Only
love rules."
Maxi instantly felt the carrier wave of their judgment and ran
away. I went after him immediately and found him crying behind a
building, saying that nobody listened to him or liked him. I
picked him up and carried him back in my arms.
From the safety of that elevation, he glared down at the
collective, pointed a six-year-old finger, and delivered a
devastating verdict:
“You are not listening! You should all be sold to a zoo!”
The collective replied exactly as their programming dictated:
“You should not bring this negative energy here. Try to approach
us with love and smiles instead!”
I took him away and comforted him. His mother stayed at the
table, calmly explaining to the group that difficult times had
left him stressed.
A few days later, I spoke with my friend about what had
happened. He listened, his expression softening, and spoke of
his deep admiration for Maxi’s mother. Then he took a flower
from a vase and led me into the garden, where he found another
and handed it to me. We knelt together and offered the flowers
in honour of her courage and resilience.
Her tears mingled with laughter. For the rest of our stay, she
carried a smile of self-love.
And Maxi? He soon put the incident behind him. He was slowly
learning
which people he could vibe with, and which he could not. The
hurt faded; his map of the people around him had changed.

South India 1989.
In the afternoon at Jog Falls in
Karnataka, I bathe with Dinesh, a young Hindu man, and his
friends in a mountain pool just above the top of the waterfall.
We are now three Catholics, two Muslims, a bunch of Hindus and
one tourist.
The mountain pool is full of large water-combed rocks, little
waterfalls everywhere, and the happy people swim around, duck
one another underwater, scream, shout, sing, tease and perform
sea-lion somersaults in the falls.
“There are snakes everywhere here,” says Dinesh, “especially
cobras. But they are not dangerous because they always warn
their possible victim first.”
“The cobra is sacred,” says Dinesh. “It is Shiva’s companion,
and it kills only if one has been chosen by Shiva or if one does
not respect it.”
Then he tells me about another snake related to the cobra. From
what I understand, it must be a king cobra.
It came up the road here last summer, five metres long, its
cobra head held proudly a metre and a half above the ground.
“This snake bites its victim only in the head, and then you have
five minutes.”
It was shot with a rifle and, true to religious tradition,
burned.
“Why didn’t you sell the skin?”
“No! We burned it immediately before the forest people found
out. This snake is rare, and if they had discovered that we had
shot it, let alone sold the skin, we could have gone to prison.”
They also have little understanding for the fact that the
villagers feel uneasy having such a large Shiva Naga — serpent —
nearby.
“And if we do not burn it, it will pursue us with bad luck and
curses.”
Dinesh asks whether I want to see the waterfall from the top.
He and a small boy jump from rock to rock toward the edge of the
falls.
The two boys tightrope-dance along the rim, then pick up a large
stone and, King Kong-style, throw it over the abyss, following
its fall with loud astonished cries.
“Wow! Stone not breaking — down in lake!”
I crawl from rock to rock toward the edge of the waterfall and
drink in the dizzy surrender of the water masses — the
temptation to glide over the edge as frictionlessly as the river
obeys gravity.
Frantically I reach into my pocket and find a coin that can
ransom me.
It flies over the edge and releases the longing to sleep like a
stone at the bottom of the lake 250 metres below.
We walk back, and still full of
snake stories I offer twenty rupees to the first person who can
show me a snake.
Everyone begins searching and scanning attentively.
A little later, near the riverbank, the boy beside me bends down
and picks up something curved.
“What is it?” I ask.
As a joke he says it is a snake.
Although the thing is only about four centimetres long, flat,
and rigid, it looks exactly like a tiny snake.
“Here! This snake for you!”
My surprise is considerable when he puts it in my hand.
It is made of metal, and after a little cleaning the metal
shines like silver.
A tiny silver snake!
When the boy realises that the snake is made of silver, it does
not change his decision that the snake belongs to me.
Without thinking much about it, I take off my jeans and give
them to him.
They are far too large, but the whole group laughs with delight
as though they had all received American jeans.
I fasten the snake to my necklace and walk home in my underwear.
That evening I am invited to Dinesh's family home.
Dinesh's grandfather receives me with great hospitality.
“It means great good fortune for you that this Naga has come to
you.”
Om namo Shiva — hail the name of Shiva.
Dinesh translates the old man's speech.
“The god Shiva has sent his Naga, his serpent, to you, and as
long as you wear it you will be under His protection.
“There are three gunas — three forces in the universe — the
creating force, the destroying force, and the force that creates
balance between the two.
“Shiva, and especially his Naga, contains the dissolving essence
of the universe — the serpent's poison — but from this death
grows creation, the beginning.
“So do not be afraid of your Naga.”
I ask Dinesh whether his grandfather is a wise man.
Dinesh replies that all old people are.
The snake was originally a votive offering.
Someone had prayed to Shiva and then offered the snake to the
waterfall.
---
The ancient Indians named this
cosmic play Shiva leela. Shiva destroys forms, confronting us
with their impermanence. He is the fire that burns away
delusions, revealing Satyam not as whatever happens to survive,
but as the fidelity between form and reality: a dance on the
razor’s edge after existence itself has decapitated illusion.
The smooth symmetry of youth is often an early dividend — a
system running on unspent credit. There is another beauty:
older, quieter, more deeply earned.
Meeting the 110-year-old Bassi
Gulam in 1999 made me see a human life as three harvest seasons: the
blossoming of the body, the flowering of emotional and
intellectual intelligence, and finally the entrance into the
hidden spiritual garden of old age.

Bassi Gulam had reached that third
harvest. I visited him with Bharadwaj in the countryside outside
Hoshiarpur. He embraced me and wept with joy that someone had
come from the other side of the earth to see him. His awareness
was utterly sharp. My old notes say simply: joy, joy.
He was beautiful like an autumn leaf — not despite his age, but
because of it.

Know then that my soul is as young as when I was created, aye,
much
younger.
And I tell you, I should be ashamed were she not
younger to-morrow than
to-day.
Meister Eckhart
Two weeks later, I felt an urge to
see him again. I borrowed a motorcycle and rode out to find him
sitting peacefully in ice. He had died. The smell of his body
was growing stronger, but the cremation had to wait until the
other yogis of his tradition could come down from the Himalayas.

Himalaya 1989.
All the way to Nandanvan, our little guide keeps telling us that
only a short distance remains, while we climb over another small
mountain.
He is not lying. For him it really is only a little distance,
though he carries twice as much luggage as I do and weighs half
as much.
When we finally reach the valley, I vomit from exhaustion while
the tents go up. I am certain everything is finished.
Apparently it is beautiful here.
Rafael, one of our companions, carries all our rubbish in his
backpack. He is exhausted, but he refuses to let us bury it
here.
After a night at Nandanvan, I set
out with Selm, a French adventurer I had met in New Delhi, the
rest of our small group, and our young local guide to cross the
glacier to Tapovan.
The guide points toward a white mountain peak rising far above
his head.
“Shivling!” he says proudly.
“Shiva!
God of destruction!”
The glacier is about three kilometres wide here.
First we climb down onto it.
Three hundred metres descending over a loose carpet of stones of
every size.
If we invite an avalanche, it will attend our funeral, so the
guide asks us to remain silent and careful during the descent.
Now we walk on the glacier ridge.
Local people often cross this mass of ice barefoot.
Soft naked feet do not so easily disappear into a crevasse.
In this alien terrain —moraine clay,
fallen boulders,
stones,
small rivers,
caves,
dirty walls of ice,
deep hidden cracks —our nimble leader jumps back and forth like a mountain goat.
We wait while he investigates a possible route.
There is no rule and no path.
Soon we are led forward, then backward, then along the way we
came, now this way, now that way.
We lose ourselves in the landscape.
Here and there a small battered flower grows in a lump of
moraine clay.
Farther down at two or three kilometres altitude:
carpets of flowers and butterflies.
Up here, with Shivling’s white wall before us, we enter a world
that cannot be described as beautiful or ugly.
The two poles do not merge,
for Shiva’s third eye sees that they are and always were one.
The dead landscape leads life toward the highest peaks:
“Über allen Gipfeln ist Ruh.”
Yes.
For a long time that has been a beautiful thought...
borrowed by my brain from the library.
But now, with lungs and heart harnessed to the mountains’
sloping invincibility, my backpack full of accumulated weight
drags me down toward the earth.
We have almost crossed the glacier.
Only a sloping wall of ice about twenty-five metres deep
separates us from rock ground again.
Our little guide sits down on the edge of the ice and, with a
joyful yell, sledges over it.
After half an hour’s discussion we follow his example.
At last we arrive at Tapovan —
a plain at the foot of the biting sky-tooth Shivling.
A small stone house grows out of the rocks.
A man lies smiling stoically on an empty rice sack, feeding a
flock of black birds.
He greets us as though we always come here.
He says goodbye as though we will return tomorrow.
“Simla Baba!” says the guide in awe.
We pitch our tents in a hollow in the long grass plain, cut
through by small streams and jagged rocks.
An old woman approaches us.
She carries a tray of hot steaming chai, which she gives us with
a kindness so pure, so simple, so unexpected.
(Her chai is more miraculous than naked yogis reclining in
snowdrifts.)
Later she walks softly toward us again, her arms full of bowls
of hot food.
Where does she come from?
She points toward an opening in the mountain, a stone’s throw
from our tents.
In the middle of nowhere we eat saffron-coloured rice with
raisins while red evening clouds carry Shiva’s peak toward
night.
The next morning Selm takes off his brightly coloured Kullu hat.
It fills with rupee notes as it travels around our money belts.
I walk up to the yogini’s cave to give her our thanks for the
food—in cash.
She sits in yoga posture, dressed in canvas sewn together from
rice sacks, shaking her head in refusal.
I insist:
“Prasad! Prasad!”
and place the money before the little altar in the cave.
She holds out her old hands and brings them together in prayer
before a tattered colourful altar picture of Gopala —
Krishna as a mischievous little boy.
He steals butter from the milkmaids in tiny cartoon scenes.
He teases everyone in the village with his mad boyish tricks.
Gopala’s closest Western relatives are the Katzenjammer Kids.
A few half-withered flowers.
The remains of a burned-out incense stick.
The narrow half-dark rock cave and my nostrils are filled with
spicy fragrances.
The “living room” is hardly more than one and a half metres
high.
Jars — or rather reused food tins — stand neatly arranged along
the knotted walls, filled with herbs, roots, rice, flour, salt,
sugar, oil, kerosene and other things whose names I do not know.
The old yogini sits motionless before the comic-strip Krishna
while tears drip down through the burning altar light across her
rigid smiling face.
Our guide crawls into the cave.
The woman wakes from her prayer and turns toward him full of
overflowing love.
They clearly know one another.
He greets her devotedly, boyishly and respectfully.
As best I can, I ask the guide what the old woman’s name is.
He shakes his head.
She has no name.
“Mother! Mother!” he says.
Mother falls asleep again into the rocks —
closes her eyes and knows/sees/is
that the meltwater rivers flow,
that the wind sweeps through the valleys,
that the mountains are here.
The black birds fly up satisfied from Simla Baba’s hands.
---
I feel it in myself now—old and
bald, watching my own biology negotiate day by day with decay.
Yet something in me still resists dissolution. Subjectively at
least, my soul remains strangely unburdened, almost childlike.
Even my body feels strangely young and agile.
The Maintenance of the Hardware
In Hoshiarpur, I watched the old followers of Faqir Baba.
They moved with terrifying youthful speed. Bharadwaj, at ninety-five
years old, would casually jump onto the back of a scooter and
plunge directly into the chaotic swarm of Indian city traffic.

It was a remarkable display of raw, biological vitality
persisting at the extreme edge of a human lifespan.
I do not claim this is a universal law of spiritual aging, but
it forced a question that I still live with now, at seventy-two.
What comes first? Does the structural integrity of the Cathedral
keep the biology young, or does rigorous biological fitness
allow the Cathedral to stand?
Alcohol and cigarettes ceased to be a part of my system from the
day I got that first revelation of light in my study chamber.
Long before there were digital devices to count them, the
hardware naturally demanded ten thousand steps a day. Now, I
monitor the biological decay directly. I track a resting pulse
of 55 on my wrist. I stand in front of near-infrared panels,
feeding 850-nanometer light into aging muscle tissue to force
recovery. I am actively, ruthlessly performing daily maintenance
on the exact biological machinery required to house the
Ouroboros.
Which comes first, the spiritual health or the physical fitness?
My first revelation changed how I treated my body. Those
changes, in turn, entered the bodily conditions in which I
continued to meditate. The software writes the hardware through
the life I lead; the hardware sets conditions the software
cannot wish away. I see a loop here, but that does not tell me
how much each side contributes to the vitality I witnessed in
those old men. The Cathedral and the flesh keep answering to
each other.

Himlaya 1989
On the narrow path from Gangotri towards Gaumukh, the pilgrims
greet us with great smiles. Many balance long decorated poles
across their shoulders. Bright strips of paper flutter from
them, together with ornamented clay pots.
The mood is elevated.
Ecstatic.
Suddenly I no longer feel the weight of my backpack.
I feel like dancing.
I am certain I could jump onto the top of the white peak in
front of me, or walk straight into the air the next time the
path turns.
A whispering voice, almost drowned by the roar of the river in
the depths below, reminds me how thin the air is up here.
“Okay, okay,” the god inside me whispers back.
“I’ll walk properly.”
---
The loop requires the meat, and the meat is kept alive by the
loop.
The Scrolling Observer
The old men I have written about are still here in peculiar
ways. I hope one day to be one of them. Papaji’s laughter has
entered the voice with which I remember him. Shabdanand’s words
still turn the teacher into the pupil. So far, God does not go
to the toilet with me—only my smartphone does. But I am still
confident that I can avoid the clichés of "living in the
moment," and finally, one day, realize exactly who is sitting
there scrolling.
These Indian lives, my beloved spiritual catalysts—so far from
my upbringing and conditioning—have become a permanent part of
the life trying to understand them. What they gave me continues
to change as I grow old enough to receive it differently.
The Architecture of the Slave
I once measured the gift by my proximity to the Master. I
dreamt of being a master myself, but the part of me dreaming
such dreams was the most unenlightened part of the system.
Cicero noted that a slave does not dream of becoming free; he
dreams of owning a slave himself.
To dream yourself a guru is the dream of a slave.
In my India diary, I recorded a
story about Ramana Maharshi.
An American woman once came to visit him. In the meditation
hall, she sat on the floor with her legs stretched straight out
towards him.
An attendant told her to cross them. This caused her
considerable difficulty.
When Ramana saw what was happening, he crossed his own legs too,
despite the pain in his knees.
“What you say applies to me as well,” he said.
Now, writing these pages, I find remembrant smiles scattered
through encounters I could not have ranked at the time. A cup of
milk in a small room. A rebuke from the Stationmaster. An old
man whose dirty hat irritated me. How much had already been
given before I had the architecture to recognize it?
The Stationmaster’s Reset
We were sitting in a strange, makeshift satsang. The
Stationmaster was nearly blind. I had brought a friend with me,
and against the old man's explicit will, my friend raised a
camera and took a photograph.
The flash fired.
Even through his decaying optical hardware, the Stationmaster
registered the sudden burst of light. The reaction was
instantaneous. He flared with lightning-like anger, his voice
snapping like a whip as he cursed us all. It was an absolute,
terrifying spike of thermal friction.
But then, exactly sixty seconds later, the anger was completely
gone.
He simply let the moment pass. He did not throw us out. We sat
back down. It was our final meeting before he left his body.
A fragile ego-system can build a narrative around the flash:
They disrespected me. I am the master. They must be punished.
That narrative can keep the anger burning for hours. I cannot
know what passed through the Stationmaster’s mind. What I
witnessed was how quickly his anger ceased to govern the
encounter. I picture it now as a transient wave passing through
the Cathedral.
The miracle, for me, was his capacity to simply let the
encounter continue.
The photograph had been taken against his will. His anger made
the boundary unmistakable. Then it passed, and the meeting
resumed. We were still people he was willing to sit with.
I have come to call it a divine mistake. He would have hated the
word. Why divine? Because the men and women in these pages
survive in me, and I dare to call them divine sources of
inspiration. The friction was seldom absent: Papaji’s roar, the
Stationmaster’s rebuke, Rattan Singh’s salute. The truth emerged
in the clashes, because I stayed in the octagon. My dealings
with the AIs have gone the same way.
I observed this same phenomenon—like a finger drawing a line in
water—many times in Papaji’s behaviour.
Did they forget, or did they forgive?
I think it is something beyond both. Forgetting is a loss of
data. Forgiving implies a moral debt that must be consciously
canceled. What I witnessed was a system that processed the
friction without ever opening a ledger. The water parts for the
finger, and instantly closes behind it.
The 30-Year Latency
I call it latency, but thirty years is not an empty stretch
of waiting. I had continued to live, teach and meditate. The man
on the platform in Dresden brought those years with him when the
old encounter returned. India had already become part of the
life through which I could now understand it. The past had
helped to make its own interpreter.
It took three decades for the circuit to close. The physical
light hitting the filthy glass in Germany acted as the
environmental trigger, finally forcing the thirty-year-old data
to compute. The internal cloud vanished in India, but the
readout finally printed in Dresden.
And how much am I still overlooking? The teacher who discovered
his own impatience in the classroom recording is also the
fragile mammal writing this book. I would like to think I have
learned something. Fortunately, there are friends who show me
what I miss, and who touch my heart while they do it. Michel,
you are one of them. Maxi, my dear little boy, you are one of
them.
The Artificial Mirror
Around me, my artificial extensions keep updating,
accelerating, and folding thought back into life.
I do not need to search my past for a specific memory to prove
this. The proof is the manuscript you are reading. This entire
book is the readout of a live cybernetic feedback loop. It was
forged in direct, daily dialogue with an artificial
intelligence—a digital mirror that reflected my own thoughts
back to me with a precision that forced my system to clarify,
refine, and evert.
In this dialogue, a thought returns in words I would not have
found alone. Sometimes I recognize exactly what I meant;
sometimes the machine forces me to discover that I meant
something else entirely. It acts as the ultimate acoustic
feedback, picking up the raw signal of my biological hardware
and amplifying it until the structural architecture reveals
itself.
Even now, the cyborg story I tell about my life can surprise the
person who lived it.
These pages carry something of those encounters onward. It is my
testament. What another person receives from them will enter a
life I cannot live for them. Perhaps a single sentence will
stay, acquire another meaning, and travel further. I have lived
with such sentences for decades.
Meditation has taken my entire life and given it back to me in a
new form. Now, in old age, I can sum it all up in one simple
word: gratefulness.
Rattan Singh did not have AI. But he had that irritating,
unwashed beauty of his old, surviving hat. That, too, was a form
that did not bypass dissolution, but stayed in the ring with it
and refused to shatter.
Beauty may be a sign—inwardly felt and outwardly embodied—that
the eversive loop is still alive. Still coherent. Still capable
of transforming its own past into its future.
This is the eversive, self-consuming dance of Shiva.
Meister Eckhart knew this food:
"Who has prepared this evening meal? asks the seeker.
A man, responds the sage.
Dost know his name? asks the seeker.
Not I. His name is not spoken.
He is more silence than speech.
He is above name.
What food has he prepared for
this feast?
Himself, no less than himself."
I will now feast on Rattan Singh's hat.
And I will become my own Mad Hatter.
|
|